Donmai

Honkai Impact/Gakuen requests

Posted under Tags

elysialover said:

BUR #31940 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create implication elysia_(summer_2023)_(honkai_impact) -> elysia_(herrscher_of_human:_ego)_(honkai_impact)
create implication elysia_(office_lady)_(honkai_impact) -> elysia_(honkai_impact)

elysia_(summer_2023)_(honkai_impact) is a summer line oufit for elysia_(herrscher_of_human:_ego)_(honkai_impact)
elysia_(office_lady)_(honkai_impact) is Elysia in the Honkai Impact x Honkai Star Rail crossover video.

I guess Summer 2023/2024 tags for the other girls could be made, then?

xcv450 said:

I guess Summer 2023/2024 tags for the other girls could be made, then?

They can, yes. We have a lot of untagged Honkai Impact 3rd costumes but haven't had time to go through them or anything (and some implications need to be fixed as well but that's for another day, I'm not going through that headache). If it's just one or two posts and doesn't take more than a two-tag search official alternate costume is enough, they don't need a new chartag. Elysia in this case has a lot of posts per alternate costume.

Three issues:

  • "Other" is a bad name, it's prone to mistags and getting poisoned, leading to unnecessary work for gardeners and admins. This needs a better name that's more specific to when it was used in the story (Salt Snow Holy City, Salt Snow or Holy City).
  • Plugsuits are specific to the Neon Genesis Evangelion copyright and only used by them so this needs to be called something else before it starts polluting gentags reserved for another copyright or we need to table discussion about the use of the plugsuit tag for non-Evangelion copyrights and generalise the tag to "specifically Evangelion plugsuits or outfits that look like them".
    • It's easy to call it "plugsuit" since it clearly looks like one and with how HI3 takes some concepts/makes references to EVA (including a collab in the past) but it's not one. We don't (or shouldn't) call Firefly's outfit a plugsuit either. That tag is already poisoned enough with things that aren't clearly characters from other copyrights in Evangelion plugsuits.

Changli said:

What about them?

Changli said:

  • "Other" is a bad name, it's prone to mistags and getting poisoned, leading to unnecessary work for gardeners and admins. This needs a better name that's more specific to when it was used in the story (Salt Snow Holy City, Salt Snow or Holy City).

Salt Snow sounds good.

Changli said:

  • Plugsuits are specific to the Neon Genesis Evangelion copyright and only used by them so this needs to be called something else before it starts polluting gentags reserved for another copyright or we need to table discussion about the use of the plugsuit tag for non-Evangelion copyrights and generalise the tag to "specifically Evangelion plugsuits or outfits that look like them".
    • It's easy to call it "plugsuit" since it clearly looks like one and with how HI3 takes some concepts/makes references to EVA (including a collab in the past) but it's not one. We don't (or shouldn't) call Firefly's outfit a plugsuit either. That tag is already poisoned enough with things that aren't clearly characters from other copyrights in Evangelion plugsuits.

Maybe just bodysuit is more appropiate? I was kinda confused when I first looked at the tag and saw plugsuit.

1 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18