There have been multiple posts by this artist approved before and the quality meets the standards set by other posts as well.
and
this is first art of trihexa from dxd
Posted under General
There have been multiple posts by this artist approved before and the quality meets the standards set by other posts as well.
and
this is first art of trihexa from dxd
Sproq981 said:
Horribly late response, but if at any point, I made a point that an image that's part of a series shouldn't be deleted, then I'm sorry. I have to remind myself that.
Anyway, several (not all, but an awful lot) pics I've been uploading kinda got deleted and I'm rather stumped as to why.
post #5694141
1) I don't know why this got deleted, because someone uploaded the Pixiv version of this, it looks the same as this, and that got approved, but not this one. Like, it couldn't even be kept as child post?post #5682768
2) I guess this one just wasn't that good to look at?post #5687236 and post #5687243
3) I came to really like this artist, but I guess their style was just too sketchy?post #5699347
4) I take it this one had weird proportions or something? I'm kind of a sucker for Mari, so I kinda pounced on uploading it ASAP.post #5700121
5) I guess this one looked pretty half-baked at best? (I guess a little part of me is bitter that neither Captain Earth nor the character Akari Yomatsuri didn't exactly set the world on fire, so I went and posted this one because it was from an established artist because it wasn't there already. Sorry.)post #5707657
6) I guess this one had weird proportions too?post #5713465 and post #5713470
7) These two I don't get, because they look super top-notch. Probably got buried in the queue or something?post #5714375
8) This one I don't get either, because it looks mighty exquisite.post #5714503
9) This one I was disappointed that it got nixed, because it looked crisp and was directly an inspiration for post #5570379. Maybe the breasts are too big? (Yes, I know official art does not get an easy pass because it's "official".)
1) You got 1upped. It is an unfortunate thing that I am certain we'd have a solution for had a bunch of other site stuff happened. I'm sorry to say that it is largely unavoidable.
2) The way it's shaded makes her look like The Thing.
3) At least those two are.
4) Yes, plus bad foreshortening makes the legs look all kinds of wrong.
5) Yes
6) Partially yes. It edges into the comic's original style a bit and ends up giving her a weird neck.
7) Got a bit of big torso-big-head-awkward arms going, plus the back hand is a bit gangly and her waist si awkwardly narrow. Not any individual mistake, but a combination of questionable ones.
8) Western characters, especially ones like Chel who are mostly used for porn and lewds, tend to get overlooked. It's fair to admit approver bias there. I'd recommend appealing ones like that before bringing them up in here.
9) What you call crisp I call lacking detailed and flat.
Overall:
Try not to let personal bias get in the way of paying attention to the art. I always say to fap before you upload. While fapping isn't entirely applicable to you, the sentiment of clearing your head holds true. It's like the saying of not going shopping while you're hungry.
animeboy12 said:
The popped hip is a bit much, as much as I would love to approve more Hex.
Updated
Veradux said:
Let's go in order:
Bad legs
3d, especially 3d porn, is held to much higher standards. Especially when the models are openly taken from another person.
Rough overall
Western-style art is similarly scrutinized or ignored, doesn't help that it's not the artist's best work
Same as the 2nd
It's surprisingly flat and empty for official art
Questionable spine twist
The lack of an artist and being official art probably gave people pause. Official art isn't a free pass and can be hard to source properly.
Weak linwork and flat shading
Thank you for the response, I was wondering why all those posts got deleted, now I can avoid uploading those kind of posts.
Although, post #5154194 looks really good to me, I have seen much worse posts being approved, I guess that post got bad luck, well, I will keep uploading posts from this series.
Thanks again.
Veradux said:
1) You got 1upped. It is an unfortunate thing that I am certain we'd have a solution for had a bunch of other site stuff happened. I'm sorry to say that it is largely unavoidable.
2) The way it's shaded makes her look like The Thing.
3) At least those two are.
4) Yes, plus bad foreshortening makes the legs look all kinds of wrong.
5) Yes
6) Partially yes. It edges into the comic's original style a bit and ends up giving her a weird neck.
7) Got a bit of big torso-big-head-awkward arms going, plus the back hand is a bit gangly and her waist si awkwardly narrow. Not any individual mistake, but a combination of questionable ones.
8) Western characters, especially ones like Chel who are mostly used for porn and lewds, tend to get overlooked. It's fair to admit approver bias there. I'd recommend appealing ones like that before bringing them up in here.
9) What you call crisp I call lacking detailed and flat.
