unless they actually do?
Veraducks did you see my furry boy I posted? Come on ... and approve my gay furry boy! I read Wez 1010 post. I know you guys like this sort of thing
#gayupdanbooru
Posted under General
unless they actually do?
Veraducks did you see my furry boy I posted? Come on ... and approve my gay furry boy! I read Wez 1010 post. I know you guys like this sort of thing
#gayupdanbooru
jxh2154 said:
People have been asking for a thread where feedback on uploads could be obtained. So here it is. I have some reservations about how acrimonious this thread is likely to get, and if it turns into nothing more than a flame-fest, I will lock it.
Rules for those requesting feedback:
#1 - You are not guaranteed feedback. It is entirely voluntary to give it.
#2 - Danbooru may simply not be an appropriate place for your favorite art. If so, accept this and move on.
#3 - Try not to be too thin-skinned,and don't take things personally.Rules for those giving feedback:
#1 - Give constructive feedback only.
#2 - Refrain from name-calling. Asking people to be thick-skinned doesn't mean you're allowed to be insulting.
Hello fluff guy... I have a ask why they deleting these posts post #5029636 post #4998955 I don't know why
Pacherry said:
Hello fluff guy... I have a ask why they deleting these posts post #5029636 post #4998955 I don't know why
Well I can answer that for you. Danbooru is first and foremost an anime image collecting site
The first one is a western cartoon done in a western style so it would be considered off topic.
The second one is a bit more ontopic being Link, but it's really just something like a kid would draw. I could do that for you. There's no shading at all.
All the colors are solid.
Head really large compared to the body. So the proportions look off and the legs under the covers seem really small indicating that the legs are super tiny. It's a nice image. But not really up to the quality danbooru is aiming for.
I’d like to get some feedback on 4 posts that went to the deleted status today:
post #5030849 and it’s alternates post #5030860 and post #5030865, along with post #5031317.
All four tallied a decent number of upvotes while they were pending so I hope that quality isn’t the issue here. If I wait 30 days and appeal would it be likely they get approved? Is there anything I can do better to improve acceptance chances in the appeal?
I have 2 other posts that are in pending and I’m beginning to worry they won’t be approved (post #5037553 and post #5032659). Any guidance you can provide would be appreciated. Thanks.
NotoriousWeb said:
The pelvic anatomy in that one is really weird, to the extent that I'm tempted to tag it bad_vulva. When a woman sits upright, her vagina points roughly downwards. The only way it would make any sense to be facing out like that is if she were slouching with her pelvis rotated backward. Look at some artists' nude reference photos and you'll see what I mean.
It's by no means the worst example of this that I've seen, but it's enough to spoil the image for people who have an eye for this sort of thing. When an artist draws porn, you should expect them to at least put the genitals in the right place.
Hey_hi_hello_have_a_nice_day! said:
post #5021705
The face and head scare me. Something about the perspective and shading is causing some kind of combo of Uncanny Valley and Fight or Flight.
MisterSeven7 said:
Any reason in particular for why post #5028208? I am unable to tell if there are any anatomical errors in this image but someone can correct me.
It's lacking refinement. Simple block shading, simple framing, etc. etc.
NotoriousWeb said:
Weird head.
All four tallied a decent number of upvotes
Score has no impact on whether or not something gets approved. Upvotes, favcount, etc. are basically meaningless metrics.
I have 2 other posts that are in pending and I’m beginning to worry they won’t be approved (post #5037553 and post #5032659). Any guidance you can provide would be appreciated. Thanks.
Please refrain from asking about things that are still pending, especially if they're less than a day old.
Updated
jay19 said:
if he approved one and not the other, I'm sure he looked at both and decided the second one was better for whatever reason. It's a little heart breaking but there are images that are good but none of the approvers like it and they don't owe you an approval.
No no no, that is not what i mean, i would like some feedback if the image is wrong, yes it would be nice if it was approved but i would also like to know why if it was not approved, i mean so i know what kind of images i should and should not upload in the future.
I understand they owe me nothing but if i know what to upload in the future and what not then we can all save time and we will have more good images on this site in the end for everyone to enjoy.
That is why i ask.
jay19 said:
Well I can answer that for you. Danbooru is first and foremost an anime image collecting site
The first one is a western cartoon done in a western style so it would be considered off topic.
The second one is a bit more ontopic being Link, but it's really just something like a kid would draw. I could do that for you. There's no shading at all.
All the colors are solid.Head really large compared to the body. So the proportions look off and the legs under the covers seem really small indicating that the legs are super tiny. It's a nice image. But not really up to the quality danbooru is aiming for.
Oohhh, thanks i understand... The second imagen is made by tuyoki
Hey_hi_hello_have_a_nice_day! said:
No no no, that is not what i mean, i would like some feedback if the image is wrong, yes it would be nice if it was approved but i would also like to know why if it was not approved, i mean so i know what kind of images i should and should not upload in the future.
I understand they owe me nothing but if i know what to upload in the future and what not then we can all save time and we will have more good images on this site in the end for everyone to enjoy.
That is why i ask.
Yes, I understand why you asked. And the feedback i gave was
"There are images that are good, but none of the approvers like the image"
If he saw it and didn't give you an answer and he's giving everyone else feedback then it most likely falls under the category:
The image is probably decent, but the approvers don't like it.
