Donmai

AI-generated art check thread

Posted under General

HeyThereGuy said:

post #8559250 and post #8582542 by roribitanx are tagged as ai-generated.

This feels like a classic case of someone tagging based solely on the art style looking “AI-ish”.

Just want to say I flagged the Marisa one not only because of the look but also because of the double-sided broom which is a mistake I don't think a human would make. The whole thing from the hair to the shoes looks off and inconsistent but the broom is what pushed me to tag and flag.

Updated

ANON_TOKYO said:

post #8718351

@OhaiThar can you (or other people) explain why this should be regarded as assisted and not generated? The resolution and basically every finer detail when looking close screams, to quote the flagger, "AI slop".

I'm the one who made the flag, since at fight I assumed that this one is merely someone use this "artist's" style for AI slop generation.

But it turns out that after quick look to their Pixiv account, the images seems to be AI slop.

This is especially apparent when you compare the image that the "artist" has drawn prior to AI usage (pixiv #101639266) to the one that starts to have AI involved (pixiv #103783631) which have massive "improvement" in terms of basic anatomy and the AI-shading, despite both images were posted within 2 months.

r_cutiee is definitely using AI. They previously were flagged in post #8574513 and that flag was overturned, but this person's skill is bizarrely inconsistent in ways that make no sense. They've got great shapes in some places but AI-like nonsense in others, like in post #8888655: outlines are inconsistent, and the hair beneath her shows that kind of parting that AI does because it doesn't understand what hair actually is, despite all these other details that look much more clean and refined (at a glance). Over in post #8733731 we've got some very AI-looking finger silliness, and in post #8733702 we have all of the above: the man's hand in Momo's hair and its effect on her hair is completely ridiculous and makes no sense.

I don't know if they're tracing or just coloring over an AI's output or what, but these compositions are absolutely not their original work. I find their crying on Xitter pretty unconvincing too; who goes to all the work that it would take to produce the passable components of these images and decides to just quit because one single imageboard isn't being nice to them? This stuff is at the very least AI-assisted, and I don't think it meets standards well enough for a pass.

Just withdrawing all of this. It still looks fishy to me, but the more I look at it, the less comfortable I feel being certain AI is involved. It may just be someone whose skill with painting and such is much... much higher than their line work, anatomy, etc.

Updated

2xVision said:

r_cutiee is definitely using AI. They previously were flagged in post #8574513 and that flag was overturned, but this person's skill is bizarrely inconsistent in ways that make no sense. They've got great shapes in some places but AI-like nonsense in others, like in post #8888655: outlines are inconsistent, and the hair beneath her shows that kind of parting that AI does because it doesn't understand what hair actually is, despite all these other details that look much more clean and refined (at a glance). Over in post #8733731 we've got some very AI-looking finger silliness, and in post #8733702 we have all of the above: the man's hand in Momo's hair and its effect on her hair is completely ridiculous and makes no sense.

I don't know if they're tracing or just coloring over an AI's output or what, but these compositions are absolutely not their original work. I find their crying on Xitter pretty unconvincing too; who goes to all the work that it would take to produce the passable components of these images and decides to just quit because one single imageboard isn't being nice to them? This stuff is at the very least AI-assisted, and I don't think it meets standards well enough for a pass.

100% agree, imagine spending thousands of hours on learning how to actually draw and just quit - no real artist would do that