Donmai

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

zddf

zddf said:

Need help with these
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6190657
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6189602
not my upload but still don't get why
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6181244 (Explicit)

Soon to be deleted even tho the artist has 840 posts and the quality is no different than what got approved
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6193579 (Explicit)

and do approvers have a daily limit?

flagged this just to test the system and got rejected https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6199875 https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6199884
I hate to compare again but the current approval system is flawed when it comes to mid-quality art. how these two are better than the ones I quoted above? The only difference, one is from a popular series and the other is obscure

Reply
MarqFJA87

Mayhem-Chan said:

for the second one, to me it's actually the arms that look the most okay, while the legs, butt, breasts and even back itself look more off

In what way? Saying that "it's off" is too vague to be helpful in identifying the problem.

Reply
user 499293

zddf said:

flagged this just to test the system and got rejected https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6199875 https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6199884
I hate to compare again but the current approval system is flawed when it comes to mid-quality art. how these two are better than the ones I quoted above? The only difference, one is from a popular series and the other is obscure

Not sure why you linked two when only one was flagged, but in any case I don't see what you mean by "hand". The hand looks fine. SFW/cute artworks are more likely to be approved when they're "mid-quality" than some grotesque titty monster porn.

Wolf_of_Gubbio said:

any reasons for this post #6155128 ?

Western styles are much less likely to be approved. Combined with bad link + third-party source... It seems to be a stitch from here.

Reply
Mayhem-Chan

MarqFJA87 said:

In what way? Saying that "it's off" is too vague to be helpful in identifying the problem.

to me it's glaring but basically:

  • the upper attachment of the breast to the body is way too high/thick, looks like it's gonna pass above the collarbone and go directly to the girl's chin
  • the back has big structure and proportion issues, the upper back being too short, lower back too long, maybe a mistake at trying to manage perspective on the body (i get that applying perpective on the human body is especially hard, even more when you havent yet really acquired anatomy essentials like this artist)
  • she has no pelvis, even though from that angle, and with her pose and body type, the hip bone should be very prominently jutting out
  • the way the butt and visible thigh are attached to each other is just plain wrong, here too it's just a miss in basic body structure and form; the thigh is as thick as her waist (to be fair there are styles in which this particular thing works, mentionning inputwo again, and i've seen many other good cases, but here it's clearly more of a mistake and mismanagement of body perspective)

By far the best part of the image is the face (and even the ear is a bit too low), the overall anatomy itself is actually not sound at all, i've seen relatively beginner level stuff with better anatomy

Reply
zddf

kittey said:
No.

welp there goes my narrative

Talulah said:
The hand looks fine. SFW/cute artworks are more likely to be approved when they're "mid-quality" :[/posts/6193579].

I get that but it's very random to me and I don't know what gets approved and what's not when it comes to mid-quality fanart. some arts Im skeptical about got approved and others Im very confident the quality was good got deleted
and then going to genshin tag and me seeing the mess there was the reason for the rant. I want to apologize for that.

than some grotesque titty monster porn.

lol, but it's well-drawn and not any different from what got approved by the same artist. same for this post #6177350 (Explicit). another popular artist with 700 approved posts but usually pokemon and very popular nintendo games
unappealing art style or pose to many? yes but I think it's well-drawn

Western styles are much less likely to be approved.

I don't like western art usually but the artstyle here post #6189602 is very appealing and the quality is good imo which is why I asked.

Combined with bad link + third-party source... It seems to be a stitch from here.

if that is the case the approvers should have said something so I can fix this. The artist uploaded that art in pixiv but I wanted the full body version so I uploaded his work from Artstation which I thought is an approved website, but now you mentioned it, the approvers probably noped out when they saw the source which makes sense since it's all western fanart there
again if that's the case I will post the pixiv source so it gets replaced with that
Edit: just noticed you didnt quote me here, lol. well I think it still applies so won't edit that out

Updated

Reply
user 499293

wakaba_hiiro said:

I'm getting Cloudflare error 504 a lot.

there are a couple of other posts over the last couple years with the same issue, but I can't find a solution anywhere

forum #210230

forum #195515

forum #150708

Does anyone know if there's something on my end that I can fix, or will this just go away if I wait a couple hours?

There are some network problems at the moment. You'll just have to try again or wait a bit and hope they're fixed.

Reply
Mayhem-Chan

post #6140451

flagger said:

Confusing perspective. Seika's legs shouldn't bend that way if she's sitting yokozuwari style around Kikuri's arm

What way should they be bent then?? Only issue to be seen is seika's right leg disappearing under the other, not anything related to perspective or the way she sits

Reply
1 260 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 473