Posted under General
post #3175724
What is wrong with this image? Only thing I can think of is that the approvers didn't like the art style.
post #3160683
Only thing I can think of is maybe approvers didn't like her face.
post #3051352
An approver told me they think the proportions on her face and body are too wonky, but I think it's just the angle.
post #3058575
I kinda have a feeling this would have been approved if it was bigger, but as far as I could find, this is the largest version to exist.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/3194635
I was 110% sure this was gonna get approved...
I'm still learning the ropes of posting pictures here, so here I go.
post #3195389
I'm having trouble seeing what's wrong with this picture, especially since a related picture by the same artist was approved earlier (post #3195355). The only thing I can probably see is the dialogue looking a bit weird with how it overlaps everything else.
Updated
I'm not sure if it's bad luck, the mods not liking the art style, or me just not understanding why some posts don't get approved.
post #3196068, post #3196157
These are part of a series in which two of the posts got approved. Not sure if the same mods looked at the entire series. Maybe the angles are a bit off?
post #3197652
Maybe the shading's not good enough?
post #3197712, post #3197714
The only thing I can think of is there being a bit too much of a contrast between dark and light.
post #3197799 (and its children)
The colors might be a bit too saturated, though I personally don't think it detracts too much from the overall quality.
---
And now to take a crack at a few that aren't mine:
post #2776874
Maybe there's not enough detail in the picture? I'm not too sure, though it looks too cute to pass up!
post #3018293
It's kinda tricky to make out her right hand, and the fingers looks a bit "blocky," but that's about it imo. It's a bummer this was deleted, because the rest of the image looks soooo good!
post #2694429
The poster didn't give a source. If that got fixed, I think this would make a good child, mainly because it appears to be at a higher res.
Updated
calvinhobbes1010 said:
post #3196068, post #3196157
These are part of a series in which two of the posts got approved. Not sure if the same mods looked at the entire series. Maybe the angles are a bit off?
The artist’s style, especially the shading, is kind of hit or miss. These two have rather wonky faces that might have tipped the scales towards rejection. In the second post, the space between the face and the left of the hood makes the face look really strange.
post #3197652
Maybe the shading's not good enough?post #3197712, post #3197714
The only thing I can think of is there being a bit too much of a contrast between dark and light.post #3197799 (and its children)
The colors might be a bit too saturated, though I personally don't think it detracts too much from the overall quality.
I guess nobody liked Kirby enough.
post #2776874
Maybe there's not enough detail in the picture? I'm not too sure, though it looks too cute to pass up!
Not much detail, shading’s not too great, hands and faces are kind of meh.
post #3018293
It's kind of tricky to make out her right hand, and the fingers looks a bit "blocky," but that's about it imo. It's a bummer this was deleted, because the rest of the image looks soooo good!
If the right arm is supposed to be across her stomach, the elbow should be further to the front. She looks like an amputee like this. The arm’s also kind of thin and looks too short, definitely shorter than the left arm. The left arm not only has blocky fingers but also looks more like a tube with no discernible wrist. IMO, the rest of the image isn’t good enough to make up for those flaws.
post #2694429
The poster didn't give a source. If that got fixed, I think this would make a good child, mainly because it appears to be at a higher res.
The poster didn’t give a source because it’s a self-made GIF conversion (and upscale) of the parent ugoira. We don’t want third-party conversions. The original version is quite fine (and already uploaded).
DragonKnightGX said:
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/3194635
I was 110% sure this was gonna get approved...
The character’s not too bad and the strangely disproportionate legs (thick thighs and too thin lower legs, part of her hip clipping into the armrest) and somewhat inconsistent shadows might be forgiven if the rest of the image wouldn’t look like total garbage in comparison: only a gray gradient and a zero-effort couch. Even no background at all would’ve been better than that.
The rejection on this has me confused. Bad anatomy? Artifacts? just not interesting enough?
post #3203067
All of the other versions got approved, don't know why this one got deleted.
post #3203088
post #3201250
post #3201231
post #3201213
^ These aren't good enough?
Kyoriku said:
post #3203088
post #3201250
post #3201231
post #3201213
^ These aren't good enough?
They’re pretty rough and apparently didn’t tickle anyone’s fancy, except for the first one.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/3204981
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/3204983
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/3204985
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/3204986
What the FUCK is wrong with these ones? I'm sorry, but what the FUCK?
post #3204983
Looks good to me. The style is a bit dated, but that shouldn't be an issue. Definitely would've approved this.
post #3204985
Again, this one looks fine. I think she's supposed to be sitting on the glass thing, but there's some issues with depth and background. I might have approved this one.
post #3204981
Shading doesn't support a light source here. Some sketchy lines coming off of her hair don't play well with the rest of the image. Probably would've passed this one over.
Updated
Elfaleon said:
post #ID: 3204983
Again, this one looks fine. I think she's supposed to be sitting on the glass thing, but there's some issues with depth and background. I might have approved this one.
Given that you mention her sitting on a glass thing, I assume you meant this post?: https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/3204985
Please tell me why it can't get approved on this elite website?
blackreven said:
Please tell me why it can't get approved on this elite website?
Firstly, the art style isn’t one that’s particularly appreciated on this site.
Secondly, you apparently didn’t read the Uploading Guidelines:
Uploading One's Own Art is Sacrilege
Posting one's own art is severely frowned upon, and there are two reasons behind this:
- Firstly, artists tend to be biased when it comes to judging the quality of their own work. What looks good to you may be regarded as mediocre to Danbooru moderators.
- Secondly, allowing posting of own work (self-posting) will cause a sudden spike of sub-par uploads as users mistake us for another Pixiv or Deviantart, far beyond the scope and capacity of Danbooru.
More suitable sites to upload your own art to include Deviantart and Pixiv.
Admins and moderators are especially harsh on self-posting artists, lashing out penalties without remorse. The one and only way to feature your art on Danbooru is to show immense talent and skill elsewhere, and with that, captivate some fans on the other side of the Internet into uploading your art.
blackreven said:
Please tell me why it can't get approved on this elite website?
post #3206557
First and foremost, this is a self-upload. Self-uploads are held to an even higher standard than normal ones. Secondly, the style is fairly western/not terribly anime-inspired which is another category that bumps the standard required to a higher level.\
Now to the technical - The rough and fuzzy shading is a style choice that has fans, but also a lot of approvers probably prefer a clean style. Her hand looks a bit weird to me. The face also approaches the uncanny valley (don't think it's quite there, but I know some people who would be put off).
The image isn't bad, it's just not enough to compensate for the two categories which necessitate a higher standard of scrutiny.
Questionable
Explicit
Im surprised the last one didnt get approved.
poppoko said:
post #3174535
Not bad but not great or interesting either.
Chimera99 said:
Questionable
post #3199442
Ridiculous breast anatomy that didn’t catch anyone’s fancy, I guess.
Im surprised the last one didnt get approved.
post #3207982
Gives me the creeps, somehow. I guess it’s the face.
kuugarisingultimate said:
post #3209466
Not too bad, but most of the image is pretty bland and I guess the face is what puts it below threshold.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/3212200
I fucking wish I fucking knew what the fuck is so fucking wrong with this one.
