Posted under General
This seems on par with other pictures by the artist, but it wasn't approved. I'd also like reviews of some of my other uploads that I think are high-enough quality to justify approval:
post #8152273
post #4848302
post #3665450
post #3665447
Thanks.
Updated
post #8762543post #8761704 (7 approvers)post #8762952 (7 approvers)post #8763053 (5 approvers)
Updated
post #8747971
post #8747989
post #8757537
post #8757579
Any reason why these got deleted? They are all drawn well
TheGamingRodent said:
post #8747971
post #8747989
post #8757537
post #8757579Any reason why these got deleted? They are all drawn well
post #8747971: Might be because of the foreshortening of her legs; it looks awkward.
Here is a picture that checking favorites it would been uploaded by at least 3 contributors but unfortunately I did it so it was deleted
post #8763554
Updated
any idea why these weren't approved? They have the same quality as other posts from the same artist. The first one has a fair number of favorites too
post #8759320
post #8759307
post #8759300
post #8759295
post #8759274
post #8759259
post #8720702
I've been posting a lot of official RWBY art by Uyalago, and while the majority of it was approved, these ones slipped through the cracks.
post #8742338
post #8742360
post #8744388
post #8744443
post #8744524post #8750858post #8753694post #8754164post #8754255 (approved parent)post #8761366 (approved parent)
post #8761376post #8761384
post #8763407
post #8763461
Updated
post #8733189 <- I still don't get why It got unapproved while the parent and sibling were approved
post #8738122 (parent with related post)
Why were these rejected?
Once again, would like a second look
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8753017?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3AWoodyTheFemboy (only Seven approvers)
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8743889
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8738348?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3AWoodyTheFemboy
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8738359?q=parent%3A8738348
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8738365?q=parent%3A8738359
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8724611?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3AWoodyTheFemboy
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8551688?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3AWoodyTheFemboy (too toon-porny?)
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8587271?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3AWoodyTheFemboy
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8513490?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3AWoodyTheFemboy
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8737857?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3AWoodyTheFemboy (too toon-porny?)
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8434169?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3AWoodyTheFemboy
Updated
Hi, any feedback on why this post wasn't approved? Please give it a second chance.
post #6147191
Updated
BKaz20 said:
I've been posting a lot of official RWBY art by Uyalago, and while the majority of it was approved, these ones slipped through the cracks.
Several more were deleted. I've lost quite a few upload slots because of this.
post #8765561
post #8766605
post #8766630post #8766649post #8766842 (approved parent)
Updated
The artist is fine, the character/copyright gets approved all the time, the art quality is very high, am I missing some issue with this one?
I understand that the first two images were uploaded by a contributor, so it is inherently subjective; but I don't exactly get why a post that it is has a score of 17, has been reviewed and appealed still does not gel with the approvers. It is the last variant of these parent-child posts, so why is this one constantly getting singled out?
Also, why was this post appealed by an approver? I was under the assumption that approvers had the power to automatically undelete posts (something that has happened to numerous posts of mine.) This post is also singled out despite being visually similar to another piece of art from the same artist.
Can someone give me feedback on https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8725282?
The animation is pretty good
Any ideas about post #8771264?
TAKAMAN said:
I understand that the first two images were uploaded by a contributor, so it is inherently subjective; but I don't exactly get why a post that it is has a score of 17, has been reviewed and appealed still does not gel with the approvers. It is the last variant of these parent-child posts, so why is this one constantly getting singled out?
The score is irrelevant. Users can upvote or downvote posts for any reason, including things that have nothing to do with art quality, so it’s not a good metric to determine whether something should be approved.
Also, why was this post appealed by an approver? I was under the assumption that approvers had the power to automatically undelete posts (something that has happened to numerous posts of mine.) This post is also singled out despite being visually similar to another piece of art from the same artist.
There was no reason given in the appeal, but it’s possible there weren’t many approvers that looked at it. Some approvers will appeal posts if they think there weren’t enough eyes on it to give it a fairer shot, but that doesn’t necessarily mean they would approve it themselves.
abel1502 said:
Any ideas about post #8771264?
It is customary to wait until after the post is deleted before asking. There is still a chance your post will be approved before the three days are up.
Blank_User said:
The score is irrelevant. Users can upvote or downvote posts for any reason, including things that have nothing to do with art quality, so it’s not a good metric to determine whether something should be approved.
That was merely a point I gave to the post's credit, I'm more bewildered by the fact all of the approvers that even bothered to interact with it came to the conclusion that it should stay deleted. If this post is bad enough to stay deleted, then the other two parent-child posts should be flagged, because the differences are as minute as an eye variant, I'd like to know exactly why they have no interest in approving this single post specifically.
