The bulk update request #31824 (forum #308955) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
Posted under Tags
The bulk update request #31824 (forum #308955) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
BUR #33023 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
create implication nicole_(computer)_(sonic) -> nicole_(sonic)
create implication nicole_the_holo-lynx -> nicole_(sonic)
Two forms of the same character.
BUR #33024 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
create implication knuckles_(series) -> sonic_(live_action)
create implication sonic_spinball -> sonic_the_hedgehog_(classic)
create implication dr._robotnik's_mean_bean_machine -> adventures_of_sonic_the_hedgehog
Knuckles is a series in the Live Action Sonic universe, and Sonic Spinball is a classic era game. Plus another missing implication - I don't think Bean Machine should imply Classic given its circumstances.
Updated
BUR #33025 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
remove implication sonic_advance_2 -> sonic_(series)
remove implication sonic_advance_3 -> sonic_(series)
create implication sonic_advance -> sonic_advance_(series)
create implication sonic_advance_2 -> sonic_advance_(series)
create implication sonic_advance_3 -> sonic_advance_(series)
create implication sonic_advance_(series) -> sonic_(series)
Probably about time we fix this too.
Trouble_Windows said:
BUR #33024 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
create implication knuckles_(series) -> sonic_(live_action)
create implication sonic_spinball -> sonic_the_hedgehog_(classic)
create implication dr._robotnik's_mean_bean_machine -> adventures_of_sonic_the_hedgehogI don't think Bean Machine should imply Classic given its circumstances.
Shouldn't Mean Bean Machine instead be implicated to adventures_of_sonic_the_hedgehog since it's a reskin based on that cartoon?
zetsubousensei said:
Shouldn't Mean Bean Machine instead be implicated to adventures_of_sonic_the_hedgehog since it's a reskin based on that cartoon?
Yeah, that works I think. I wasn't sure what exactly to point the implication to.
Trouble_Windows said:
BUR #33025 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
remove implication sonic_advance_2 -> sonic_(series)
remove implication sonic_advance_3 -> sonic_(series)
create implication sonic_advance -> sonic_advance_(series)
create implication sonic_advance_2 -> sonic_advance_(series)
create implication sonic_advance_3 -> sonic_advance_(series)
create implication sonic_advance_(series) -> sonic_(series)Probably about time we fix this too.
Uh, matey? Does Sonic Rush Adventure needed to be implied with it's predecessor? Is it necessary to do so? I'm just wondering about it.
zerotoinfinity said:
Uh, matey? Does Sonic Rush Adventure needed to be implied with it's predecessor? Is it necessary to do so? I'm just wondering about it.
Don't think so, we only really do that for spinoffs in totally different genres and subseries. Sonic Adventure 2 isn't implied to Sonic Adventure.
Trouble_Windows said:
Don't think so, we only really do that for spinoffs in totally different genres and subseries. Sonic Adventure 2 isn't implied to Sonic Adventure.
Oh, OK... I see your point, then.
The bulk update request #33023 (forum #316733) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
The bulk update request #33024 (forum #316734) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
The bulk update request #33025 (forum #316735) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
BUR #38759 has been approved by @Hillside_Moose.
create implication blaze_the_cat_(bassist) -> blaze_the_cat
create implication silver_the_hedgehog_(rockstar) -> silver_the_hedgehog
New costume
The bulk update request #38759 (forum #341964) has been approved by @Hillside_Moose.
BUR #39025 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
create implication sonic_the_hedgehog_(pirate) -> sonic_the_hedgehog
create implication sonic_the_hedgehog_(karate) -> sonic_the_hedgehog
create implication silver_the_hedgehog_(postman) -> silver_the_hedgehog
create implication silver_the_hedgehog_(nutcracker) -> silver_the_hedgehog
create implication silver_the_hedgehog_(butler) -> silver_the_hedgehog
More overlooked ones. I have to look and see if I can fond any more floating around.
Edit: Think that's all of em.
