Donmai

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

Because they're duplicates. Duplicates don't often get approved. If you see them getting approved it's either because the approver didn't notice or was horny and didn't care, or it wasn't actually approved and was uploaded by someone whose posts are automatically marked as active.

Bionicman76 said:

The non-colorized version got accepted. https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5672235?q=parent%3A5672235

It got flagged and deleted.

sh9248 said:

Can I get some feedback on post #5135882 ?
Are the proportions too exaggerated?

Partially. The exaggeration causes her to look like she's got a torso stretched and widened like that one Captain America meme.

mahalnwamazing said:

It has been reviewed by 9 approvers. 9 did not like the post enough to approve it.
Where is this picture wrong?
post #5670731

Generally poor all around. Weak shading, weak anatomy, bad fluid physics, a tiny, abrupt knee, the condoms look like they're floating.

NPEE2003 said:

Is there something wrong with these pictures?
post #5675485
post #5675475
post #5675463
post #5675462
post #5675460
post #5675373
post #5675364
post #5675339
post #5601982 (I didn't upload but uploader by other user, But I appeal this post and later 1 week it's rejected)

Same as with a lot of this artist's deleted image:
They're stretched like taffy and overly flexible and oddly boney/thin. Distended shoulders, bad hands, and legs twisting and pointing in awkward directions.

Foolboy234 said:

Could I get some feedback for these post:
post #5668371

The cheap cutout animation ruined it.

Pizzastoners said:

post #5678354 post #5678363
post #5686317 post #5686326

The artist appears to struggle with side profile faces. They're all either meme-worthy wide or squished.

Bionicman76 said:

post #5678770 post #5678853 post #5678922 post #5678939 post #5678958

The first two definitely fall into borderline content. Breasts that wild are difficult to approve, especially when the lactation part is kinda poorly drawn.

The rest are all simply just rough, almost sketches. Lotta "drew boobs, phoned in the rest". The first, while creative, is a bit "00s seedy porn site" in a bad way.

jay19 said:

Just curious about these recent deletions

post #5675883

He just doesn't look quite right. Plus an odd torso twist that I'm not certain is supposed to be a torso twist? The fact that I can't tell is a bad sign.

Legocity264 said:

What exactly is wrong with these posts? Extensively tagged, and no immediately obvious disqualifying factors like bad proportions or bad perspective.

post #5366195

post #5366170 (variant 1)
post #5366173 (variant 2)
post #5366177 (variant 3)

Also I hate how when I ask in the appeal message what is wrong, I never get any actual feedback and they just say "check this thread if you want feedback." Like FFS, just say something constructive, even if it's just "I don't like your username" or some nonsense.

They're all very rough in the non-boob anatomy, especially the faces. Shading is really weak, as well. Halfway between smear shading and normal shadowing. I know they're all approved now, but watch for details like that to avoid this thread entirely.

punished_K said:

post #5687323

Armpit posts are vulnerable to questionable anatomy. This one got hit with that in the arm and armpit. Plus they drew the armpit first and phoned in the rest of the arm.

Lesia said:

post #5688778 I need feedback please

You got 1upped. An unfortunate thing.

skywalkerred said:

Why was post #5695483 deleted...?
and post #5695887, whats up with it?

Comics have a harder time in the queue than most things, doubly so when they're greyscale. Combo that with the generally unimpressive use of that greyscale, little to no shading, and how both of them are just generally weak linework and you've got a deletion.

Hi, recently, my posts are not being approved, I haven't had too many before. Some months ago, my posts weren't deleted that much.

I am wondering if something changed in the last months, but I have found no changes.

So, what are the reasons these posts are being deleted? I already appealed, but it was also rejected.

post #5689226
post #5670097
post #5670919
post #5573704
post #5441932
post #5154194
post #5055193
post #4993270
post #3487105

That last one is old, but looks really good to me, like the other that are approved from the same artist.

Thanks in advance.