Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

5 approvers
post #8812756
post #8812785
post #8812881

jxh2154 said:

People have been asking for a thread where feedback on uploads could be obtained. So here it is. I have some reservations about how acrimonious this thread is likely to get, and if it turns into nothing more than a flame-fest, I will lock it.

Rules for those requesting feedback:
#1 - You are not guaranteed feedback. It is entirely voluntary to give it.
#2 - Danbooru may simply not be an appropriate place for your favorite art. If so, accept this and move on.
#3 - Try not to be too thin-skinned,and don't take things personally.

Rules for those giving feedback:
#1 - Give constructive feedback only.
#2 - Refrain from name-calling. Asking people to be thick-skinned doesn't mean you're allowed to be insulting.

Why was my post deleted?

lucarioRiolugirl said:

Why was my post deleted?

ai-generated images are against the rules.

post #8814503

Hi, any feedback on why this post wasn't approved? Please give it a second chance.
post #6903404

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8817357?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3ANoIdea4GoodName: Seen by 5 approvers.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8804232?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3ANoIdea4GoodName: Ditto.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8640825?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3ANoIdea4GoodName: Seen by 7 approvers on the first appeal.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8459058?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3ANoIdea4GoodName: Ditto.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8430988: Parent of approved post, but it takes place at night.

post #8728431

The lower resolution version was approved after being flagged.

Ylimegirl said:

Most of the active posts there didn't go through the modqueue. A contributor liking something enough to upload it doesn't necessarily equal an approver liking something enough to approve it.

Shouldn't those quality standards be the same?

EDIT: Nevermind.
I'm not sure how to delete forum posts so all i can do is edit it to blank it out...

These two are pretty well-rendered, maybe they deserve another chance?
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8784945?q=parent%3A8784945 (NSFW)
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8784954?q=parent%3A8784945 (NSFW)

Thank you, Boys and Squishy!

post #8789567 Good quailty but only 5 approvers have seen.
post #8723016

I'm starting to think that Danboru is just full of retards who are really into low-quality 2D boobs. I've been trying to get an explanation for why this post (post #8752376) isn't approved, but they just send it back for rechecking and then delete it. You've got a site full of low-quality stuff, and you're rejecting semi-realistic art. Maybe you should get some therapy.

That post doesn't look that good honestly for a number of reasons, including how bad that torso twist is.

WRS said:

That post doesn't look that good honestly for a number of reasons, including how bad that torso twist is.

You told me there were anatomical problems with this art, but you only added anime art to your favourites, which have far more critical issues.

What right do you have to judge the quality of your work when you have no artistic skills?

Viseult said:

I'm starting to think that Danboru is just full of retards who are really into low-quality 2D boobs. […] You've got a site full of low-quality stuff, and you're rejecting semi-realistic art.

Viseult said:

You told me there were anatomical problems with this art, but you only added anime art to your favourites, which have far more critical issues.

This is an anime-centric imageboard. It's gonna have a skew towards anime-style art. You might wanna try uploading to a different booru if this concept bothers you so much. (and semi-realistic ≠ good by default)

Just asking, because officially only 6 or less checked them:
post #8819632
post #8818804
post #8818731
post #8806893
post #8820101
post #8720487
post #8685929

this one, because the non cum sibling post got approved:
post #8634455

More failed appeals I'd like an explanation for

SFW
post #8706584 (is it Byakuren's eyes?)
post #8711437 Thanks!
post #8714269
post #8721820
post #8740556 (only 5 reviewers on appeal) Thanks!

NSFW
post #8703729 (is it the foot?)

Thanks again!

andlabs said:

More failed appeals I'd like an explanation for

SFW
post #8706584 (is it Byakuren's eyes?)
post #8711437
post #8714269
post #8721820
post #8740556 (only 5 reviewers on appeal)

I think most of them just didn't catch the interest of the approvers. post #8711437 for example, is more of a WIP/quick sketch if you compare it to the other works by the artist.

post #8703729 (is it the foot?)

Most likely.

NoIdea4GoodName said:

I think most of them just didn't catch the interest of the approvers. post #8711437 for example, is more of a WIP/quick sketch if you compare it to the other works by the artist.

Fair enough; I have noticed that for some other posts, including one that already failed appeal (which is why I now try to note if a seemingly unfinished post was completed or not). I'm still going to try appealing my other deleted posts, just because doing so wouldn't hurt. Thanks!

Can I ask for what reason my post are deleted? I'm new to this kind of imageboards and maybe doesn't know rules of posting....

post #8820015
post #8680745
post #8680727

post #8590942
Anything wrong with this post?