Donmai

Seriously, tank tops are shirts

Posted under Tags

BUR #35748 has been rejected.

Show

mass update camouflage_tank_top -tank_top -> tank_top
mass update print_tank_top -tank_top -> tank_top
mass update aqua_tank_top -tank_top -> tank_top
mass update ribbed_tank_top -tank_top -> tank_top
mass update multicolored_tank_top -tank_top -> tank_top
remove implication black_tank_top -> tank_top
remove implication blue_tank_top -> tank_top
remove implication brown_tank_top -> tank_top
remove implication green_tank_top -> tank_top
remove implication grey_tank_top -> tank_top
remove implication orange_tank_top -> tank_top
remove implication pink_tank_top -> tank_top
remove implication purple_tank_top -> tank_top
remove implication red_tank_top -> tank_top
remove implication striped_tank_top -> tank_top
remove implication white_tank_top -> tank_top
remove implication yellow_tank_top -> tank_top
remove implication torn_tank_top -> tank_top
create alias white_tank_top -> white_shirt
create alias black_tank_top -> black_shirt
create alias yellow_tank_top -> yellow_shirt
create alias blue_tank_top -> blue_shirt
create alias grey_tank_top -> grey_shirt
create alias red_tank_top -> red_shirt
create alias green_tank_top -> green_shirt
create alias pink_tank_top -> pink_shirt
create alias purple_tank_top -> purple_shirt
create alias orange_tank_top -> orange_shirt
create alias striped_tank_top -> striped_shirt
create alias brown_tank_top -> brown_shirt
create alias camouflage_tank_top -> camouflage_shirt
create alias print_tank_top -> print_shirt
create alias torn_tank_top -> torn_shirt
create alias aqua_tank_top -> aqua_shirt
create alias ribbed_tank_top -> ribbed_shirt
create alias multicolored_tank_top -> multicolored_shirt
create implication tank_top -> sleeveless_shirt

The Earth is still blue, and the moon is still white. The sun is still painful to look at, and terrible fart porn is still occasionally uploaded.

Nothing has changed since topic #23558. Tank tops are still listed as a type of sleeveless shirt on Wikipedia, and the Google search results for sleeveless shirt are still full of tank tops.

Imagine if we had red_baseball_cap, or blue_down_jacket, or yellow_sneakers, while at the same time refusing to acknowledge them as hats, jackets, or shoes. That's what this is.

Shinjidude said:

If we do this, we should also do the same for camisoles, perhaps even sweaters and the like. It'd just boil down to <color>_top. I'm not sure if I'm in favor of that or not.

Camisoles, yes. Sweaters, no. color_top tags would be incredibly broad and unhelpful; they'd be a step backwards in the same way color_legwear was.

1