Posted under General
So, I have a few images in my status:deleted, and I get most of them, but I wanted a little feedback on post #787728, specifically. I'm wondering which holds more weight towards deletion: The quality of the pixel art, or the fact that I animated the artist's sprite sheet myself? I guess what I'm getting at is, if I had just uploaded the original sprite sheet, would that have been more likely to meet with success, or is this piece just straight-up not for Danbooru?
Updated
nanami said:
post #731982 (already translated; but maybe not funny?)
post #500094 (also already translated)
Gaketsu's shading style and such is rather polarizing. Hands are pretty bad on the watermelon too.
Danzaiver said: post #787728
I think the issue is that the sprite simply lacks charm (coupled with the fact that the animation is pretty stiff). And even though I'm a big, fat TF2 fan(atic) myself, I don't really find anything appealing about the sprite at all.
Try looking at some posts tagged with pixel_art (or pixel_art gif), and contrast them to the Heavy sprite to get an idea of what I mean - being able to consider a sprite "charming" is of crucial importance.
Updated
Checking on the art of this comic post #758354
and checking on the art of post #763730
nanami said:
post #721802
post #703468
post #648731
Personally I'm tired of the "just punched in the face" look and the third one her head just looks fat.
post #702315
post #701451 (is it Noda's left fist?)
nanami said: post #702315
It's an above average image, but the lack of amazing-ness and interesting emphasis killed it for me. Plus she's not that pretty. So yeah, personal preference plays strong in this one. I honestly don't know why nobody else approved it.
nanami said:
post #702315
rantuyetmai said:
...
It looks fine to me, nothing spectacular, but definitely undeletable. I must have passed it over as borderline before, but I think she looks nice. I've undeleted it for you.
Krugger said:
post #758458
post #755785
Generic Touhou parody comics. Been there, done that, got the T-shirt
Just a quick note not directed at anyone in particular: Remember, this thread is for asking for feedback in a general sense. Not as a fallback plan if your deletion appeal thread post didn't get you anywhere for a given post. Most people shouldn't be posting in this thread repeatedly.
post #780624 - why ? I know it's pretty hardcore pic, but still it doesn't include gore and it's in fine resolution 1k+ * 1k+.
Sometimes I have a feeling that some series are undesired on danbooru e.g. from kami nomi zo shiru sekai series.
Updated
HNTI said:
post #780624 - why ? I know it's pretty hardcore pic, but still it doesn't include gore and it's in fine resolution 1k+ * 1k+.Sometimes I have a feeling that some series are undesired on danbooru e.g. from kami nomi zo shiru sekai series.
A) Not the deletion appeal thread
B) Its...ok? I doubt I'd approve it, but its not horrible or anything.
C) What in the world makes you think KamiNomi images aren't desired?
I'm just curious why these pics weren't approved:
post #781580
post #785067
post #772785
post #766124
post #756600
post #754858
post #750128
Thank you for your time.
takuya_yagami said:
I'm just curious why these pics weren't approved:
Everyone's going to have their own reasons, but...
post #781580 - Not a fan of huge breasts.
post #785067 - Text/URL is annoying, not a fan of DC/Marvel, either
post #772785 - ...Okay, yeah, that is pretty cute...
post #766124 - Not Danbooru related, even with the shopped-on school swimsuit
post #756600 - Meh
post #754858 - Meh art, too much text
post #750128 - Don't like the style
