Donmai

AI-generated art check thread

Posted under General

ion288 said:

post #8628283
Flagged but not tagged. Feeling tempted to reapprove this.

If u play with filters u can notice that white background is not white and overall images are upscaled to hell, but I'd say these arts have low quality to be AI

Arcana55 said:

post #8300676

I don't see anything wrong with the hair, hands or otherwise.

The most recent upload of this artist was also tagged AI-generated, and a reason given was "because her hair goes behind her eyebrow and eye". That's terrible reason, as that's something artists do all the time.

I see no evidence of AI. The aliased lines actually look like something it would be difficult to produce with AI.
I also do not think that post #9153646 shows any signs of AI. I agree that the hair behind the mascara wings is not a sign at all.
Just in regards to your comment about AI generation of text on that second image: SDXL can sometimes make text, and Flux can reliably produce it. Coherent text is not a strong "not AI" signal anymore imo. Also, it can be added in post with zero difficulty in this case, because it's not molded to anything in the image; just flat text on a simple background.
The callout to NovelAI mentioned on another of their works on pixiv is the indicator here, but does that put a black mark on their work forever if we can't discern anything in future images of theirs? I don't know.

Please check https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/9138177
The artist (Miychi) is being accused of putting https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/9040786 through AI and plagiarizing the original artist. Both people tried to get featured on Nanashi Mumei's fanart review stream, and Miychi got their art shown instead of the original artist's.
Miychi's Pixiv has existed for less than a month and they've already got a bunch of art that people have pointed out looks a lot like it's in qiandaiyiyu's art style. Also, they have other AI-generated art saved in their Pixiv bookmarks.
Supposedly they're a reincarnation of another Russian AI art account called chokopaii that has had AI accusations in the past. They also both like to use the "my body is weak" line.

EDIT: forgot to link the callout https://x.com/_nHase/status/1913016199719559540

Updated

AngelFlash said:

Please check https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/9138177
The artist (Miychi) is being accused of putting https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/9040786 through AI and plagiarizing the original artist. Both people tried to get featured on Nanashi Mumei's fanart review stream, and Miychi got their art shown instead of the original artist's.
Miychi's Pixiv has existed for less than a month and they've already got a bunch of art that people have pointed out looks a lot like it's in qiandaiyiyu's art style. Also, they have other AI-generated art saved in their Pixiv bookmarks.
Supposedly they're a reincarnation of another Russian AI art account called chokopaii that has had AI accusations in the past. They also both like to use the "my body is weak" line.

EDIT: forgot to link the callout https://x.com/_nHase/status/1913016199719559540

Doesn't look like AI to me, looks more like a typical twitter drama, lying girl vs lying girl, doesn't require lots of intelligence and inspiration even for "original"(lol) artist, if you're frustrated about post being plagiarized tag it with derivative_work and link to the parent post.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/9138175?q=parent%3A9138175 - this looks more suspicious, different eyes
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/9082848?q=miychi - eye dropping down after eyelids
also 9 arts of such high quality in just half a month seems impossible to me without huge artistic background or AI involvement
https://x.com/shinbun_n/status/1912974599513309383

AngelFlash said:

EDIT: forgot to link the callout https://x.com/_nHase/status/1913016199719559540

looks like twitter drama came to an end and this post is now deleted

Updated

Dead_Princess said:

post #9164093

Somebody tagged this as AI-assisted but I can't find anything that proves it is, I checked everywhere and there is even a Making-of on their Twitter account.

another huge jump in quality just in a few days? Compare Furina and Miku works to latest touhou's
https://x.com/Chamal_Z/status/1900574116454809954 - mar 15
https://x.com/Chamal_Z/status/1903040594257321984 - mar 21
https://x.com/Chamal_Z/status/1912702565944553664 - april 17

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/9164093 - also nonsence highlight on pinky finger

https://www.pixiv.net/en/artworks/128951773 - look at artifacted as hell Kisaki's qipao buttons or idk how it's called

pixiv bio:
趣味でお絵描き練習してます。
よろしくおねがいします。
※制作過程で一部オリジナルのAI素材を使用しています。ご了承ください。

Updated

Hello! I've found this artist that makes really nice looking stuff, but I have a gut feeling AI may be involved to some capacity.

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts?tags=puriririririri
https://x.com/puriririririri
https://x.com/monokurocorp

First, there's a gap in posts from February 2024 to December 2024. To me, the posts before the gap don't look suspicious at all.

This gap ends with a post I'd say kinda looks like it's part of a marketing campaign:
https://x.com/puriririririri/status/1865785419264409891/video/1

The posts after this seem to have an upgrade in quality, which could also be explained by thinking the artist just got better in this time period.
Also, I think this monochromatic ms-paint style could be easily retouched to hide AI artifacts and such.

The other thing is the lack of any information on the artist's pages other than a link to a "coming soon" website:
https://www.monokuro.world/

The website lists several twitter accounts, which are the two artist's accounts, an account with crude art that also links to the same website and Oekaki Connect, an NFT company or website.

Oekaki Connect's website features some merch and NFT galleries. Some of this NFT art looks like it was done by a real artists, but still designed to be mass produced:
https://www.oekakiconnect.net/archive/art/hapa-heaven/hurt-hapas

This collection is AI, they even admit it (well, it's not like it doesn't obviously look like AI):
https://www.oekakiconnect.net/archive/art/ghiblady/ghiblady-maker

This one has really bad art... (click on the twitter link):
https://www.oekakiconnect.net/archive/art/girlonline/

There's also an image board that's very strange to me, it looks pretty active and it features crude art, but at the same time some of that crude art looks like it was made by pretty capable artists:
https://bbs.oekakiconnect.net/

All of this makes me think this company is just interested in getting tons of art for cheap. It also doesn't seem like they care about quality that much.