Donmai

How do I tag this?

Posted under Tags

Brightlight said:

Which tags should I use for cup instant udon (like Maruchan Akai Kitsune udon)? We have the tag "cup ramen" but don't have "cup udon".

Cup_udon? Though to be honest I don't see why they shouldn't be tagged instant_udon as well.

The rule in the instant_ramen wiki about not using it for cup_ramen is kind of dumb, and I'd much prefer to treat cup ramen as a subset. That wiki was written by a user with zero forum activity and very few contributions to date, so I don't regard it as authoritative. Judging by the results of a cup_ramen instant_ramen search, a lot of taggers simply disregard this rule anyway, so there's an argument to be made for doing away with it altogether.

The only past forum discussion I've seen on the subject of instant noodles was topic #4920, and that mostly pertained to the problem of implicating ramen when you can't see the contents of the cup, so we don't really have any precedent to go by here.

Flummoxen said:

Should I tag Touhou's wriggle_nightbug as arthropod_girl?

Tagging arthropod_girl just because a girl has antennae is like tagging elf just because she has pointy ears, or tagging vampire just because she has fangs. I'm very much against tagging arthropod_girl on drawings of Wriggle when she's basically a human whose only insectile feature looks like it's being worn as an accessory. Save that tag for images with something more, like post #4913685.

Updated by DanbooruBot

The_Bob said:

Do we tag triforce even if it's a non-Zelda-related three-triangle pattern (as in post #5028089)? Do we have a "generic triforce" pattern tag?

I'm not sure but I wouldn't tag your example triforce in any case because the three triangles are merely a part of a random triangle pattern.

Edit: I removed the tag from this post. I'm pretty sure this isn't what someone searching triforce is looking for.

Updated by DanbooruBot

Laudividni said:

Edit: Examples post #4975339, post #4979682, post #4466511, post #4653452 and post #4966337.

Should posts where present characters appear in multiple series and the artwork is clearly about one specific, contain all the copyright tags regardless? The Fate franchise is an example, sometimes I want to search for the copyright to find specific Koha-ace, CCC or Stay Night art, but I find Grand Order or other stuff.

Bump. In addition, you don't tag all three Fate routes on posts with the characters of the fifth holy grail war. If you search for Heaven's Feel, you find Heaven's Feel art, same should happen with the rest of the franchise. Also, the Fate (series) tag serves as an umbrella, same as Artoria Pendragon does.

But I want to see opinions from others before doing anything major and messaging people adding the unrelated copyright tags.

Updated by DanbooruBot

post #5032649 - Think it's a dildo based on the pixiv gallery tags, another image in the gallery, and the color of the "dick." It's tricky because judging based on other images in the same gallery isn't very relevant for tagging what you see but the dick is a very different shade of skin tone BUT that's not uncommon to see.

Updated by DanbooruBot

About cup instant udon:

iridescent_slime said:

The rule in the instant_ramen wiki about not using it for cup_ramen is kind of dumb, and I'd much prefer to treat cup ramen as a subset. That wiki was written by a user with zero forum activity and very few contributions to date, so I don't regard it as authoritative. Judging by the results of a cup_ramen instant_ramen search, a lot of taggers simply disregard this rule anyway, so there's an argument to be made for doing away with it altogether.

I agree with you. I checked the search results for instant_ramen and found 90% of them are cup ramens.
Moreover, 60% of them were not tagged as cup_ramen. I wonder if we need cup_ramen tag...

Updated by DanbooruBot