Most of those, I'd say yeah, go ahead and delete them. I do disagree with the method of batch nomination though for the reasons I stated above.
Yeah, start with the worst and most obvious posts, but you're not going to be able to draw a line between what's obvious and what's not, so it makes sense to require a reason for everything. After all, these are posts that have been approved by someone with privileges for some reason. I suppose pointing out the score could be a sufficent reason though.
post #464450 : I'd sort of vote to keep. I don't really like it, but the creepy realism actually is the whole point, and the artist's modus operandi. The artist does have talent, and it's not really that much worse than post #619275 which has a relatively high score, and I have sort of become to like.
post #458018 and post #458018 : I don't like these, but Hazuki and Slash do, and it's not worth fighting over anymore. They are voted lower than their quality merits due to the publicity they've gotten. The other stuff on the first page of order:score_asc is generally much worse. I'm ambivalent about keeping them at this point. They have also been thoroughly discussed and arguments on both sides made, so they've basically gone through the equivalent of this thread already anyway.
Updated