I don't see anything wrong with it, other then it also does nothing for me.
jay19 said:
Well I can answer that for you. Danbooru is first and foremost an anime image collecting site
The first one is a western cartoon done in a western style so it would be considered off topic.
The second one is a bit more ontopic being Link, but it's really just something like a kid would draw. I could do that for you. There's no shading at all.
All the colors are solid.Head really large compared to the body. So the proportions look off and the legs under the covers seem really small indicating that the legs are super tiny. It's a nice image. But not really up to the quality danbooru is aiming for.
And what you think of these buddies? post 4877239 post 4877135
Pacherry said:
And what you think of these buddies? post 4877239 post 4877135
First post ... again not an image done in the style of "Anime" or "eastern" image.
and also let's talk perspectives (viewing angles)
The face is looking at the viewer but what's the angle of the body suppose to be?
and there's a body but "they" have stick arms and legs? "they" is used singularly here because I can't tell if this is suppose to be a "Boy" or a "Girl"
and what's the theme of the piece? It just seems to be something you drew for fun. There's no "idea" or "feeling" behind it. It's just there.
and that's another issue ... please don't self upload to danbooru. People will always be willing to upload work they like. I know the idea behind the self uploads is to get your work out there but that's what twitter is for ... danbooru's image board is not the place for finding your audience.
Please don't let me discourage you from doing art. I checked out your deviantart channel. Your art is okayish but danbooru is looking for more of a professional standard. One day, you will be good enough to have art in danbooru. So keep working towards that, awesome artwork is not an easy journey.
Second post has the same problem as the first post ... it's not done in an "eastern" image style but also I'm not sure what that is ... 600 K?
I honestly don't know what I'm looking at other then the 600 K. It's really confusing. Also the font for 600 K kindof looks like "Gook" which is an offensive term. So that's something else against it.
I hope that helps
jay19 said:
First post ... again not an image done in the style of "Anime" or "eastern" image.
and also let's talk perspectives (viewing angles)
The face is looking at the viewer but what's the angle of the body suppose to be?
and there's a body but "they" have stick arms and legs? "they" is used singularly here because I can't tell if this is suppose to be a "Boy" or a "Girl"and what's the theme of the piece? It just seems to be something you drew for fun. There's no "idea" or "feeling" behind it. It's just there.
and that's another issue ... please don't self upload to danbooru. People will always be willing to upload work they like. I know the idea behind the self uploads is to get your work out there but that's what twitter is for ... danbooru's image board is not the place for finding your audience.
Please don't let me discourage you from doing art. I checked out your deviantart channel. Your art is okayish but danbooru is looking for more of a professional standard. One day, you will be good enough to have art in danbooru. So keep working towards that, awesome artwork is not an easy journey.
Second post has the same problem as the first post ... it's not done in an "eastern" image style but also I'm not sure what that is ... 600 K?
I honestly don't know what I'm looking at other then the 600 K. It's really confusing. Also the font for 600 K kindof looks like "Gook" which is an offensive term. So that's something else against it.
I hope that helps
Very thanks dr chicken! The first post.... Well... is a super paper mario style, i understand you, i use Manu Styles in games, tv shows or artists, some artists in deviantart are inspiration for me, Incluiding oriental artist... Then, i Have Some Habilities In Pixelart, Wowie! i Don't Know Have Some Potential... Also, The 600K Are Followers Of The Artist
????? Can anyone tell me why my post was deleted?
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5032844?q=user%3AKomedordksada
It was accepted and then someone reposted it and it was deleted like ?????? Everything is correct the image is the same of the source, why it was deleted???
Komedordksada said:
????? Can anyone tell me why my post was deleted?
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/5032844?q=user%3AKomedordksadaIt was accepted and then someone reposted it and it was deleted like ?????? Everything is correct the image is the same of the source, why it was deleted???
It says so right above the image:
This post was deleted for the following reason:
sample; child of full size
You uploaded a Twitter sample image, which means that it’s not the full size image.
Consider using the bookmarklet, which will always upload the full size image.
kittey said:
It says so right above the image:
You uploaded a Twitter sample image, which means that it’s not the full size image.
Consider using the bookmarklet, which will always upload the full size image.
I will say, however, that the proper thing for @mongirlfan to do would have been to request a replacement and DM'd Komedordksada rather than 1upping.
Veradux said:
I will say, however, that the proper thing for @mongirlfan to do would have been to request a replacement and DM'd Komedordksada rather than 1upping.
It's a normal thing to upload a better version of the picture if it is available, that being better resolution, quality or uncensored. However, what I wasn't expecting and that I personally find unfair, was to delete post #5032844 that was uploaded by @Komedordksada and move the likes/favorites to the version I have uploaded (post #5034439), and that is out of my control.
I would like some clarification on why post #5035381 and post #5035375 wasn't approved. Thanks for the help!
mongirlfan said:
It's a normal thing to upload a better version of the picture if it is available, that being better resolution, quality or uncensored.
That only applies to better versions from a different source (e.g., Pixiv vs. Twitter). If someone uploaded a sample, request a replacement instead of uploading the full-size image yourself.