Posted under General
This topic has been locked.
post #7891481
post #7891495
post #7891500
Doubt it constitutes abuse on the part of the flagger, but to my (now years-old) knowledge lowres and jpeg artifacts are not, in & of themselves, valid reasons to flag an image that doesn't have any larger alternative versions available.
Updated
Trouble_Windows said:
I'm as much for anatomy checks as anyone else, but she's visibly leaning forwards.
A flagger being wrong about poor anatomy is not flag vandalism. Also, that is a big head.
reg_panda said:
The horned girl is between the viewer and the big head girl, the perspective can't cause this.
edit: no, the horned girl is probably behind the big head girl.
She's further away from the camera, yeah, she's also a child so she's smaller in general :P
AngryZapdos said:
A flagger being wrong about poor anatomy is not flag vandalism. Also, that is a big head.
Fair enough. Not my post anyways, just thought it was an odd flag ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Still new to some of the site's functions
poor res
Trouble_Windows said:
Topicality check - western porn of western game series
Not what off-topic means
Actually it was a good flag, and this is what off-topic means. Western characters + western artist + western style + rule34 is perfectly okay to be flagged for off-topic. If you don't think that it is western style, or you think that it is high quality enough, or otherwise interesting, that's a different question.
reg_panda said:
Actually it was a good flag, and this is what off-topic means. Western characters + western artist + western style + rule34 is perfectly okay to be flagged for off-topic. If you don't think that it is western style, or you think that it is high quality enough, or otherwise interesting, that's a different question.
While I don't agree you deserved the now removed negative record, don't be surprised if you get another one if you keep going around telling people that made up rules exist.
reg_panda said:
Actually it was a good flag, and this is what off-topic means. Western characters + western artist + western style + rule34 is perfectly okay to be flagged for off-topic. If you don't think that it is western style, or you think that it is high quality enough, or otherwise interesting, that's a different question.
Please don't make up rules or guidelines.
WWW was discussed ages ago and got binned very fast. That's not a valid flag reason on its own.
WWW has nothing to do with quality.
don't be surprised if you get another one if you keep going around telling people that made up rules exist.
Mb, there is no "www rule" in the form I stated in the other topic (which I deleted within 20 mins, that's not a very harmful form of "going around telling people").
I still don't see why wasn't this flag a perfectly good flag. I did a similar flag, and it goes fine flag #623133
Also I don't see why wouldn't Western characters + western artist + western style + rule34 perfectly okay reason for a flag. It breaks the rules, and it is eligible for flagging, according to help:upload_rules and howto:flag. (And everything western style, not anime related is eligible for a flag. Not off-topic, but for a flag.)
Also off-topic contains images like post #6926016 or post #6261010 (i actually like this one, probably bc of the steam). (While we are at it, I've removed off-topic from post #7197312, put it back if not good. I asked it before, but noone answered.)
help:upload_rules only says "anime-style". If toon is treated differently than the rest of the western styles, that should be written somewhere.
Updated
reg_panda said:
Mb, there is no "www rule" in the form I stated in the other topic (which I corrected within 20 mins, that's not a very harmful form of "going around telling people").
I still don't see why wasn't this flag a perfectly good flag. I did a similar flag, and it goes fine flag #623133
Also I don't see why wouldn't Western characters + western artist + western style + rule34 perfectly okay reason for a flag. It breaks the rules, and it is eligible for flagging, according to help:upload_rules and howto:flag. (And everything western style, not anime related is eligible for a flag.)
Also off-topic contains images like post #6926016 or post #6261010 (i actually like this one, probably bc of the steam). (While we are at it, I've removed off-topic from post #7197312, put it back if not good. I asked it before, but noone answered.)
help:upload_rules only says "anime-style". If only toon porn in off-topic, but not the rest of the western styles, that should be written somewhere.
Where are you getting the idea that "WWW" is against the rules? Literally nothing in either of the pages you've linked says or even implies this.
help:upload rules said: Danbooru is primarily for anime-style or anime-related artwork.
The bolded word here is really important. "Primarily" does not mean "exclusively."
Iunno, probably multiple sources.
BTW "Good drawings of non-anime content." was explicitly mentioned in howto:flag as something that shouldn't be flagged until 2022-09-27, when @nonamethanks removed it ( https://danbooru.donmai.us/wiki_page_versions/diff?thispage=448263&type=previous ). I am not sure if that was a change of policy, or just something that was deemed redundant? If it is still the policy, I don't see why that line can't be there.
reg_panda said:
Iunno, probably multiple sources.
BTW "Good drawings of non-anime content." was explicitly mentioned in howto:flag as something that shouldn't be flagged until 2022-09-27, when @nonamethanks removed it ( https://danbooru.donmai.us/wiki_page_versions/diff?thispage=448263&type=previous ). I am not sure if that was a change of policy, or just something that was deemed redundant? If it is still the policy, I don't see why that line can't be there.
I removed it because that wiki page was becoming too bloated with irrelevant things and had different information than what the upload rules said.
The only things that are unquestionably off-topic are the three lines under help:upload rules. Everything else should be sorted out by the mod queue.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7947397Second time a post has been flagged for being a dupe. Even if it's unsourced, I don't think it should be flagged just for that? (correct me if I'm wrong)
This happened previously with https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6878277 (flagged for being a dupe).
Not sure if they are the same person. However, in case they are, it might help to direct them to the rules about ''not flagging dupes''.
Edit: Got the first part answered by Unb. Still, I don't think it hurts if it were the same person of the second post that flagged the post for being a dupe.
Updated
