How do I tag this?

post #6252496 is unfinished. The artist says he didn't want to colorize the clothes. Should I remove the color tags?

post #6255949

What's the yellow clothing around her shoulders? A poncho/capelet/???

Should post #5749993 and others like it be tagged with gawr_gura_(2nd_costume)?

She has the cat ears, hairstyle, and hair accessories from the outfit, but is otherwise nude.

Does the complete outfit need to be present for a post to qualify for the tag?

What about post #5655465, which has a modified version of the outfit?

There are also posts like post #5534765 and post #5425252, which have the cat ears, hairstyle, and hair accessories, but the clothes themselves are different?

The_Bob said:

post #6255949

What's the yellow clothing around her shoulders? A poncho/capelet/???

I would call that a capelet because it's fastened at the chest (and thus "wrappable"), whereas ponchos are usually a continuous piece of fabric with a head hole that has to be put on like a sweater.

bob14234657 said:

I would call that a capelet because it's fastened at the chest (and thus "wrappable"), whereas ponchos are usually a continuous piece of fabric with a head hole that has to be put on like a sweater.

Thanks!

bob1159 said:

Should post #5749993 and others like it be tagged with gawr_gura_(2nd_costume)?

She has the cat ears, hairstyle, and hair accessories from the outfit, but is otherwise nude.

Does the complete outfit need to be present for a post to qualify for the tag?

What about post #5655465, which has a modified version of the outfit?

There are also posts like post #5534765 and post #5425252, which have the cat ears, hairstyle, and hair accessories, but the clothes themselves are different?

this is just my opinion so don't quote me in a court of law (also I couldn't find any guideline for this type of thing) but users searching through costume tags probably want to see either the whole costume or at least significant elements of it, not a random ensemble of outfits loosely bound by a hair ornament or other head details.

bob1159 said:

Should post #5749993 and others like it be tagged with gawr_gura_(2nd_costume)?

She has the cat ears, hairstyle, and hair accessories from the outfit, but is otherwise nude.

Does the complete outfit need to be present for a post to qualify for the tag?

What about post #5655465, which has a modified version of the outfit?

There are also posts like post #5534765 and post #5425252, which have the cat ears, hairstyle, and hair accessories, but the clothes themselves are different?

Don't know if everyone would agree but i tend to believe that when an alternate costume is at least taken as the base for a drawing, elements from it clearly visible, even if it's modified, it's better to have that costume tagged than not

Thank you Mayhem and Other Bob.

hi guys
can you help me tagging post #6260375 , especially the ears/hair/tails of the character in the extreme right of this image?
thanks in advance

Hello ^_^
I would like to ask if no humans is applicable or not when it comes to posts like post #6260450 that depict characters but inside a photo (object) while the presence of inanimate object (still life) is the main focus.

Wolf_of_Gubbio said:

hi guys
can you help me tagging post #6260375 , especially the ears/hair/tails of the character in the extreme right of this image?
thanks in advance

the fur looks like that of a snow leopard to me

post #4243720

How to tag that grape ornament? A brooch? A pendant? Something else?

magcolo said:

post #4243720

How to tag that grape ornament? A brooch? A pendant? Something else?

Pins?

To whom this may concern,

In post #917749, what is the clothing she is wearing in the torso? Is it a strapless shirt or a crop top? For now, I just provisionally tagged it as a strapless shirt because its wiki description seems to be more fitting, but I would like a 2nd opinion ／ review

Thanks in advance

magcolo said:

post #4243720

How to tag that grape ornament? A brooch? A pendant? Something else?

not enough volume to be a brooch and pendants have to hang from something. pin would be the best choice here, but is currently a dumping ground for button badge and lapel pin (and its wiki completely disagrees with all three of these usages!). definitely worth making a new tag for smaller, non-circular pins like your image.

World_Funeral said:

Hello ^_^
I would like to ask if no humans is applicable or not when it comes to posts like post #6260450 that depict characters but inside a photo (object) while the presence of inanimate object (still life) is the main focus.

people-counter tags can be omitted, and no humans can be used, if the subject you're tagging is a minor focus including those in picture frames.

Iroshi said:

To whom this may concern,

In post #917749, what is the clothing she is wearing in the torso? Is it a strapless shirt or a crop top? For now, I just provisionally tagged it as a strapless shirt because its wiki description seems to be more fitting, but I would like a 2nd opinion ／ review

Thanks in advance

this is fine left at strapless shirt, crop tops must have attached sleeves/straps/other shoulder support for the tag to apply.

bob14234657 said:

crop tops must have attached sleeves/straps/other shoulder support for the tag to apply.

Is this because of the cropped shirt wiki? i feel like those two tags shouldn't even be separate in the first place now that i notice this rule

Mayhem-Chan said:

Is this because of the cropped shirt wiki? i feel like those two tags shouldn't even be separate in the first place now that i notice this rule

I went by the strapless shirt wiki, actually. cropped shirt was probably made a tag because the vast number of crop top posts also happen to be cropped shirt, but its wiki still includes tank-tops and blouses. whether it should get nuked or not I have no opinion on.

bob14234657 said:

I went by the strapless shirt wiki, actually. cropped shirt was probably made a tag because the vast number of crop top posts also happen to be cropped shirt, but its wiki still includes tank-tops and blouses. whether it should get nuked or not I have no opinion on.

But then i don't understand why you said crop tops can't be strapless