Overall:
Try not to let personal bias get in the way of paying attention to the art. I always say to fap before you upload. While fapping isn't entirely applicable to you, the sentiment of clearing your head holds true. It's like the saying of not going shopping while you're hungry.The popped hip is a bit much, as much as I would love to approve more Hex.
Thanks for the response. Side note: I actually heard of that saying about not shopping when you're hungry. And appealing posts like post #5714375 before complaining about them? That never occurred to me. I thought I had to ideally wait like a month or so to do that. I'll think on that next time it happens.
And thanks for undeleting post #5723676 and post #5725153. Means a lot since Yomi is a recent favorite of mine. The artist has more variants like this, but yeah, fap before uploading from now on.
Thanks again.
Sproq981 said:
And appealing posts like post #5714375 before complaining about them? That never occurred to me. I thought I had to ideally wait like a month or so to do that. I'll think on that next time it happens.
This used to be true until recently, now disapprovals are purged as soon as the post enters the modqueue again.
Why were these deleted...
post #5737882
post #5737897
Need some more information on this one post #5737762
I want to upload more but to avoid deletion I want to understand the reasons why a certain art may not get approved.
Was it the lazily drawn stuffed toy?
Or Nel's pelvic region drawn in weird shape?
Couldn't be her hair? could it?
or is it the thighs? (on second thought I shouldn't have uploaded it but I want to make sure)
I saw that 10 approvers saw it and they all might have different reasons but to avoid deletion in future I'd like to make sure what to not upload. Thank you in advance.
I would like feedback on
post #5726662
post #5738086
I'm new to posting and I was wondering why both my uploads were removed.
post #5734296
post #5734284
Is it a problem with the artworks themselves or did mess something up when I was posting them?
Bartle said:
I'm new to posting and I was wondering why both my uploads were removed.
post #5734296
post #5734284
Is it a problem with the artworks themselves or did mess something up when I was posting them?
A tip I can give you for further uploads is to only upload the better version, as one of them is a redrawn version of the other image and has way better quality. I cannot say much of why it wasn't approved, but you should try and appeal later on, so a new set of approvers can evaluate it again.
Obi-Wan said:
A tip I can give you for further uploads is to only upload the better version, as one of them is a redrawn version of the other image and has way better quality. I cannot say much of why it wasn't approved, but you should try and appeal after a month has passed, so a new set of approvers can evaluate it again.
Disapprovals are deleted when a post re-enters the queue now (appeal or flag) so there's no longer a need to wait a month.
And why was this removed?
post #5737441
Also this one post #5743488
post #5745864
post #5745858
post #5737762
Please tell me what the problem is here.
skywalkerred said:
Why were these deleted...
post #5737882
Very messy. Cute, but barely more than a colored sketch.
phositive said:
Need some more information on this one post #5737762
I want to upload more but to avoid deletion I want to understand the reasons why a certain art may not get approved.
Was it the lazily drawn stuffed toy?
Or Nel's pelvic region drawn in weird shape?
Couldn't be her hair? could it?
or is it the thighs? (on second thought I shouldn't have uploaded it but I want to make sure)
I saw that 10 approvers saw it and they all might have different reasons but to avoid deletion in future I'd like to make sure what to not upload. Thank you in advance.
Aside from Kon being a background element, you've identified a fair amount of the issues. Her anatomy is awful all around. Look at something other than the boobs and you'll see terrible hips and legs, a bad neck, and gangly arms.
wizardmagican said:
I would like feedback on
post #5726662
post #5738086
Bad anatomy on both of them. Those hips are awful.
skywalkerred said:
And why was this removed?
post #5737441
Also this one post #5743488
A shaky phone recording and a Rick Astley fake-out isn't great. I think if it wasn't a phone recording it could've eked by.
The second is just messy and underdone.
phositive said:
post #5745864
post #5745858
post #5737762Please tell me what the problem is here.
Bad anatomy on all of them. I think you need to zip up your pants and tighten your belt before uploading.
Pizzastoners said:
The flat shading and color filter don't help, but the main issue is that the focal point - the vagina and hand - are drawn worse and with less shading than the rest of the pic. A surprising inversion of the typical "drew the x first".
user_945637 said:
Thank you for your feedback but that was uncalled for. Not only it is rude but also hypocritical.
Posts with exaggerated features have less chances of getting approved, so there's not much that can be done. I know it's not prohibited per se, and you may find sometimes some similar content that was approved, but it definitely makes it harder to get an initial thumbs up. You can look up for borderline content on help:upload_rules to have a better idea of this.