Pointless Pools

Hillside_Moose said:
pool #1679 - "Food of doom"
Redundant with the bad_food tag.

While most of the bad food tag qualifies for the pool most of what's currently in the pool doesn't qualify for bad food in the least.

Hillside_Moose said:
pool #1615 - "Epic Fail"
Redundant with the failure tag.

Added failure where it was missing, notified the pool creator and deleted.

Log said: While most of the bad food tag qualifies for the pool most of what's currently in the pool doesn't qualify for bad food in the least.

Agreed. I think "food of doom" is just not a great name. Inappropriate Food or something along those lines might make more sense.

pool #1617 - "Touhou - Everyone is straight in Gensokyo"
This pool seems like a reaction to the talks regarding getting rid of the heterosexual tag. A touhou couple search should would work, or touhou -yuri rating:e for sex.

Hm, yes, since couple is defined as heterosexual, it's probably redundant. Curious to hear what others say and see if I'm missing something though.

Regarding the "Food of doom" pool, if you're talking about the concept shown in post #624706, post #656870, or post #608721, it probably deserves a tag of its own, or at least have the pool renamed and description rewritten so it doesn't include anything where bad_food is sufficient.

jxh2154 said:
Hm, yes, since couple is defined as heterosexual, it's probably redundant. Curious to hear what others say and see if I'm missing something though.

Well, post #533961, at least, is one that wouldn't fall under touhou couple. Not sure if that's a common case, though; 7 pages of pool:1617 touhou -couple to look through...

jxh2154 said

Hm, yes, since couple is defined as heterosexual, it's probably redundant. Curious to hear what others say and see if I'm missing something though.

Half of the pool didn't have the couple tag, and the pool was actually intended to show characters that show at least an attraction to opposite sex, where the tag couple didn't necessarily fit in. (that's what I think)

pool #1674 - "Happy Facials"

It's more a search term than a pool; that or smile facial.

They are not all "smile facial". Some of them are without "smile", some are "happy_sex", or just "happy" or none of those. Sure i use those tags to find the pics. If i anyhow broke the law, so delete it...

pool #1448 - "Objectification"

We already have a tag for this, and it's called objectification.

pool #1632 - "Completely Unamused"

Not that it's a bad pool, I just think it could just be better off as a tag.

pool #1677 - "Perfect Breasts"

Is there really such a thing as the absolute perfect pair of breasts?

No, but that's not really the point of the pool. It's just a pool for images that have well drawn body parts just like "The Perfect Feet" and "Dat Ass!!".

Hillside_Moose said:
pool #1448 - "Objectification"
We already have a tag for this, and it's called objectification.

Deleted.

Algasir said: pool #1632 - "Completely Unamused"
Not that it's a bad pool, I just think it could just be better off as a tag.

But what tag?

mario1277 said: pool #1677 - "Perfect Breasts"

It's in line with the other body part pools we have.

Perhaps an unamused tag? I can't really think of a good tag name...

Maybe it is better off as a pool.

Well aren't you a quitter.

We have the expressionless tag in use, though it could benefit from having some synonyms aliased to it.

Edit: Adding a pool to the list: pool #1700 - "The Morning After"

We already have a morning tag.

Hillside_Moose said: Edit: Adding a pool to the list: pool #1700 - "The Morning After"
We already have a morning tag.

Doesn't seem quite the same - morning also has things like post #553257 and post #435807 (though that one could probably just be sunrise. If we used a tag for this it would have to be morning_after for the common expression.

jxh2154 said:
It's in line with the other body part pools we have.

What happened to the Pool about breasts that (if I remember the summary) adhere to gravity, it wasn't related to the hanging_breasts tag just so you know.

pool #1721 - "I'm gonna rape you"

First of all, the pool's name doesn't fit its contents at all. Second, tease or presenting should already cover this.

unicogirl said:
What happened to the Pool about breasts that (if I remember the summary) adhere to gravity, it wasn't related to the hanging_breasts tag just so you know.

Natural Breasts? No one knows. It's deletion was mentioned in this thread a while back, but no one actually requested for it to be deleted here.

pool #1741 - Kimonos and Katanas

Entirely redundant. Just search kimono katana.

pool #1528 - Scared to Sleep Alone

It's not a bad concept, but there's no reason for it to be a pool instead of a tag. I don't understand why people are so quick to create new pools yet reluctant to create new tags.

evazion said: pool #1721 - "I'm gonna rape you"

[/quote]
Deleted.

evazion said: pool #1741 - Kimonos and Katanas
Entirely redundant. Just search kimono katana.

Deleted.

pool #1528 - Scared to Sleep Alone
It's not a bad concept, but there's no reason for it to be a pool instead of a tag. I don't understand why people are so quick to create new pools yet reluctant to create new tags.

Leaving until someone comes up with said replacement tag.