Donmai

Deletion appeal thread

Posted under General

This topic has been locked.

user 126

kiwine said:
What is your problem, pal ?!

I dunno man, you uploaded your own DevianTart to a more strictly run database and appealed it when no one wanted to approve it, and I'm just telling you why!

kiwine

shii said:
you uploaded your own DevianTart to a more strictly run database

"More strictly run database" ...

Is it forbidden to show his own drawings here ?
The place is just for friggin'lurkers with no talent ?
The watermark... oh I think I saw a lot more in approved drawings, around here.

You don't LIKE it, alright...
So you have to laugh at me, huh ?

...And you have to lecture me about what you think is "good anatomy", of course ...
... with all the crap stocked here, let me recommand you to buy glasses, so-called-good-taste-boy.

Oh, by the way: don't forget to delete this one, too:
http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/202881/bare_shoulders-blue_hair-breasts-bunny-disgaea-hai

Updated

Muey

kiwine said:
Is it forbidden to show is own drawings here ?

The general rule is that you don't upload your own work.
The logic behind that is that if your stuff is, from an unbiased viewpoint, good enough to actually get approved, someone else will eventually stumble on it and upload it here.

I'd also lay off the "but there's much worse stuff here already" -spiel, if you'd been around here for a while, you'd know that kind of shit will not improve your chances regarding anything ever here.

kiwine

Muey said:
The general rule is that you don't upload your own work.
(...)
I'd also lay off the "but there's much worse stuff here already" -spiel, if you'd been around here for a while, you'd know that kind of shit will not improve your chances regarding anything ever here.

I understand your first point, but it's not written in the rules I agreed to sign up.

One of these rules says this:
"_Watermarked: Any image where a person who is not the original copyright owner has placed a watermark on the image."

Makes sense ... So BOBOBO actually is Eiichiro Oda, creator of ONE PIECE and owner of the copyrights ?
-> http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/205078/

Another rule says this:
"_Grotesque: Any depiction of extreme mutilation, extreme bodily distension, feces, or bodies that are far outside the realm of normal human proportion (for example, breasts that are as large as the body)."

http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/415971/

http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/230423/

http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/81553/

breasts... as ... large ... as ... the body...

http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/315407/

Ow yeaaah... good anatomy too, very nice CG colors and no watermarks at all ! Sheesh ...

On your second point, I'm not trying to improve anything anymore, I'm just saying...
Like Shii is saying whatever he wants.
I don't care about "worse" and "better" judgements, that's not what I'm talking about.

My point here is to tell him to not talk to me like I'm a scumbag: I know my skills level, and his comment was so wrong ... he don't likes my Nico Robin fanart, that's okay with me.

That's all.

Updated

0xCCBA696

kiwine: Sorry, but yeah, this site is more for "lurkers with no talent". We collect art, not publish it. As Muey said, it is preferred that if you are an artist you do not upload your own work. That said, I don't think your art is as terrible as Shii is making it out to be, but I still wouldn't have approved that image, mainly because of the retarded caption.

Snesso

kiwine said:
One of these rules says this:
"_Watermarked: Any image where a person who is not the original copyright owner has placed a watermark on the image."

Makes sense ... So BOBOBO actually is Eiichiro Oda, creator of ONE PIECE and owner of the copyrights ?
-> http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/205078/

I think it's meant to be, if an artist draws a pic and adds his website its alright... but watermaks like aerisdies.com should just be purged from the world

kiwine said:
Another rule says this:
"_Grotesque: Any depiction of extreme mutilation, extreme bodily distension, feces, or bodies that are far outside the realm of normal human proportion (for example, breasts that are as large as the body)."

http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/415971/

http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/230423/

http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/81553/

breasts... as ... large ... as ... the body...

http://danbooru.donmai.us/post/show/315407/

Ow yeaaah... good anatomy too, very nice CG colors and no watermarks at all ! Sheesh ...

The first one... yea, those are pretty huge, but I think its still into the acceptable area.
The second one, i personally like; although the breasts are out of normality, the style/shading is good, and the artists manages to make huge breasts look "possible", not sure if you get what i mean.
As for the third one... it was posted over 2 years ago, when Danbooru didnt have moderation and people posted whatever they wanted, so it doesnt count. Someone will probably delete it soon.
And the last one.. god, istantly deleted.

Rules and examples aside, I kinda like your Robin pic, the anatomy style follows Eiichiro Oda style (damn slim torso, huge breasts, etc.)... would have approved without the text probably... or posted it myself, since people here dont want artists to upload their own stuff.

kiwine

0xCCBA696 said:(...)As Muey said, it is preferred that if you are an artist you do not upload your own work.

Snesso said:(...) would have approved without the text probably... or posted it myself, since people here dont want artists to upload their own stuff.

Or maybe if I used another nickname, nobody noticed, huh ?

About the text, it's stupid, I know... it's on purpose: to do the same thing that Oda does with stupid english lines on his chapters illustrations, but... whatever.

Thanks for answering anyway, guys.

Updated

LaC

kiwine said:
Or maybe if I used another nickname, nobody noticed, huh ?

Thanks for the warning. If I see anyone else uploading your art, I'll know it's you under a fake name, and block the account.
BTW, you just demonstrated another reason why we don't want artists here: artist drama in the face of criticism. Don't use a hammer to drive a screw, stick to DeviantArt.

KeliraTelian

kiwine said:
Or maybe if I used another nickname, nobody noticed, huh ?

About the text, it's stupid, I know... it's on purpose: to do the same thing that Oda does with stupid english lines on his chapters illustrations, but... whatever.

Thanks for answering anyway, guys.

Yeah, but you are no Eichiro Oda.

Also, what LaC said. Artist drama is among the worst forms of drama. Your art sucks, get the fuck over it.

roastbeefy

unicogirl said:
Can you appeal uploads by Users?

I would sure hope so! As for the question you probably meant to ask, the answer according to
่‘‰ๆœˆ : "Certainly. It's about appealing deleted posts, not who uploaded them."

1 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 757