Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Hello, I want to ask why this post that I put up was denied (https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/4871850)

I felt adding some more for Ghost Ogre and Ghost reaper would be a nice addition, and I felt this post was of proper quality, considering this is the artist's post from Pixiv. Sometimes while I do believe that complex and styling art is good, sometimes the appreciation comes from the picture and the viewer, since the artist was highlighting overlaying both characters together to make a new monster (A ygo mechanic). I re-read the rules, and found the art was not poorly drawn, it wasn't downscaled since this was the artist's pixiv upload, or a low effort meme or upload. I'm just confused on why it was denied since I thought it was of proper quality.

The same can apply here (https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/4871870) since again, I felt that these art does portray very high quality of the character's appearance and clothing.

BranOtaku said:

I'm just confused on why it was denied since I thought it was of proper quality.

The first is very blocky and perhaps not poorly drawn, but not exactly well or passably drawn either. It falls under the category of low-, or at least mid-but-poor-execution-, effort meme in my eyes.

The second has bad anatomy all around. Especially the blonde.

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/4872662

Why was this deleted?

Obscurereference said:

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/4872662

Why was this deleted?

Not enough high quality.

Naikun said:

Not enough high quality.

Yes, but what makes it not high quality?

Naikun, this was said a few pages ago. forum #197848

nonamethanks said:

Non-approvers shouldn't try to give advice in this thread, otherwise users end up even more confused than before, as was the case here.

Obscurereference said:

post #4872662 - Why was this deleted?

Left girl’s face is kinda strange; not digging the blur effect along the edges (it’s not depth of field).

Excuse me, but some time ago I uploaded a piece of artwork of Yuria Kanou (from Star Plus One!) and no one seemed to approve it. I guess I was just wondering why. As far as I could tell, there was nothing explicit about it.

Here's the link to it, by the way. https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/4792022?q=kanou_yuria+status%3Adeleted

The image is fine so far, but I try to avoid approving images with bad and unknown sources. The source links doesn't redirect to where the image is from, just to the image itself.
I guess that other approvers also try to avoid approving such bad sources.

Guaro said:

The image is fine so far, but I try to avoid approving images with bad and unknown sources. The source links doesn't redirect to where the image is from, just to the image itself.
I guess that other approvers also try to avoid approving such bad sources.

Oh, is that all? Well, could I re-upload it with the proper link? It's so weird, I could have sworn I linked the official Star Plus One website...

riselove said:

Oh, is that all? Well, could I re-upload it with the proper link? It's so weird, I could have sworn I linked the official Star Plus One website...

No, you should be able to just edit the post to add the correct source. No need to reupload.

@riselove said:

Oh, is that all? Well, could I re-upload it with the proper link? It's so weird, I could have sworn I linked the official Star Plus One website...

If the image is identical in quality, simply change the source link; if the original source is better or the existing upload is an upscale, than upload it the original source.

OK. I changed the source link. Do you all just check it from there to see if it's approvable?

@e?

Remember this

nonamethanks said:

Non-approvers shouldn't try to give advice in this thread, otherwise users end up even more confused than before, as was the case here.

since the image is over a month old, you can try appealing it. Approver responses are cleared after a month, so it'll be visible to all approvers.

Naikun said:

@e?

Remember this

By advice, I'm pretty sure he meant giving advice on why a post wasn't approved in terms of the art itself, and not advice on site practices, such as what to do to fix the source of an already existing post that otherwise would've likely been approved.

Wait, so I DO need to reupload everything, or...?

riselove said:

Wait, so I DO need to reupload everything, or...?

Just keep it deleted. By the way you should upload higher quality artworks so approvers will likely to approve.

riselove said:

Wait, so I DO need to reupload everything, or...?

No, you can use the “Appeal” link in the bottom left of the post page.

OK, I clicked the Appeal link, but is it true that it cost 3 uploads to do so? Like, is that if it DOESN'T get approved on the second try?