The bulk update request #39025 (forum #342875) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
BUR #39836 is pending approval.
create implication gnarly_knuckles -> knuckles_the_echidna
create implication knuckles_the_dread -> knuckles_the_echidna
create implication renegade_knucks -> knuckles_the_echidna
create implication nine_(sonic) -> tails_(sonic)
create implication sails_(sonic) -> tails_(sonic)
create implication mangey_(sonic) -> tails_(sonic)
create implication rebel_rouge -> rouge_the_bat
create implication thorn_rose -> amy_rose
create implication black_rose_(sonic_prime) -> amy_rose
create implication rusty_rose -> amy_rose
create implication mr._dr._eggman -> dr._eggman
create implication dr._deep -> dr._eggman
create implication dr._done-it -> dr._eggman
create implication dr._babble -> dr._eggman
create implication dr._don't -> dr._eggman
create implication birdie_(boscage_maze)_(sonic) -> birdie_(sonic)
The alternate dimension versions of the characters in Sonic Prime should probably imply their original selves, since they're for the most part just given an outfit swap and maybe some minor physical differences (Nine having spiky hair that sticks up, for example).
BUR #39837 is pending approval.
create implication sinbad_(sonic) -> knuckles_the_echidna
Also, a Knuckles variant from Sonic and the Secret Rings - since the Black Knight characters are implied, he probably should be as well.
BUR #39838 is pending approval.
create implication chao_tales -> sonic_(series)
Trouble_Windows said:
BUR #39836 is pending approval.
create implication gnarly_knuckles -> knuckles_the_echidna
create implication knuckles_the_dread -> knuckles_the_echidna
create implication renegade_knucks -> knuckles_the_echidna
create implication nine_(sonic) -> tails_(sonic)
create implication sails_(sonic) -> tails_(sonic)
create implication mangey_(sonic) -> tails_(sonic)
create implication rebel_rouge -> rouge_the_bat
create implication thorn_rose -> amy_rose
create implication black_rose_(sonic_prime) -> amy_rose
create implication rusty_rose -> amy_rose
create implication mr._dr._eggman -> dr._eggman
create implication dr._deep -> dr._eggman
create implication dr._done-it -> dr._eggman
create implication dr._babble -> dr._eggman
create implication dr._don't -> dr._eggman
create implication birdie_(boscage_maze)_(sonic) -> birdie_(sonic)The alternate dimension versions of the characters in Sonic Prime should probably imply their original selves, since they're for the most part just given an outfit swap and maybe some minor physical differences (Nine having spiky hair that sticks up, for example).
I understand the reasoning for linking variants, but I disagree that implying the Sonic Prime alternates to their main counterparts is the best approach here.
The proposal notes minor physical differences, but several variants diverge significantly!
While technically multiverse variants of Eggman in lore, the Chaos Council members (Dr. Deep, Dr. Don't, Dr. Done-It, Dr. Babble) don't share their likeness or name with Dr. Eggman (excepting Mr. Dr. Eggman). Implying these distinct characters to `dr._eggman` would clutter search results for users using the dr._eggman tag to look for pictures of Eggman (which would presumably be all users searching that tag). And Rusty Rose is also significantly different – she's a cyborg in which only half of her head resembles Amy. She's closer to a Metal Amy than Amy proper.
Even for the other characters like Black Rose or Thorn Rose, they're different characters in the series, not just the original Amy Rose in costume. They share a surname and base design, but that's it. More importantly for tagging utility, treating them as separate tags without implication aligns better with how other distinct character iterations or multiverse variants are often handled (e.g., different Mega Men like Mega Man, X, MegaMan.EXE, Mega Man Volnutt, and Star Force Mega Man, or Marvel variants like Sylvie Laufeydottir not implying Loki). This reflects their unique identities within the tagging system, even with narrative links.
Furthermore, implying them creates search problems. If you wanted to find pictures of both Amy Rose and Black Rose together, the implication `black_rose_(sonic_prime) -> amy_rose` would make the search `amy_rose black_rose_(sonic_prime)` return all Black Rose images. You'd need extra tags like `dual_persona` just to filter, which is unnecessarily complex. A direct search `amy_rose black_rose_(sonic_prime)` works perfectly well without the implication.
Cross-referencing these variants is already effectively handled by listing them on the main characters' wiki pages. This provides discoverability without forcing tag implications that hinder precision and usability.
I believe keeping these Sonic Prime variants as separate, non-implied tags is the more practical approach.
Updated