How do I tag this?

provence said:

If only the upper half is shown, then it should be topless, because you can tell for sure she isn't wearing anything at her upper half. It's the more accurate tag here.

No, it should be nude + upper body. The important thing with topless is that there has to be a bottom visible.

EB said:

No, it should be nude + upper body. The important thing with topless is that there has to be a bottom visible.

But eh well, the topless wiki does only mention the special case of the mermaid. So to make this clear, it should edited...?
And edited. So if I get this correct, topless is mutually exclusive to upper body if there is only one character.

provence said:

That doesn't sound that intuitive to be honest.
But eh well, the topless wiki does only mention the special case of the mermaid. So to make this clear, it should edited...?

Maybe there should be a clarifying discussion on this. IMO topless does not make sense without a bottom being worn (which is part of why mermaid is considered differently) just as bottomless does not make sense without a top being worn.

Flandre5carlet said:

Can an image qualify both for style_parody and for official_style?
post #2706899 is in the style of the original Hokuto no Ken anime and contains references to both the original series and another series.

I consider them to be mutually exclusive, with official style being a character drawn in the official style of their own copyright, not the style of another copyright.

EB said:

No, it should be nude + upper body. The important thing with topless is that there has to be a bottom visible.

EB said:

Maybe there should be a clarifying discussion on this. IMO topless does not make sense without a bottom being worn (which is part of why mermaid is considered differently) just as bottomless does not make sense without a top being worn.

That's exactly how I've been using it all this time and I agree with everything you said. On a related note, I've seen a lot of posts tagged with both bottomless and no panties which if I remember correctly are mutually exclusive.

post #2708040
What is the tag for the one-handed, two-finger gesture with the thumb and pinky out but the rest of the fingers closed? I couldn't find it in tag group:gestures

shaka sign: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shaka_sign.

Unbreakable said:
On a related note, I've seen a lot of posts tagged with both bottomless and no panties which if I remember correctly are mutually exclusive.

Just taking a look at the first few posts out of curiosity, something like post #2707477 could cause some confusion. Wearing a shirt and no bottom wear, so technically it should be bottomless. But the shirt is long enough that it seems it would completely cover her crotch if buttoned up (the visual looks similar enough to character wearing a short dress of that length where it would count as no panties instead).

post #2707732

Should this have the meta tag?

post #2708451
Is Anchovy wearing a black_apron?

EB said:

Just taking a look at the first few posts out of curiosity, something like post #2707477 could cause some confusion. Wearing a shirt and no bottom wear, so technically it should be bottomless. But the shirt is long enough that it seems it would completely cover her crotch if buttoned up (the visual looks similar enough to character wearing a short dress of that length where it would count as no panties instead).

While I can understand how that could cause some confusion, posts should really only be tagged with one or the other (except in cases with multiple people of course). Pictures with naked shirts usually have them long enough to cover the crotch but technically should be bottomless so it could be tricky.

should i tag monochrome in post #2708688? But it has blue color in the first panel.

natartnat said:

should i tag monochrome in post #2708688? But it has blue color in the first panel.

Probably yes.
monochrome + spot_color if no one objects.

provence. said:

post #2708451
Is Anchovy wearing a black_apron?

I'd say that she is.
________

A bunch from post #2704804:
Is the wand hanging from the ceiling from Sailor Moon? It kinda looks like the Spiral Heart Moon Rod.
Who is the man in the poster?
Who are the character figures in the glass case next to the poster?

post #2708854
Is she actually pregnant or just drawn that way?
Also, I'm not sure what breast size tag I should use.

provence. said:

Probably yes.
monochrome + spot_color if no one objects.

Yeah, that's spot color, since it's only one particular piece that's colored.

thx all
can I put post #2711996 in current event pool? cause it resembles with Mr.Grape the penguin and Fate/GO events.

Is there a term or suitable tags for a sex position where the receiving partner is being horizontally held in the air? Like post #2712753?

What is the wandlike object being held in post #2712866? I have a feeling it might be shinto related.

Elfaleon said:

What is the wandlike object being held in post #2712866?

shakujou

post #2716383
What's the food in the third panel?