f1d31 said:
I would like feedback on what would be wrong with this art to be deleted: post #4604154
I like it a lot, I went and fav'd it
Posted under General
f1d31 said:
I would like feedback on what would be wrong with this art to be deleted: post #4604154
I like it a lot, I went and fav'd it
Why do people seem to hate Tea Texiamato's work?
Runty said:
Why do people seem to hate Tea Texiamato's work?
74 % approval rate isn’t what I would call “hate”.
To answer your question: too many signs of mediocre art. Subpar hands, flawed anatomy/perspective, balloon boobs… For example, the hand in post #4606433 is just bad, which is especially annoying because the spread cleavage window is pretty much the focus of the image.
cythieus said:
I like it a lot, I went and fav'd it
yeah, so it would be great if we had some feedback explaining a little bit why it was deleted.
Runty said:
Why do people seem to hate Tea Texiamato's work?
It comes off less as stylized and more as lazy.
CormacM said:
It's pretty good overall, but the face ruins it. It's somehow flat? and kind of weirdly angled? If the artist revised the face it would probably be uploadable.
Really? I thought the face looked fine enough. But since you mention it, maybe the nose could have been more defined? Wish I could reach out to the artist, but Japanese isn't my first language and I don't even know if they'd reach back...
Okay, what's wrong with this one?
Boobs too hard to believe? Bad leg position? Reona is actually that busty in the anime.
f1d31 said:
yeah, so it would be great if we had some feedback explaining a little bit why it was deleted.
Overall just a little amateurish. To nitpick: the right hand looks like a baby's hand, the right foot and leg connect at a slightly uncomfortable angle, and the left hand, which should be a focal point for the whole image, is lacking in detail and kind of awkward. Images which are drawn in a more realistic style are going to be held to higher standards of realism.
post #4612145
post #4612168
post #4612175
I just wondering is "bad quality" here mean the amateur coloring? I think it's better than the previous approved post by the same artist (Natori Sana ones)
post #4278159
Might as well ask this one
dikkun11037 said:
post #4612145 post #4612168 post #4612175
I just wondering is "bad quality" here mean the amateur coloring?
Mediocre hands and faces too.
post #4278159 Might as well ask this one
Too unremarkable for my tastes.
post #4609753 Lately I've been hoping that my eye for catching anatomical/drawing errors has been improving without character bias or my own post bias. But I'm not sure I deserved a deletion against me for this one. Am I missing something?
ricroll said:
post #4609753 Lately I've been hoping that my eye for catching anatomical/drawing errors has been improving without character bias or my own post bias. But I'm not sure I deserved a deletion against me for this one. Am I missing something?
'Flat' face, odd-looking fingers, very weird waist, overall horizontally-squashed/vertically-stretched body.
CormacM said:
It's pretty good overall, but the face ruins it. It's somehow flat? and kind of weirdly angled? If the artist revised the face it would probably be uploadable.
I mean, I thought the face looked fine, but now that you mention it, maybe it could've been defined better? I'd contact the artist, but they use Pixiv and they probably moved on anyway...
Anyway, post #4614837 got deleted yesterday, which is a great shame because Lin You is a great character in Dragalia Lost and a lot of them don't get fan art. Or at least really good ones. (Actually, you could apply this to virtually all the characters in DL...) Any ideas why this got booted? Maybe it's too plain-looking?
Sproq981 said:
I mean, I thought the face looked fine, but now that you mention it, maybe it could've been defined better? I'd contact the artist, but they use Pixiv and they probably moved on anyway...
Anyway, post #4614837 got deleted yesterday, which is a great shame because Lin You is a great character in Dragalia Lost and a lot of them don't get fan art. Or at least really good ones. (Actually, you could apply this to virtually all the characters in DL...) Any ideas why this got booted? Maybe it's too plain-looking?
Left hand is weird.
Though overall looks kinda okayish, I guess. But it doesn't really stand out either (other than the hand, for the wrong reasons).
NNescio said:
Left hand is weird.
Though overall looks kinda okayish, I guess. But it doesn't really stand out either (other than the hand, for the wrong reasons).
Wait, really? I'm actually kinda surprised because I honestly can't see how the left hand is weird. Like, it needs to show the thumb to be less weird?
(Man, Dragalia Lost needs more love in the fan art department...)
what exactly is wrong with these
post #4610704
post #4614124
post #4524996
post #4524998
post #4614504?
among us cannot be equated with anime style. For me, some of the other posts (post #4579732, post #4569660, post #4582334, etc) are also not worthy of approval.