Donmai

Deletion request thread

Posted under General

glasnost said:
post #875592

Silly edit.

It's so stupidly funny though that I decided to stretch the rules a bit. And since it got reapproved (before I even knew it was flagged) by none other than the Great Opponent of Fun™, Fencedude himself, I consider the matter settled.

I'll flag them right now. Joke photoshops and tiny dithered-to-hell screencaps don't get a free pass just because a series is popular at the moment.

EDIT: Looks through mahou_shoujo_madoka_magica ~screencap ~cap ~gif.

This is goddamn ridiculous. Posting what looks like every key point in the episode in low quality gif format is entirely unnecessary. If you want to see this episode then just fucking download it.

Updated

Oh yes, I've never understood the practice of making lowres gif straight out of episode footage and posting that. These should be purged. I also agree with not accepting photoshops in principle, but there are always exceptions -- the moustache one I consider funny and witty enough to stand on its own, and in this case the fact it's a shopped cap fades to nothing more than a choice of medium, much like say collage (in the traditional, paper-based sense).

tl;dr: I wouldn't accept Madoka shops just because they're Madoka, but I wouldn't kill good images either just because they happen to be Madoka shops.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 60