Donmai

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

post #2088278
Is it really that bad that it had to be deleted twice, the second time after it was already reapproved? Because the quality is the same as the artist's works at the time and if that's the case, why not just delete all of the artist's other early works as well? Also, it being part of a series should help a little in it's defense, no?

user_267184 said:

post #702290

this comic. And everything by the artist. Must know what's wrong with that.

A lot of approvers don't tend to approve the sketchier pixelated "old oekaki" style that artist uses. I tend to be ok with it though (but I often pass on comics).

Sproq981 said:

Okay, I was sure post #4790074 was going to be a keeper. What was wrong with that one? Weird posing shenanigans?

Her torso looks really strange. The area between her waist(?) and hips seems to be too long. The pose isn’t doing it any favors in that regard.

kittey said:

Her torso looks really strange. The area between her waist(?) and hips seems to be too long. The pose isn’t doing it any favors in that regard.

I mean, I kinda interpreted it as Allenby performing a diving kick of sorts? Like a variation of the Super Inazuma Kick from Gunbuster, but with 20% more panache/style? Which is remarkable because the Super Inazuma Kick is already all panache/style, so this kick would be like 120% panache/style. And Gunbuster and G Gundam are somewhere among the best examples of Super Robot animes in my opinion, so that's why I thought this piece was made competently enough.