Hi, just want to ask what exactly is wrong with post #5554148.
Posted under General
Hi, just want to ask what exactly is wrong with post #5554148.
BaraStuff19 said:
Hi, just want to ask what exactly is wrong with post #5554148.
Hi, just looking at it. I think the guy on top has his butt twisted too much towards the viewer. Like he's distorting his hips a bit. (Could just be really flexible?)
And the bottom guys left leg might be too big? (It looks wider then the right leg) Would be my guess.
post #5556980
post #5551327
post #5550190
What is the reason for these being removed? Is it because it's in black and white/one color?
skywalkerred said:
post #5556980
post #5551327
post #5550190
What is the reason for these being removed? Is it because it's in black and white/one color?
Greyscale/monochrome stuff is fine if it looks good. These pieces are just kinda mediocre.
skywalkerred said:
I would have approved this post if Paimon was more detailed, it brings down an already borderline post.
skywalkerred said:
post #5551327
post #5550190
What is the reason for these being removed? Is it because it's in black and white/one color?
I think this artist is just mediocre overall, even their approved posts would probably not survive a flag.
whats the deal with this one being unapproved? post #5552518
incubatedveg said:
whats the deal with this one being unapproved? post #5552518
My guess would be the feet looks too sketchy, specifically the toes... also is she being hurt? Is this ryona? If so that will turn most approvers off. But mostly this is just meh tbh.
Dunno why this adorable chibi art would be rejected.
I've been wondering why these posts were not approved, any feedback would be appreciated.
post #5568937
post #5568938
post #5569130
and this one.
So, there's this obscure manga that I love a lot and it isn't getting any representation. Over two years ago, I created the new copyright tag and posted five images. Only one got approved. Now, most of these pics were pages taken directly from the manga, so I understand why they got deleted in hindsight. Anyways, fast forward to today... I posted four new images of some fairly high quality fan art. But not only did all four of them get rejected, all four of them got UNANIMOUSLY rejected by all seven approvers.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5572891
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5572919
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5572925
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5572930
None of these pictures are perfect. One has ridiculous boob anatomy, one has weird fish eyes that are way too far apart from each other, one is kinda blurry (I think it was painted?), and one is just all around the most "okay" piece of art ever, But still... really? None of these are good enough? At this point, you might as well just delete the only one that DID get approved, because it honestly shouldn't have been approved in the first place and then you can at least get rid of the misleading tag that shows 9 pics but really only has one.
Same artist & style as post #5574773 (honestly, even better anatomy)...
could I get some feedback on these three?
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5572354
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5573235
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5573236
ion288 said:
Some good quality posts will likely get dropped since they arent very interesting.
It's not great to tell uploaders that things don't get approved due to being "uninteresting". Art just needs to be good to approved. It doesn't need to be unique or "special". We have unrestricted users who upload nothing but big boob touhou pics. Yes, there are biased for and against certain subjects, mediums, and fetishes, but the biggest issue is by far the flooded queue.
Saying things like "it's not interesting" is something I have railed against in this thread before. If that's the only reason an approver can come up for something not being approved, it's likely that it was simply missed in the deluge of anime pics. They're the most likely candidates for appeal.
Runty said:
Dunno why this adorable chibi art would be rejected.
Although it's a chibi, it tried to ride the line between simple and well-shaded. The shading is not good, though. Things can be cute and still not be approvable. Same with any other emotion.
myhm said:
Anything in particular with these?
post #5563896
post #5563900
There's enough weird anatomy, like her neck, and weak shading throughout.
skywalkerred said:
post #5569362
Seriously, what was wrong with this post?post #5569130
and this one.
First: Weak shading and weaker linework.
Second: 3d models are much harder to get approved, especially when it's a major game like Genshin. Genshin's models can be ripped and posed in-engine, so 3d models are viewed with much greater scrutiny. You can tell that's the case with this one due to the hair and clothing details.
MegaFlare said:
A common error for these kinds of pictures:
Bad spines.
TotallyKyle said:
So, there's this obscure manga that I love a lot and it isn't getting any representation. Over two years ago, I created the new copyright tag and posted five images. Only one got approved. Now, most of these pics were pages taken directly from the manga, so I understand why they got deleted in hindsight. Anyways, fast forward to today... I posted four new images of some fairly high quality fan art. But not only did all four of them get rejected, all four of them got UNANIMOUSLY rejected by all seven approvers.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5572891
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5572919
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5572925
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5572930None of these pictures are perfect. One has ridiculous boob anatomy, one has weird fish eyes that are way too far apart from each other, one is kinda blurry (I think it was painted?), and one is just all around the most "okay" piece of art ever, But still... really? None of these are good enough? At this point, you might as well just delete the only one that DID get approved, because it honestly shouldn't have been approved in the first place and then you can at least get rid of the misleading tag that shows 9 pics but really only has one.
Answering this on its own because it needs to be parted out...
First and foremost, posting something on Danbooru "for recognition" is not the purpose of the site. Go to MAL and make a forum post, make a DeviantArt account, shill on Twitter. Danbooru is a curated repository of anime art and fanart. It is not a signal-boosting platform for your favorite whatever. If you do want to get the word out, so to speak, commission a good artist and post that, not pages from the manga.
Next, those images are not high quality. The first one is pretty borderline, but has odd anatomy issues (her lower body is weirdly small) and the mirror isn't working properly. The second and third also have some minor anatomy glitches and awkward posing. The fourth is just outright amateurish.
"unanimously rejected by all seven approvers" shows that you, despite being here for years, don't know how the site works. On a typical day-to-day basis, there are about 20-25 active approvers. Overall, on a less frequent basis, that number doubles.
It takes exactly one approver for an image to be approved. One. Out of nearly 50 active ones.
I'm certain a fair portion of them just didn't see the image, but that's still a lot of people. Keep in mind that approvers are not required to actually click the rejection button. They can simply move on to the next post.
Further, looking at your other uploads, it seems you're letting your love of the manga cloud your judgment. As I said previously, you can like something without it being uploadable. I skip plenty of harpy pics that I actively like for many issues, both minor and major. And, yes, I think a lot of your approved posts would not survive a flag. There's even a traced image in there.
Lastly, your tagging. This is not related to your images getting approver or not, but it needs to be said as it's a major cornerstone of the site. You're both undertagging and overtagging at the same time. Remember to not tag canon when possible. You're using the superhero tag on naked characters and strong on characters curled up in bed. But you're also missing simple tags like hair color and gender count. Try going through the howto:tag checklist.