Donmai

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

CoreMack

HunterVR said:

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5182300

Mod deleted it with "No." and no further deliberation or explanation.

If you take a look at the upload rules (help:upload rules), you'll see that both photographs which have nothing to do with anime and low-effort memes are "off-topic" and prohibited on this site. Your upload was essentially both of these.
Posts that are very poor quality are also subject to being deleted immediately. No offense, but the art you are posting is very far below the minimum standards for this site.

Reply
Nacha

The images in the pool were all uploaded by an unrestricted uploader, so they didn't need to go through the moderation queue. I do think that comics are harder to get approved, as some approvers do skip them in the queue.

Reply
Veraducks

OmegaStarNeo said:

post #5183777
post #5183788

How did these goof up?

It's a messy sketch and a meme. Although I sympathize with head rubs knocking me out and feeling amazing, the art feels half-finished at best.

Silvermanelol said:

post #5185647
post #5185647
post #5185677
post #5185705

post #5186005
post #5185997
post #5185975
post #5185951

May I ask why these posts have been deleted? The animated ones got hundred of up votes and likes. If there is a problem with resolution or such it can be fixed. Im just very confused why majority of my posts are being deleted. I uploaded everything correctly, sorted and tagged everything

Upvotes don't matter are not an indicator of quality. Animated porn will pretty much always get hundreds of upvotes because people are horny. Tagging, sourcing, etc. are requirements for all images, yes, but that doesn't mean a well-tagged image is automatically approved.

What matters above all else is the quality of the art. The non-animated ones have a lot of odd anatomy and proportion errors. The animated ones have similar issues but the added issue is that the animation isn't very good. It's the image cut out and crammed into a live2d-type program and made the spots mash together.

razorsharp said:

post #5170446 just a variation of an approved post

what happened with these?
post #5170429
post #5167928

Bad proportions and weird anatomy. Always to pull your eyes away from the booba and look at the details. You'll spot big heads, twisted spines and arms, and similar stuff.

sheepinspace said:

I just got here and my post keep being deleted i don't understand why..

post #5135012
post #5134970
post #5166154

Self uploads are strongly discouraged and, when they come up, are looked at with significantly more scrutiny than otherwise. I think your art is pretty close to approvable, but self upload is a tag that is highlighted red for approvers. A lot of us tend to just auto-skip images with such tags. And that's before, again, the increased scrutiny.

kit009 said:

Requesting some tough love on this one:
post #5190622

booba

Updated

Reply
Nacha

MaidBelfast said:

Hi,

I was just wondering what is wrong with these images, they are of good quality and better than some things which are approved on Danbooru, and yet they were rejected

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5180099
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5179963
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5180029

There is no need for Cropped art, when the original image is uploaded. Then there is a missing source for the cropped one, which isn't helpful either. The sketch image is just way to simple. The complete image has way to many flaws. The nipples look like a :3 mouth, the left girls torso looks to small, her eyes asymmetrical. The right girls body has a poor foreshortening leg. And there are still more flaws, which ruin the whole image. Remember, that small flaws are still fine in an image, as long as they don't jump into your focus while looking at an image. But the huge amount of flaws make the image not approvable.
As an extra: "better stuff is approved" will almost never get you an approval. You better point out the good stuff about an appealed image, instead of comparing it with others.

Reply
Veraducks

sh9248 said:

Can I ask for feedback on those two?
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5158055
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5158057

They both have odd proportioning, perspective, and just a little bit of bad anatomy. Enough weak bits that they fall apart.

truesword24 said:

Hi, can somebody tell me why these images are deleted?

post #4609576
post #4666201
post #4974118
post #4974183
post #4976449
post #5191987
post #5192004

They are both aesthetically pleasing and don't have any obvious quality problems so they really should be approved IMHO.

Pretty much all of them have obvious quality problems. It's the weak shading that kills most of them.

SWA_YAMAYURI said:

Hello, can I feedback these posts.

post #5193880
post #5199222
post #5199221
post #5199216

I don't understand why these get deleted.
Thanks.

Similar to the others, they have a lot of weird proportions, anatomy, and perspective.

Reply
SWA YAMAYURI

Veradux said:

They both have odd proportioning, perspective, and just a little bit of bad anatomy. Enough weak bits that they fall apart.

Pretty much all of them have obvious quality problems. It's the weak shading that kills most of them.

Similar to the others, they have a lot of weird proportions, anatomy, and perspective.

I checked the artist of post #5193880 before upload it. miraino tsubasa
They're almost the same style, so I decided to upload the post. To be honest, I believe they are the same quality, but didn't get deleted.
Forgive me, but for all of the post, I Used Saucenao or Ascii2d to find sources or duplicates followed by upload instructions. So I still have not idea how they similar to the others.
Thanks.

Reply
1 198 199 200 201 202 203 204 205 206 488