What was wrong with it? Did I miss a parent rule?
Posted under General
What was wrong with it? Did I miss a parent rule?
cm2 said:
What was wrong with it? Did I miss a parent rule?
If you're uploading the pixiv version you shouldn't also upload the twitter version, unless they're different. Duplicates like that are unlikely to be approved.
Just curious as to why these posts were deleted. I assumed that because similar artwork of the same artist had been approved, that these would be approved as well. One was marked as poor quality even though it looked almost the same as one that had been approved.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5163446?q=user%3ADogbooru
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5163424?q=user%3ADogbooru
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5149678?q=user%3ADogbooru
I'm guessing it just depends on the approvers that review it.
Dogbooru said:
Just curious as to why these posts were deleted. I assumed that because similar artwork of the same artist had been approved, that these would be approved as well. One was marked as poor quality even though it looked almost the same as one that had been approved.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5163446?q=user%3ADogbooru
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5163424?q=user%3ADogbooru
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5149678?q=user%3ADogbooruI'm guessing it just depends on the approvers that review it.
I actually really like that artist personally, but I wouldn't upload them to Danbooru and I am hesitant about approving them because their artstyle is very different from the anime style that Danbooru is focused on. Art not drawn in an anime style and not related to any Japanese copyright definitely can get approved here if it is good, but its chances are much lower than anime art. Each post is weighed individually, so when an artist's style is already somewhat off-topic then it can be a coin flip whether each post will get approved.
Sorry, I'm not sure whether I can feedback the post which not I upload.
But I found those following post I think it is pretty good.
post #4927592
post #4831283
post #4831286
post #5162274
post #5163840
If I broken the feedback rules, I apologise.
Thanks.
SWA_YAMAYURI said:
Sorry, I'm not sure whether I can feedback the post which not I upload.
But I found those following post I think it is pretty good.
post #4927592
post #4831283
post #4831286
post #5162274
post #5163840
If I broken the feedback rules, I apologise.
Thanks.
If it's someone else's uploads, it's better that you at least tried appealing it first and it failed before posting it here and you choose just a few decent examples, otherwise odds are you'll be ignored. You should wait the disapprovals vanish before appealing the last two uploads, though.
Hyozen said:
If it's someone else's uploads, it's better that you at least tried appealing it first and it failed before posting it here and you choose just a few decent examples, otherwise odds are you'll be ignored. You should wait the disapprovals vanish before appealing the last two uploads, though.
Sorry, I forgot I can Appeal. I will try it.
Thank you so much!
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5167345?q=user%3Apl3sm
Can anyone please give my feedback why my post didn't get accepted?
SWA_YAMAYURI said:
Sorry, I forgot I can Appeal. I will try it.
Thank you so much!
What Hyozen said is not entirely true. There're no hard-set rules regarding that and you'll get feedback on any deleted image you ask about. They are all old enough to be appealed, though I have my doubts about them succeeding. They all have very poor shading and questionable to bad anatomy. Shinano is the best one of that bunch but between the bad feet, bad hands, and strange waistlines I can't say that an appeal for any of the others would go through.
pl3sm said:
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5167345?q=user%3Apl3sm
Can anyone please give my feedback why my post didn't get accepted?
Self uploads have a naturally harder time getting through the queue and when they do catch an approver's attention we end putting much more scrutiny to the image. Like his overly long fingers and tongue.
Personally, I don't think it was worth "6 believe it has poor quality." and recommend waiting a month and then appealing it. Being a self upload makes it very unlikely to be approved, but I can think of 1-3 approvers who might approve it.
You can simply use post #5167345, btw.
Veradux said:
What Hyozen said is not entirely true. There're no hard-set rules regarding that and you'll get feedback on any deleted image you ask about. They are all old enough to be appealed, though I have my doubts about them succeeding. They all have very poor shading and questionable to bad anatomy. Shinano is the best one of that bunch but between the bad feet, bad hands, and strange waistlines I can't say that an appeal for any of the others would go through.
Self uploads have a naturally harder time getting through the queue and when they do catch an approver's attention we end putting much more scrutiny to the image. Like his overly long fingers and tongue.
Personally, I don't think it was worth "6 believe it has poor quality." and recommend waiting a month and then appealing it. Being a self upload makes it very unlikely to be approved, but I can think of 1-3 approvers who might approve it.
You can simply use post #5167345, btw.
Thank you. The reason why I want to appeal just because those posts is pretty in my view. Of course, I'm knew the post good to me may not to the others, so I respect the decision by approval team anytime.
