Donmai

How do I tag this?

Posted under Tags

bob14234657 said:

crop tops can't be strapless because that would be a tube top. and if tube tops aren't tight enough on the bottom to the waist, then it goes back to strapless shirt.

Not necessarily, you can even read the tube top wiki essentially saying it can cover the entire torso just as much as it can be the length of a crop top, there's an obvious and significant area of overlap naturally but that's it.
Also if crop tops couldnt be strapless because of the reason you gave, then crop top overhang wouldn't exist
edit: forgot it also included non-strapless shirts brainfart

Updated by DanbooruBot

Mayhem-Chan said:

Not necessarily, you can even read the tube top wiki essentially saying it can cover the entire torso just as much as it can be the length of a crop top, there's an obvious and significant area of overlap naturally but that's it.
Also if crop tops couldnt be strapless because of the reason you gave, then crop top overhang wouldn't exist

okay this is getting off-topic, feel free to dmail me or dm me on discord at Sekai#5543

Updated by DanbooruBot

Sorry if this has been resolved before, but what would be the correct commentary-related tag for posts like post #6259771, with only Twitter hashtags in the commentary? I've seen some posts where the hashtags were translated (post #5871313) and posts where they weren't (post #5131767), both tagged with commentary, so I don't know whether it should or shoudn't be tagged commentary (or if hashtags should be translated at all for that matter).

Updated by DanbooruBot

薄紅 said:

Sorry if this has been resolved before, but what would be the correct commentary-related tag for posts like post #6259771, with only Twitter hashtags in the commentary? I've seen some posts where the hashtags were translated (post #5871313) and posts where they weren't (post #5131767), both tagged with commentary, so I don't know whether it should or shoudn't be tagged commentary (or if hashtags should be translated at all for that matter).

Hashtags are often redundant with our copyright and character tags. If that's all that's in the commentary it shouldn't get any commentary tags IMO. Translating it might be helpful to someone who can't recognize them as such but just doesn't feel worth the trouble most of the time.

post #6259771 hashtags are just oshi no ko and hoshino ai (oshi no ko) so it shouldn't get any commentary tags and it doesn't really need translation.
post #5871313 translating the hashtag feels more valuable to me since it's actually meaningful and not redundant with Danbooru's tagging. There's also text commentary in addition to the hashtag so it would get the commentary tag anyway. If the tag were the only commentary I don't think I would tag it as commentary but I wouldn't argue if you did.
post #5131767 hashtags are not useful but there's commentary apart from the hashtags so the commentary tag is appropriate anyway. Translating the hashtags there would result in "#Arknights #Arknights #Arknights" which might be why it wasn't done.

Personally if I translate a commentary with redundant copy/char hashtags in addition to actual commentary I usually just leave out the hashtags in the translated version.

Updated by DanbooruBot

薄紅 said:

Sorry if this has been resolved before, but what would be the correct commentary-related tag for posts like post #6259771, with only Twitter hashtags in the commentary? I've seen some posts where the hashtags were translated (post #5871313) and posts where they weren't (post #5131767), both tagged with commentary, so I don't know whether it should or shoudn't be tagged commentary (or if hashtags should be translated at all for that matter).

If a commentary is made solely by hashtags, it doesn't need any commentary metatag.

I translate hashtags and add commentary to posts I see, even if it turns out as something like "#Arknights #Arknights #Arknights" though, it doesn't bother me, some of them have meaning and I don't expect everyone to know basic Japanese or whatever, it also helps me to filter them out of searches.

Updated by DanbooruBot