Pointless Pools

Hillside_Moose said:

Tagging any instance of groping when the tag is supposed to reference the phrase is just unnecessary noise. post #1492821 you could claim Kongou's starting up the phrase, but that's really stretching it.

On closer inspection, the Pixiv commentary on post #1500116 may imply a legitimate reference, so I added the raw commentary and commentary_request tag. I removed the it's_ok_to_touch tag from post #1492821, as there didn't seem to be similar support from the Pixiv commentary or artist tags there.

pool #5611 - imouto. It's just full of pictures of little girls. It's like putting everything under chartags:3 + Suwako, Kanako and Sanae into the Moriya family pool.

MagicalAsparagus said:

pool #5611 - imouto. It's just full of pictures of little girls. It's like putting everything under chartags:3 + Suwako, Kanako and Sanae into the Moriya family pool.

While it doesn't seem that anyone's paid attention to it for quite a while, the pool does seem to follow the common theme of having characters that are clearly younger sisters or acting like one at the very least. I don't see any pictures of girls who aren't acting as or shown (or known) to be younger sister in the pool. The only problems I see with it are that it's underpopulated and a good number of the pictures that are just of kyon no imouto don't really belong.

pool #8256 - That's WAY too gross

"pool #1351 - TOO SCARRING CANNOT UNSEE" should be sufficient. Dunno...

game2009 said:

pool #8256 - That's WAY too gross

"pool #1351 - TOO SCARRING CANNOT UNSEE" should be sufficient. Dunno...

I don't think the single post in the pool is really a "cannot unsee" type of thing. But I agree this pool doesn't need to be. A description that doesn't really tell what it's about but only what it's not about, the content of the only picture in the pool is not even in the same ballpark as the grossest stuff on this site, the pool only contains a single picture and is way too subjective.

Horrifyingly gross would more be karuami_ruku, not that there's anything there right now.
http://justicers.sakura.ne.jp/semahiro/karuami.html

pool #8242

Can be replaced with a nagamon_(meme) (or something to that effect) tag.

pool #8296 - Pokemon - Eeveelution

Tags should be enough, I think.

pool #8290 - 404 not found

Vague and pointless pool.

upupu said:

pool #8290 - 404 not found

Vague and pointless pool.

Seems like it's a pool for posts that look like 404 pages.

Wiimeiser said:

Seems like it's a pool for posts that look like 404 pages.

But what "looks like a 404 page"? That's really vague, you could use any image you want on a 404 page if you wanted.

Toks said:

But what "looks like a 404 page"? That's really vague, you could use any image you want on a 404 page if you wanted.

We even have a 404 tag for actual 404 images.

pool #8309 or pool #8154 should be deleted, they are the exactly the same.

pool #7426 - Kantai Collection - It's OK to touch...

Moved to tag it's ok to touch, and the only post in the pool has already been tagged.

pool #8302 - Kantai Collection - Shitty Admiral should be deleted, i think pool #6282 - Trolling is enough.

pool #8242 - Nagamon Collection
Taggable with just nagamon. Qualifier if needed.

Kadoya said:

pool #8242 - Nagamon Collection
Taggable with just nagamon. Qualifier if needed.

Beat you to the punch :-)

Ironbottom said:

pool #8242

Can be replaced with a nagamon_(meme) (or something to that effect) tag.

The reason I made Nagamon a pool instead of a tag is because "silliness" isn't exactly objective.

pool #8338 Kantai Collection - Good Work Admiral!

"The exact opposite of pool #8302"

Are counter-pools allowed?

Hoobajoob said:

pool #8338 Kantai Collection - Good Work Admiral!

Are counter-pools allowed?

All popular franchises in the last years got such a huge a amount of worthless pools. (touhou, madoka, attack on titan and now kancolle)
I'm sure if people want to search for the concept of doing a "good job", or a "shitty job" at something, we can create tags for them.
But even then, I don't see the unifying theme in that pool. because they don't even adhere to the pool's rules. I could take random kancolle comic posts and get the same result.

(yes, I think both pools shouldn't exist)