Donmai

AI-generated art check thread

Posted under General

Shiocchi said:

This might not be the correct thread for this, but everything in juejue's tag is AI generated, and are tagged as such on Pixiv. I don't want to have to flag each individual one, so can someone delete them all?

Although those tags were not added by the artist themselves, if you actually look at any of their art there is clear AI editing going on, especially in the hands. You can basically pick them out at random and spot it in every image after post #6088792. Like, it's an extremely obvious artstyle shift.

I'm going to tag most of them AI-assisted because they're obviously also edited. I don't know if this is in that grey area of "not edited enough" or whatever, but not tagging it at least assisted would be obviously incorrect. Especially for the nude ones. The ones with clothes seems to be edited even more or not even AI at all.

Marlor said:

It is, and yet again, you can easily check it by opening photoshop or another editing program and playing with the contrast settings. It'll show you tons of noises, which would never be there if it were a real painting.
See this example: https://danbooru.donmai.us/forum_posts/241342

https://files.catbox.moe/e88oso.png

The result is completely different from this one. At high contrast and steep curves, besides the polka dots, I see a fine grain, which is more like a filter, plus color banding due to low bit depth. If no noise is shown after this much manipulation I don't think there is any noise in this. Unless you were referring to JPEG artefacts which would not be present if you downloaded the full-size image to edit.

PSD: https://files.catbox.moe/z7gff2.psd

BTW, as a control group, I applied exactly the same Adjustment Masks to the picture used in forum #241342. This is the result and you can see it does reveal the noise and patterns.

https://files.catbox.moe/uvh3ub.png
https://files.catbox.moe/2fqfxe.psd

Updated

8253803 said:

https://files.catbox.moe/e88oso.png

The result is completely different from this one. At high contrast and steep curves, besides the polka dots, I see a fine grain, which is more like a filter, plus color banding due to low bit depth. If no noise is shown after this much manipulation I don't think there is any noise in this. Unless you were referring to JPEG artefacts which would not be present if you downloaded the full-size image to edit.

PSD: https://files.catbox.moe/z7gff2.psd

BTW, as a control group, I applied exactly the same Adjustment Masks to the picture used in forum #241342. This is the result and you can see it does reveal the noise and patterns.

https://files.catbox.moe/uvh3ub.png
https://files.catbox.moe/2fqfxe.psd

Look at the hair, there're exact the same noises

1 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 138