Don't create counter BURs for the sake of creating counter BURs. guilty_gear already has a history of being the umbrella and you're going to screw up people's muscle memory.
Posted under Tags
This topic has been locked.
Don't create counter BURs for the sake of creating counter BURs. guilty_gear already has a history of being the umbrella and you're going to screw up people's muscle memory.
Hillside_Moose said:
Don't create counter BURs for the sake of creating counter BURs. guilty_gear already has a history of being the umbrella and you're going to screw up people's muscle memory.
I wasn't creating it for it's own sakes, and muscle memory isn't a valid argument, pretty much every old tag would be kept on that "merit" otherwise.
Isn't it not the standard to keep copyrights with dedicated characters to their own? this would be like saying fate/extra should imply fate/stay_night because it was the first in line, instead of making fate_(series).
heartattack said:
I think "alias guilty_gear -> guilty_gear_1" throws everything GG into the GG1 tag. Even "update guilty gear -guilty_gear_strive -guilty_gear_xrd -guilty_gear_xx etc -> guilty_gear guilty_gear_1" throws a lot of untagged stuff into GG1.
I guess my question is what do we use a GG1 tag for:
-GG1-specific character designs, eg Dr Baldhead and blue tabard Millia
-official art from GG1, if we've got any
-the rest of OG cast in their OG designs? This one seems weird to me because afaik most of them (Sol, Ky, Potemkin etc) keep the same design from GG1 through to GGXX. Not terrible, just seems weird to me.Depending on what it's for, GG1 might be something we want to tag manually.
i do agree with this that perhaps guilty_gear as a tag should be gardened now that it's pointed out, but outright rejecting it after not even 6 hours seems a bit rash
Pokeball99 said:
Isn't it not the standard to keep copyrights with dedicated characters to their own? this would be like saying fate/extra should imply fate/stay_night because it was the first in line, instead of making fate_(series).
Fate uses idiosyncratic titles for every release, not just a numeric Fate/Stay Night 2, which warrants the (series) qualifier. Something you would have gleaned had you read my previous reply in the thread.
i do agree with this that perhaps guilty_gear as a tag should be gardened now that it's pointed out, but outright rejecting it after not even 6 hours seems a bit rash
I didn't reject KagayakuShiningGate's BUR.
Updated
Hillside_Moose said:
Fate uses idiosyncratic titles for every release, not just a numeric Fate/Stay Night 2, which warrants the (series) qualifier.
Except we already implicate tags like that for the likes of Mortal Kombat, To Heart, Rance and three different Mega man series, not to mention dozens of others which titles are mostly numerical like that.
BUR #18628 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
create implication battlefield_1 -> battlefield_(series)
create implication battlefield_3 -> battlefield_(series)
create implication battlefield_1942 -> battlefield_(series)
create implication battlefield:_bad_company_2 -> battlefield_(series)
Noticed a Battlefield game in there and saw that none of them are implicated besides 4. Other entries are too small to implicate.
Also not sure if Forgotten Hope: Secret Weapon should be implicated to 1942 or not (it's a mod)
BUR #18629 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
create alias senki_zesshou_symphogear_xv -> senki_zesshou_symphogear
This one might be a bit controversial, but I don't see why we should have a tag for just XV when none of the other seasons have their own tags. The only reason I can assume this came about is because it was the final season, while previous seasons didn't get their own tags since they all built off each other and new characters introduced in one season would usually carry into the next in some form or another. XV's new characters carried into the mobile game so it's not like they're exclusive to that single season.
HeeroWingZero said:
Also not sure if Forgotten Hope: Secret Weapon should be implicated to 1942 or not (it's a mod)
Kaiserreich implies Hearts of Iron, so there's precedent, assuming the mod is exclusive to 1942 or Battlefield in general.
The bulk update request #18628 (forum #248923) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
The bulk update request #18629 (forum #248925) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
The bulk update request #18532 (forum #248554) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
The bulk update request #18524 (forum #248503) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
The bulk update request #18522 (forum #248500) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
The bulk update request #18521 (forum #248499) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
Pokeball99 said:
BUR #18523 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
create implication donkey_kong_country_2 -> donkey_kong_(series)
create implication donkey_kong_country -> donkey_kong_(series)
create implication donkey_kong_(game) -> donkey_kong_(series)
create implication donkey_kong_64 -> donkey_kong_(series)
create implication donkey_kong_jungle_beat -> donkey_kong_(series)
create implication donkey_konga -> donkey_kong_(series)
create implication donkey_kong_barrel_blast -> donkey_kong_(series)
create implication donkey_kong_3 -> donkey_kong_(series)
create implication donkey_kong_country_3 -> donkey_kong_(series)
create implication donkey_kong_country_(cartoon) -> donkey_kong_(series)
create implication donkey_kong_jr._(game) -> donkey_kong_(series)here's Donkey Kong as well, there's a few mario and donkey kong crossover copyrights but wasn't sure if those would be valid to implicate
Do we need a Donkey Kong Country umbrella tag?
The bulk update request #18523 (forum #248501) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
BUR #38245 has been approved by @nonamethanks.
create implication battlefield_2 -> battlefield_(series)
create implication battlefield_2042 -> battlefield_(series)
create implication battlefield_2142 -> battlefield_(series)
create implication battlefield_hardline -> battlefield_(series)
create implication battlefield_v -> battlefield_(series)
create implication battlefield:_bad_company -> battlefield_(series)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battlefield_2
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battlefield_2042
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battlefield_2142
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battlefield_Hardline
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battlefield_V
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battlefield:_Bad_Company
The bulk update request #38245 (forum #340235) has been approved by @nonamethanks.