Maybe the others post all has some issue mentioned above. But I still don't understand why the post #4831283 is poor quality.
SWA_YAMAYURI said:
Thank you. The reason why I want to appeal just because those posts is pretty in my view. Of course, I'm knew the post good to me may not to the others, so I respect the decision by approval team anytime.
Maybe the others post all has some issue mentioned above. But I still don't understand why the post #4831283 is poor quality.
Their legs are very off. Noshiro's feet are either broken or the victim of a poor attempt at water refraction. Kaga's waist and hips make little sense and her neck is significantly longer but also oddly thinner than Noshiro's. At a glance, it looks decent but tear your eyes away from the wet booba and things fall apart.
As I always say:
Fap before uploading or approving. Not during.
Veradux said:
Their legs are very off. Noshiro's feet are either broken or the victim of a poor attempt at water refraction. Kaga's waist and hips make little sense and her neck is significantly longer but also oddly thinner than Noshiro's. At a glance, it looks decent but tear your eyes away from the wet booba and things fall apart.
As I always say:
Fap before uploading or approving. Not during.
Maybe you are right. I reviewed the post again, not sure whether I'm 100% understood what you pointed though. But I can see the unnatural things in the post, specially Noshiro's feet. Anyway, thanks for your patient reply and detailed explanation.
Forgive me use the translate. Thanks.
CormacM said:
I actually really like that artist personally, but I wouldn't upload them to Danbooru and I am hesitant about approving them because their artstyle is very different from the anime style that Danbooru is focused on. Art not drawn in an anime style and not related to any Japanese copyright definitely can get approved here if it is good, but its chances are much lower than anime art. Each post is weighed individually, so when an artist's style is already somewhat off-topic then it can be a coin flip whether each post will get approved.
Ohh, I understand. Makes more sense now. Thanks for the answer!
How many of these Touhou images can be recovered??
post #5163840
post #5155167
post #5101515
post #5091698
post #5012660
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5180293?q=user%3ADragons1820
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5179670?q=user%3ADragons1820
Will this get deleted because of the source? If it does, would I need to find a different source to avoid deletion? Is getting the image from a wiki website such as https://project-imas.wiki/ count as an acceptable source site here?
Durpala said:
How many of these Touhou images can be recovered??
post #5163840
post #5155167
post #5101515
post #5091698
post #5012660
They're all very rough. Someone might like the second and last ones on appeal, but the anatomy and shading are too rough on all of them.
Dragons1820 said:
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5180293?q=user%3ADragons1820
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5179670?q=user%3ADragons1820Will this get deleted because of the source? If it does, would I need to find a different source to avoid deletion? Is getting the image from a wiki website such as https://project-imas.wiki/ count as an acceptable source site here?
This thread is typically for images not yet deleted. Those images are only a few hours old and those questions are best asked before posting. The Discord is great for that. Link at the bottom of every page.
Wikis can be a decent spot to get official art if you can confirm it's a filerip, as some will use screenshots and edits. You'd want the page you got the image from rather than the specific image URL so that when we click the source link it takes us to the actual page. Keep in mind that official does not get a free pass.
Also, you can just do post #5180293 rather than the whole URL. If you're on mobile it's not hard to backspace before and after the post # in the URL.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5173205
Any specific reason to not approve it? doesn't seem that bad to me
post: https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5170485
i think there are a few things i might've done wrong here, but i'm not sure which one it is, or if it's all of them. should i have tagged the post as questionable because the girl not in frame is nude? should i have used less tags to avoid being seen as tag spamming? should i have tried to provide another source for the artist? is the post just not the proper fit for danbooru?
dysp.erdotted said:
post: https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5170485
i think there are a few things i might've done wrong here, but i'm not sure which one it is, or if it's all of them. should i have tagged the post as questionable because the girl not in frame is nude? should i have used less tags to avoid being seen as tag spamming? should i have tried to provide another source for the artist? is the post just not the proper fit for danbooru?
Mistags won't make a post get rejected. Tags can always be changed.
dysp.erdotted said:
post: https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5170485
i think there are a few things i might've done wrong here, but i'm not sure which one it is, or if it's all of them. should i have tagged the post as questionable because the girl not in frame is nude? should i have used less tags to avoid being seen as tag spamming? should i have tried to provide another source for the artist? is the post just not the proper fit for danbooru?
There's nothing wrong with the source or tags, as Bob says.
It's just too rough. It's a fine joke image but not really danbooru quality.
And, to cut this off early: It's not the content or the actions or anything like that. We gladly accept vtubers, hololive, pillowfights, etc. etc. It's just not quality enough art.