Can you guys explain how it's bad (including how proportions are off) then? It very honestly doesn't look at all bad to me other than maybe preference toward certain content.
Posted under General
This topic has been locked.
Emergency call! post #329731 will soon be automatically deleted. It's not a bad scan (well, it could have used more cropping), and the picture is cool.
I don't mind a mod or Janitor deleting a post because it's bad but it's a little uncalled for when the reason is annoyingly rude such as "stupid post" or "fuck no" as a reason.
Instead I think it should be "not good" or "no".
But that's just me, I don't know what anyone else thinks of it.
I will likely have more in the future. Here is a couple quick, I feel important ones.
post #339592 was deleted. post #339588 was accepted. These two images are the EXACT same artist, same style, same pose, et cetera. The only difference between them is the character shown. I would like post #339592 brought back.
There are also two posts that are part of a series of comics/4koma that were not accepted: post #334750 and post #338689 .
Lastly, there are a few posts that I feel are of a good enough quality for re-evaluation. I didn't go through all of the posts deleted since the last time I asked in this topic, these are only a few I saw on the first page of deleted posts.
post #338550
post #335730
post #338555
post #335880
Thank you for your time.
salarta said:
I will likely have more in the future. Here is a couple quick, I feel important ones.post #339592 was deleted. post #339588 was accepted. These two images are the EXACT same artist, same style, same pose, et cetera. The only difference between them is the character shown. I would like post #339592 brought back.
For once, I don't see anything wrong with the first two images there. I don't see why they have a negative score and I'm guessing those are from people who just want to spite you.
homeless_homo said: For once, I don't see anything wrong with the first two images there. I don't see why they have a negative score and I'm guessing those are from people who just want to spite you.
Eh? It's not like that sort of x-ray/visible insides is a universally accepted or liked thing, so it doesn't seem very odd that people might have voted it down (or up, for that matter). Anything that's a fairly specific fetish will have both fans and detractors.
jxh2154 said:
Eh? It's not like that sort of x-ray/visible insides is a universally accepted or liked thing, so it doesn't seem very odd that people might have voted it down (or up, for that matter). Anything that's a fairly specific fetish will have both fans and detractors.
Well even then, some x-rays are nice but I don't particularly care for either of those two images.
salarta said: I've deleted the Barbariccia one, as I said I would. If a janitor, mod or admin changes his/her mind, I'm sure that they could restore both.
Not that I mind in this case, but generally speaking you shouldn't do this. Whether you intend it or not, some people might see this and think they can hold good images hostage and threaten to delete them if their less good uploads don't get accepted. Granted mods have the power to fix such situations, but only if made aware of them. It's better to just not go there.
If something gets accepted, just leave it as is. It's not like the two images were part of a series, or that you had to have one to understand the other.
jxh2154 said:
Eh? It's not like that sort of x-ray/visible insides is a universally accepted or liked thing, so it doesn't seem very odd that people might have voted it down (or up, for that matter). Anything that's a fairly specific fetish will have both fans and detractors.
Let me just say, after reading what you said, I took the time to look through the first 5 to 6 pages of posts tagged with cross section, and they all have positive scores.
Even post #288821 has a score of 30.
I don't think that argument is gonna work here.
jxh2154 said:
Not that I mind in this case, but generally speaking you shouldn't do this. Whether you intend it or not, some people might see this and think they can hold good images hostage and threaten to delete them if their less good uploads don't get accepted. Granted mods have the power to fix such situations, but only if made aware of them. It's better to just not go there.If something gets accepted, just leave it as is. It's not like the two images were part of a series, or that you had to have one to understand the other.
In this special case, I see leaving one and letting the other die as entirely, unequivocally biased. It's not like they're vastly different images. The only thing about them that makes them unique is the character portrayed. They're the EXACT same style, EXACT same colors (none), EXACT same artist, EXACT same everything. If one is acceptable, the other should be acceptable as well. If one is not acceptable, the other should not be acceptable as well.
I could be arguing up a storm about this issue. Instead, I'm letting it die by deleting the one that got a pass. You guys have to do absolutely nothing here. If people look at this as "holding an image hostage" (which it isn't, I'm simply treating these two fairly equal images on fairly equal terms), you've just proven you don't bow to threats.
I don't care anymore, because it's done.