Donmai

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

MarqFJA87

Mayhem-Chan said:

to me it's glaring but basically:

  • the upper attachment of the breast to the body is way too high/thick, looks like it's gonna pass above the collarbone and go directly to the girl's chin
  • the back has big structure and proportion issues, the upper back being too short, lower back too long, maybe a mistake at trying to manage perspective on the body (i get that applying perpective on the human body is especially hard, even more when you havent yet really acquired anatomy essentials like this artist)
  • she has no pelvis, even though from that angle, and with her pose and body type, the hip bone should be very prominently jutting out
  • the way the butt and visible thigh are attached to each other is just plain wrong, here too it's just a miss in basic body structure and form; the thigh is as thick as her waist (to be fair there are styles in which this particular thing works, mentionning inputwo again, and i've seen many other good cases, but here it's clearly more of a mistake and mismanagement of body perspective)

By far the best part of the image is the face (and even the ear is a bit too low), the overall anatomy itself is actually not sound at all, i've seen relatively beginner level stuff with better anatomy

  • That looks to me more of an artifact of her upper back leaning backwards from the normal posture.
  • ... I literally cannot see how you've come to the conclusion that the upper back is too small and the lower is too long. They seem to be roughly about the same length. Where are you drawing the line, exactly?
  • To me, the angle seems to be about right for making the hip bone's tip pointing more or less in the viewer's direction, which would naturally obfuscate its presence.
  • Again, the angle seems to be showing more of the side of the thigh than the back of it.

With all that being said, by the time I've gotten back to this, I've noticed that this post and the Gura one have already been approved, so it's pretty much a moot point. Moving on...

[NSFW]
post #6181975
post #6181976
post #6181978
post #6181979
post #6181980
post #6181981
[NSFW]

What is the problem with this set?

Reply
zddf

Im 100% sure nothing wrong with this one https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6199571 first time this artist's work got deleted but it's a recurring theme for the copyright I upload for sadly
and without nitpicking, is there a major flaw here? https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6199434 It looks very similar to his other approved work https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5566979
Not my upload but I want to know the difference between these two [EXPLICIT]https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6207305 https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6198653[EXPLICIT] Why did the first one got approved but not the second?
both were uploaded by a Contributor level user

Reply
user 499293

zddf said:

Im 100% sure nothing wrong with this one https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6199571 first time this artist's work got deleted but it's a recurring theme for the copyright I upload for sadly

Dunno, looks fine. Probably just fell through the cracks.

Not my upload but I want to know the difference between these two [EXPLICIT]https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6207305 https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6198653[EXPLICIT] Why did the first one got approved but not the second?
both were uploaded by a Contributor level user

First one was not sent to the queue. Contributors can decide to put posts through the queue if they want; if they don't chose to they're automatically set as active.

Reply
Laudividni

Sibyl said:

post #6199026
Anything implies poor quality?

I don't think Danbooru is the place for that kind of comic.

zddf said:

it's a recurring theme for the copyright I upload for sadly

Some copyrights have it easier due to personal bias and no one flagging for sure, but personally, even by looking at the thumbnails, most goddess_of_victory:_nikke status:deleted posts aren't that good.

and without nitpicking, is there a major flaw here? https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6199434 It looks very similar to his other approved work https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5566979

Illustrations with breasts that large have it harder, its parent had also been deleted and appealed almost a month ago, it's a shame you uploaded it anyway. The second post you linked didn't go through the queue.

Reply
zddf

Collective said:

most goddess_of_victory:_nikke status:deleted posts aren't that good.

but many would have got a pass if it was from a more popular copyright/character and after learning contributors can bypass the quality check, I now understand where this bias for mid-quality artworks is coming from

imo all this https://danbooru.donmai.us/artists/8797 recent work has a place here but it get deleted now

Illustrations with breasts that large have it harder

but Why? I noticed that

it's a shame you uploaded it anyway. The second post you linked didn't go through the queue.

nothing shameful about that. I genuinely think the art is good and wouldn't be the first time something decent gets reuploaded from another source and approved because the right approver happened to see it

Updated

Reply
1 261 262 263 264 265 266 267 268 269 473