Donmai

(Imply and Rename) - TUYU's songs

Posted under Tags

Kymil

BUR #24434 has been rejected.

Show

create implication yappari_ame_wa_furunda_ne -> tuyu_(band)
create implication kazekaoru_sora_no_shita -> tuyu_(band)
create implication asagao_no_chiru_koro_ni_(tuyu) -> tuyu_(band)
create implication ano_yo_iki_no_bus_ni_notte_saraba -> tuyu_(band)
create implication taiyou_ni_nareru_ka_na -> tuyu_(band)
create implication kuraberarekko -> tuyu_(band)
create implication rock_na_kimi_to_wa_owakare_da -> tuyu_(band)
create implication namikare_(tuyu) -> tuyu_(band)
create implication damonisch -> tuyu_(band)
create implication kako_ni_torawareteiru_(tuyu) -> tuyu_(band)
create implication dorei_janai_nara_nan_desu_ka -> tuyu_(band)
create implication loser_girl_(tuyu) -> tuyu_(band)
create implication ame_wo_abiru_(tuyu) -> tuyu_(band)
create implication chuuken_hachi_(tuyu) -> tuyu_(band)
create implication kakurenbocchi -> tuyu_(band)
create implication doro_no_bunzai_de_watashi_dake_no_taisetsu_wo_ubaou_da_nante -> tuyu_(band)
create implication shuuten_no_saki_ga_aru_to_suru_naraba_(tuyu) -> tuyu_(band)
create implication under_kids -> tuyu_(band)
create implication under_heroine_(tuyu) -> tuyu_(band)
create implication itsuka_otona_ni_nareru_to_ii_ne. -> tuyu_(band)
create implication ama_mo_yo_(tuyu) -> tuyu_(band)
create implication rainfall_(tuyu) -> tuyu_(band)
create implication kore_dakara_yamerannai!_(tuyu) -> tuyu_(band)
create implication donna_ketsumatsu_ga_onozomi_dai_(tuyu) -> tuyu_(band)
create alias angel_chan_(tuyu) -> tenshi_chan_(tuyu)
create alias under_kids -> under_kids_(tuyu)

All of those tags refer to songs created by TUYU, therefore thy should all be linked to it.

  • "Angel-chan" is the english translation of the fan-given name "Tenshi-chan". (Although I do not know whether this tag should be kept or not, as every other song from the band does not have a character tag.)
  • "Under Kids" may be confusing if it doesn't contain the name of the band associated with it. (Here too, I do not know if the "_(tuyu)" part should be put on every song's tag or only the easier-to-confuse ones.)
Reply
John Reality Red Terror John Hopfield avidbookreader Asht Unbreakable magcolo
magcolo

Band tags are supposed to be used for posts depicting the band members, not to catch their songs.

(the following is addressed to everyone, because this is the Nth time we've had a thread like this, but none of them is able to answer the concerns I or other users have repeatedly explained under every thread, and new requests kept coming despite everything)

related previous: topic #16874, topic #21922, topic #23196, topic #23959, topic #24634, topic #25915, topic #26347
We could change, there's currently a whole discussion about music tagging going on, but progress is negligible because there're a lot of things involved and many revisions needed, and we either can't come to an agreement or straight-up don't know how to handle it so everyone stopped replying to the conversation. If you want to make a request, answer the questions first. If you don't have solutions don't make another new request despite everything said just because it's your favorite music for nothing… It'll just get ignored and automatically rejected after 45 days.

Characters from songs don't have any real consistency and I'd say people just don't care enough to discuss them. One of the concerns is there're probably a thousand of them if we consider tagging them. Currently the ones that do get tagged are usually named, creator mascots, or story characters. The edgier the design the more likely they'll have fans giving them names and tagging them, especially the rise of some recent producers bring a retro trend. Maybe we'll get to them after the music tagging mess is resolved.

Updated

Reply
Kymil

Characters from songs don't have any real consistency and I'd say people just don't care enough to discuss them. One of the concerns is there're probably a thousand of them if we consider tagging them. Currently the ones that do get tagged are usually named, creator mascots, or story characters.

Perhaps then angel_chan_(tuyu) can be deprecated or nuked?

Reply
1