Donmai

Danbooru 2 Issues Topic

Posted under General

This topic has been locked.

Unbreakable

Randeel said:

So apparently after the last small update you can see every single small tag change on a post.
This is how cluttered and dumb you can make it look http://danbooru.donmai.us/post_versions?search%5Bpost_id%5D=2644335 if you really wanted to, while technically you aren't vandalising.

This seems really annoying since I have a bad habit of remembering a few more tags for an image right after I hit submit, sometimes 3-4 times in a row for a single image. So it feels like this would make it look like I'm trying to raise my "Post Changes" counter when in fact I'm just bad at remembering stuff.

Type-kun said:

Well, then I can't say it was a good decision. Not sure what the "headaches" were, but it should be re-enabled IMO.

Couldn't agree more, the old way looks and feels so much better.

BrokenEagle98

Unbreakable said:

This seems really annoying since I have a bad habit of remembering a few more tags for an image right after I hit submit, sometimes 3-4 times in a row for a single image. So it feels like this would make it look like I'm trying to raise my "Post Changes" counter when in fact I'm just bad at remembering stuff.

Same here... this puts more pressure on me to perfectly tag the image on the first go, as I hate creating superfluous versions.

I also know that there are lots of people that hate the upload UI or want to upload more quickly, so they tag minimally on the upload page and then finish tagging on the post page.

user 460797

That is a pretty bad change. If really every tag change is recorded, then users are constantly getting a post change +1. Don't know, but what was the intention? It will create more confusion and longer post change lists under each post :/.

GiantCaveMushroom

This just seems to make post history cluttered. Should someone make a typo and immediately fix it, it will create two records for changing one minor tag. Images with a lot of detail that can have hundreds of tags will have a nightmarish post change history, especially if a user, like me, tend to add one tag at a time as they notice new small details after they hit 'submit'.

Imagine if someone tags every little detail of, say, posts like post #2149746 a few tags a time (like I did before). The post history will be nightmarishly long and impossible to read.

edit: ugh, checking the box for commentary_request when adding artist commentary adds a new record too.

Updated

BrokenEagle98

Just thought about this, but this is going to completely skew the statistics for the user reports, both mine and the official one on Isshiki. Uploaders that usually tag minimally on the upload yet more fully on the post page are going to show up as having extremely bad tagging numbers, even though they are actually doing a good job of tagging their posts afterwards.

user 460797

454 Temporary service failure
app/models/dmail.rb:181:in `send_dmail'
app/models/dmail.rb:51:in `block in create_split'
app/models/dmail.rb:47:in `create_split'
app/controllers/dmails_controller.rb:42:in `create'

and that after trying to mention said user via the @ mention:

454 Temporary service failure
app/models/dmail.rb:181:in `send_dmail'
app/logical/mentionable.rb:63:in `block in queue_mention_messages'
app/logical/mentionable.rb:52:in `each'
app/logical/mentionable.rb:52:in `queue_mention_messages'
app/controllers/forum_posts_controller.rb:48:in `create'

Don't know, but is it really possible to block users completely? Couldn't find that option anywhere and it only happens to one user.

BrokenEagle98

@Provence

It's failing because those users have e-mail notifications and for some reason Danbooru is failing at sending the DMail notice to them by email. Specifically, it's failing at the following line:

UserMailer.dmail_notice(self).deliver_now

However, if I'm reading the code correctly, at the point that the error is occurring, the DMail should have still been successfully sent to them. Still, I'll open up an issue on GitHub regarding this.

Edit:

Created issue #2904.

Updated

CodeKyuubi

Disregarding efficiency, it (tag history) always used to be like this, especially back when 1-tag-uploading wasn't an issue. It's never bothered me because I tag as best I can before uploading.

Edit: Added (tag history) because people are talking about e-mails now.

Updated

evazion

`454 Temporary service failure` is an error from the Amazon service that Danbooru uses to send email. Amazon is in the middle of a huge outage at the moment, all kinds of sites are having problems right now.

Rastamepas

Aww people are complaining because it's clearly visible when people are being shitty uploaders who can do nothing more than 3 tag upload?

I'm glad the change went through. So it can show who actually gives a shit about their uploading ethics. This is how it was 3-4 years ago and it worked just fine.

user 460797

Rastamepas said:

Aww people are complaining because it's clearly visible when people are being shitty uploaders who can do nothing more than 3 tag upload?

I'm glad the change went through. So it can show who actually gives a shit about their uploading ethics. This is how it was 3-4 years ago and it worked just fine.

If it really is such a big problem for you that people are only adding around 3 tags before uploading, then please create a forum topic. There is currently no guideline in place that says that you have to put x number of tags before you upload.

Rastamepas

BrokenEagle98 said:

Just thought about this, but this is going to completely skew the statistics for the user reports, both mine and the official one on Isshiki. Uploaders that usually tag minimally on the upload yet more fully on the post page are going to show up as having extremely bad tagging numbers, even though they are actually doing a good job of tagging their posts afterwards.

Also since I read this after the fact I'll respond in a separate post. IT SHOULD show that the people have bad tagging numbers because they are assholes who don't fully tag before uploading.

Rastamepas

Provence said:

If it really is such a big problem for you that people are only adding around 3 tags before uploading, then please create a forum topic. There is currently no guideline in place that says that you have to put x number of tags before you upload.

Because the admins won't do anything about it. I'm still going to gripe because honestly I can't stand people who do it because they are the scum of the site.

user 460797

Rastamepas said:

Because the admins won't do anything about it. I'm still going to gripe because honestly I can't stand people who do it because they are the scum of the site.

I can ensure you that the admins did something about around 11 months ago. But it wasn't by your liking doesn't mean that nobody cares about this :P.

.grey

Christ, someone's being inflammatory.

Anyways, does it really matter, just as long as the image gets tagged in a brief time anyway? I was in the middle of tagging hews hack's newest collection until I decided "someone might upload before I do" and just finished the rest as they were already upped. It's really not that big a deal to me.

And yeah, I do get annoyed with some uploaders in particular regarding that habit -- they intentionally snipe all the popular uploads with these minimally acceptable tags, but it's how the site works and I'm not about to fight it. That being said, I wish there were harsher punishments for subpar tagging on works guaranteed to be popular. Sacriven's tossed out a few neutral feedbacks to users that do do that.

At the very least I'll always try to skim the basic and frequent tags in my uploads before going for a quick one.

1 156 157 158 159 160 161 162 163 164 315