Donmai

Deletion appeal thread

Posted under General

This topic has been locked.

Fencedude said:
Oh jesus, Princess Lover HCGs are not "good art", they are freaking HCGs, the most boring porn imaginable.

There are some parts of the PL CGs that are worth uploading, none of those are them. But at least you weren't uploading the preponderance of peeing CGs (wtf is up with that anyway?)

They are all de-censored if you hadn't noticed.

artanis00 said:
If not, is there a way to get at the existing translation notes?

My solution: checking the history of the pool, copying and pasting the post number into the URL bar of any post, then checking the Notes history of each image. Can't get you the positioning of the text boxes, though.

artanis00 said:
http://danbooru.donmai.us/pool/show/839

If not, is there a way to get at the existing translation notes?

Huh, thought I approved those already. Sorry about that.

bk201 said:
I would like all my deleted posts looked at[.] If after looking through them and the moderators feel that they are not appropriate for danbooru, then please state the reasons.

jxh2154, could you edit the first post of this thread to include dire warnings about what will happen if you
- ask for justification for non-approval
- appeal your entire set of deleted posts
- act like you have the right to have your posts approved / act otherwise imperious
- don't read about:mod queue and related wiki articles
, please?

Updated

0xCCBA696 said: jxh2154, could you edit the first post of this thread to include dire warnings about what will happen if you
- ask for justification for non-approval
- appeal your entire set of deleted posts
- act like you have the right to have your posts approved / act otherwise imperious
- don't read about:mod queue and related wiki articles
, please?

Yes, I will, although the thread is so long now that I doubt many people see the first page anymore.

Edit: There, let me know if I missed anything. I'm going to put it in an about:deletion_appeals now, although anyone who wants to clean it up, feel free. I just threw it together in a few minutes just now.

Updated

0xCCBA696 said:

jxh2154, could you edit the first post of this thread to include dire warnings about what will happen if you
- ask for justification for non-approval
- appeal your entire set of deleted posts
- act like you have the right to have your posts approved / act otherwise imperious
- don't read about:mod queue and related wiki articles
, please?

Does that mean my posts will never be undeleted now that I ticked you off?

I apologize if I did step on some toes. I was under the assumption that the posts were really overlooked considering they were well received by the danbooru users.

Updated

I wouldn't say that being rude increases the chance your appeal will fail. It's just that the people who are dumb enough to be rude also tend to be the people who are dumb enough to appeal bad posts. I'd like to make it clear that post approval/non-approval is dependent only on the quality of the post, and not the user who makes it, because posts belong to the community as soon as they are uploaded, and not to the individual user who uploads them (one reason why users are not allowed to delete their own uploads).

On that note, bk201, your posts are not going to be undeleted because we mods generally don't give a damn about uncensored posts, in fact we tend to prefer the original, even if it's censored. In this case, since they are game cgs, they are not considered interesting enough to approve, usually, even if they were the original, censored version from the game. It's not because you stepped on toes or ticked us off. If anything, I'm just wearied by the number of people who misuse the word "appeal", demand explanations, assert that their shitty posts are actually "good danbooru material", etc. etc. - you just happened to be the latest in a long line, which you can see if you read the other pages of this thread.

Let it be known that the administration of this site does not live to serve "the danbooru users", a large number of whom seem to be idiots who will favorite anything featuring a bare nipple or a penis ensheathed in a vagina. The janitors', mods', and admins' tastes in image quality, and thus the selection of posts that are approved, are not beholden to the general populace. They can be assumed at some time to have been hand-picked by albert, the owner of the site, though, if that means anything to you.

bk201 said: Does that mean my posts will never be undeleted now that I ticked you off?

No, I don't think he would do that, and besides there are plenty of people who can undelete posts, not just one. Just make sure that in the future you follow the rules (just now formally laid out, I admit) in about:deletion_appeals. And try something other than HCGs for uploads. I know they're usually seen by new posters as a good way to get started, but if the set gets rejected it really puts you in the hole in terms of the accept/delete ratio.

0xCCBA696 said: I wouldn't say that being rude increases the chance your appeal will fail. It's just that the people who are dumb enough to be rude also tend to be the people who are dumb enough to appeal bad posts.

True, they go together so often that they just seem like the same thing in my mind. I'm going to reword that.

0xCCBA696 said:

On that note, bk201, your posts are not going to be undeleted because we mods generally don't give a damn about uncensored posts, in fact we tend to prefer the original, even if it's censored. In this case, since they are game cgs, they are not considered interesting enough to approve, usually, even if they were the original, censored version from the game. It's not because you stepped on toes or ticked us off. If anything, I'm just wearied by the number of people who misuse the word "appeal", demand explanations, assert that their shitty posts are actually "good danbooru material", etc. etc. - you just happened to be the latest in a long line, which you can see if you read the other pages of this thread.

Thanks for the explanation. As I said earlier, I don't post often but when I do, I try to post pictures that are of good quality and it helps knowing what the expectations are.

Again, I apologize if I came across as being rude, it wasn't a stab at the moderators for not approving the posts but rather, why they weren't approved for my future references.

1 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 757