Donmai

Pointless Pools

Posted under General

Hillside_Moose said:
pool #6474 - Tall Dark and Bishoujo

We TV Tropes now. But seriously, it's yet another favorites pool with a theme, and we're supposed to be cutting down on those (forum #69115).

Seconding to delete this pool. I also don't see a need for more pools based on TV Tropes pages, especially those that can be done with a simple tag search.

Kikimaru said:
pool #3683
Pool: Curvy bellies
Bellies with a nice curve to them without being fat or pregnant.

Can just as easily be covered by big_belly -fat/big_belly -pregnant and/or not using big_belly for fat/pregnant pics.

I think belly would be a better choice of tag than big_belly. The former actually has a significant number of posts already, and the latter doesn't really seem any different from it. Also, a lot of the bellies in that pool can't really be described as "big".
I agree that the pool would be pointless, once it's tagged with belly.

Toks said:
I think belly would be a better choice of tag than big_belly. The former actually has a significant number of posts already, and the latter doesn't really seem any different from it. Also, a lot of the bellies in that pool can't really be described as "big".
I agree that the pool would be pointless, once it's tagged with belly.

I did not know we had a belly tag.
In that case, I revise my statement:

Remove the pool, but reserve big_belly for ... well, big bellies. Tag everything else with belly.

Why aren't pointless Touhou pools like these deleted yet?

Motherly Yuuka
pool #6274

Mama Shinki
pool #6297

Trollsuke
pool #6282

This isn't the matter of whether or not those pics can be found using tags, but it's that those portrayals aren't widespread. Pools shouldn't be made simply because there exists those kinds of pics. At this rate, someone can see a pic of Unzan being fatherly to Ichirin and thus make a pool called "Fatherly Unzan" or something like that.

Updated

1 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 100 170