Freshblink said:
1. loli
2. borderline
3. middleschool looking, not loli
4. pubic hair, wide hips, big ass, top is questionable ish but bottom isnt loli
5. petite
6. loli
7. borderline
i'd say 4 is definitely not loli, while 5 and 7 are loli
Posted under General
I added the loli tag here because she looks really young, but I need additional opinions. What do you guys think?
SlaughteredMelon said:
I added the loli tag here because she looks really young, but I need additional opinions. What do you guys think?
Tag fits.
Hereinafter said:
If I could actually see her breasts and discern how developed they were, I could have argued not loli. But since I can't, might as well leave it.
Freshblink said:
Tag fits.
If I could actually see her breasts and discern how developed they were, I could have argued not loli. But since I can't, might as well leave it.
The tag was removed despite not giving any reason why (which should have been done considering you argued for keeping the tag). However, I also don't think the overall development really looks loli either.
There are about 9 pages of Vivi_(Ac8231), whose regular outfit is pretty revealing. She looks pretty young in some posts, but I only tagged the most obvious cases. Someone else may want to give these posts a second look if they have time.
Updated
Was rated G and tagged with loli. It was changed to S once before by nonamethanks, but was changed back months later. It wasn't tagged with loli until very recently.
How exactly do we categorize pregnant characters? It looks completely SFW except maybe for the character's apparent age. Do we rate these as G, or can loli apply to images like this?
For now, I upped the rating back to S to keep it out of G loli limbo.
Blank_User said:
Was rated G and tagged with loli. It was changed to S once before by nonamethanks, but was changed back months later. It wasn't tagged with loli until very recently.
How exactly do we categorize pregnant characters? It looks completely SFW except maybe for the character's apparent age. Do we rate these as G, or can loli apply to images like this?
For now, I upped the rating back to S to keep it out of G loli limbo.
loli rating:s pregnant has at least 2 more posts of the same possibly-G-worthy nature, child solo pregnant would all need to be adjusted if consensus decides on rating:s loli.
viliml said:
loli rating:s pregnant has at least 2 more posts of the same possibly-G-worthy nature, child solo pregnant would all need to be adjusted if consensus decides on
rating:s loli.
I really don't think child and pregnant should ever be applicable to the same subject. They may not need to be tagged loli, but tagging them child just sounds like a bad idea.
blindVigil said:
I really don't think child and pregnant should ever be applicable to the same subject. They may not need to be tagged loli, but tagging them child just sounds like a bad idea.
+1, even if the image shows nothing it's not like the implication of "had sex" is subtle, in fact it's pretty in-your-face.
Children of post #8141657, chibi stuff always make me unsure when it comes to loli tagging.
Unbreakable said:
Children of post #8141657, chibi stuff always make me unsure when it comes to loli tagging.
Yes IMO
Would this be considered loli? https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7214205
Hereinafter said:
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8067005
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7897529
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7808715
Image 1 no, images 2 and 3 are borderline.
LenaLatoya said:
Would this be considered loli? https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7214205
Petite.
LenaLatoya said:
Would this be considered loli? https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7214205
Idk what Freshblink is on, yes loli.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6752138?q=ordfav%3AFreshblink
Is this one a loli?
ANON_TOKYO said:
Idk what Freshblink is on, yes loli.
looks more like an anorexic teen to me, but ill go with what you said.
Updated
ANON_TOKYO said:
Idk what Freshblink is on, yes loli.
Maybe it was because of her height? But I agree. Definitely more loli than the two borderline Iona posts, at least.
Freshblink said:
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6752138?q=ordfav%3AFreshblink
Is this one a loli?
Looks like pretty standard proportions for high school students in a typical moe series to me. And serafuku tend to make the age look more ambiguous in my experience. I'm leaning toward no on this one.
I agree with Freshblink, post #8067005 looks petite. The other two are more ambiguous due to composition.