Bridget - Guilty Gear Strive

Mavado said:

Noticed that a lot of the "people" voting yes in your little poll are accounts created TODAY.

https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947159
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947169
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947171
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947180
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947184
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947185
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947186
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947197

I wouldn't be surprised if you'll end up with a hundred yes votes, all made by the two or three fanatics keeping this thread from dying.

What am I suppose to do? Go back in time and make an account years ago and contribute with tags and forum posts so I can vote in a thread that is actually meaningful to me today? Do you want actual users of this site (lurkers) to make democratic decisions when it interests them or just a cabal of 20 extremely active nerds who whine about being slightly inconvenienced by having to alter their blacklists.

evazion said:

Votes from offsite brigades will be ignored.

So my vote is going to be ignored just because I found out from a third party, but you're ok with counting votes that are for misgendering a canonically trans character??? Just so we're clear.

Sanctity said:

Why is this fair? Everyone can agree that the artist drew a transgender girl, but not everyone can agree that means the artist drew a literal girl. Or does the artist's world view trump the userbase's which is split in this manner? Also to be consistent this logic would have to apply to other images that are "explicitly transgender" giving a simple flag a very large influence in how tagging is done. And on the other hand, it doesn't make sense to tag Bridget as a girl in only this scenario. It would establish that transgirl = girl, so it would only be logical to tag Strive Bridget as a girl by default.

But I can agree that otoko no ko should be removed in "explicitly transgender" images. To me, the character's attitude is an important part of otoko no ko and Bridget thinking himself as a girl makes him no longer count as one. Though I'm not into otoko no ko so my opinion isn't worth as much as those who are. Maybe they would want transgirls included in that tag.

I do support this idea, because Bridget is now indeed a transgender girl and that tag could be very useful.

• Only Strive posts* and by default. If an artist is still drawing Bridget as an otoko no ko then the tag would not apply. *pre-Strive Bridget could be tagged as transgender if drawn explicitly as such.
• Two tags would be best for filtering. transgender (mtf) and transgender (ftm) should be fine, those are commonly used acronyms after all. And it's pointless to worry about if those terms are transphobic too much, because what counts as that varies too much from person to person. Like some will go as far to say that a lesbian not wanting to have sex with a transgirl due to having a penis is transphobic.
• Yes, reasoning previously mentioned.
• Sex based tags should care about the character's sex, not their state of mind. So Bridget could still be tagged with yaoi.
• Same as the last bullet point. Bridget is male so would get male based tags, and not female ones.

"Everyone can agree that the artist drew a transgender girl, but not everyone can agree that means the artist drew a literal girl."
Transgender girls are literal girls... wtf is this transphobic statement
Edit: unless you werent claiming that as your opinion, which upon re reading isnt entire said

evazion said:

Votes from offsite brigades will be ignored.

What do you mean ? It seems... really odd to me put this way I'll be honest.
Because if you mean ONLY people who have an account or are acknowledged on this site, let's be real it's probably impossible to change anything. At least 1 mod is straight transphobic not even denying it. To be real, your sentence sound like "Those in power shall stay in power" thing. Not to say it is tho, just what I'm getting from it.

Mavado said:

Noticed that a lot of the "people" voting yes in your little poll are accounts created TODAY.

https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947159
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947169
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947171
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947180
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947184
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947185
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947186
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947197

I wouldn't be surprised if you'll end up with a hundred yes votes, all made by the two or three fanatics keeping this thread from dying.

Some people voting down too.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947159

Must've been leaked on another website.

yototata1 said:

What do you mean ? It seems... really odd to me put this way I'll be honest.
Because if you mean ONLY people who have an account or are acknowledged on this site, let's be real it's probably impossible to change anything. At least 1 mod is straight transphobic not even denying it. To be real, your sentence sound like "Those in power shall stay in power" thing. Not to say it is tho, just what I'm getting from it.

this /\

sadodere said:

Some people voting down too.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/users/947159

Must've been leaked on another website.

Hypocrites. Lol

I find it hilarious that this is even a discussion. It really doesn't matter what someone thinks; the reality is that Bridget is a girl in the canon of Guilty Gear Strive. You can cope and mald all you want, that's not going to change. The fact that a Japanese developer, of all nationalities (don't even pretend that Japan isn't backward in a lot of ways regarding LGBTQ issues), went ahead and decided to be slightly progressive for once broke the brains of a lot of dorks and that brings me some catharsis, I will admit.

yototata1 said:

What do you mean ? It seems... really odd to me put this way I'll be honest.
Because if you mean ONLY people who have an account or are acknowledged on this site, let's be real it's probably impossible to change anything. At least 1 mod is straight transphobic not even denying it. To be real, your sentence sound like "Those in power shall stay in power" thing. Not to say it is tho, just what I'm getting from it.

Okay, I WILL confess that there is a specific mod in mind who has said a lot of transphobic stuff for the past few years...

But I think this is mainly so people aren't creating duplicate accounts just to rig the vote. Which, I WILL say, Danbooru very openly saves IP addresses and stuff. I've even had a mod "brag"(?) about it to me when I made a new account (this one) for various reasons concerning my old one.

Better to be safe than sorry, I guess. I get it, rigged votes are never helpful.

I created an account here because I had seen the convos happening and the multiple other threads derail and get locked. I actually have had my own fanart of Bridget be uploaded on this site, 1 being where shes tagged as a boy and 1 where shes tagged as a girl. It almost being a case where I had to draw actual breasts on her just for my own intentions to be recognized for how I've drawn and intended the character to be seen. Again, I understand the reasons for it, with the way the tagging system is done, but it feels like I have to go really out of my way to show how I want my art to be seen if it's going to be uploaded to this site at least.

Safebooru which is another booru site seems to have already made the change and handle all post-strive posts as 1girl for bridget, and seems to be working fine there, I believe.

sadodere said:

Okay, I WILL confess that there is a specific mod in mind who has said a lot of transphobic stuff for the past few years...

But I think this is mainly so people aren't creating duplicate accounts just to rig the vote. Which, I WILL say, Danbooru very openly saves IP addresses and stuff. I've even had a mod "brag"(?) about it to me when I made a new account (this one) for various reasons concerning my old one.

Better to be safe than sorry, I guess. I get it, rigged votes are never helpful.

Is a mod not supposed to be someone reasonable that will assist in defusing issues... I don't feel a person that is openly against any protected minority fits that role even slightly...

Look y'all, the creator of the damn game had to come out and say it due to the stupid ass backlash.
Let's not keep pretending Bridget isn't a girl. A trans girl, i.e. a girl because that's how gender works.

Izumi_blah said:

I created an account here because I had seen the convos happening and the multiple other threads derail and get locked. I actually have had my own fanart of Bridget be uploaded on this site, 1 being where shes tagged as a boy and 1 where shes tagged as a girl. It almost being a case where I had to draw actual breasts on her just for my own intentions to be recognized for how I've drawn and intended the character to be seen. Again, I understand the reasons for it, with the way the tagging system is done, but it feels like I have to go really out of my way to show how I want my art to be seen if it's going to be uploaded to this site at least.

Safebooru which is another booru site seems to have already made the change and handle all post-strive posts as 1girl for bridget, and seems to be working fine there, I believe.

+1 for safebooru and generally more acceptance in a lot of sites.
Also for those wondering, Pixiv is also making the change (slowly albeit) to be more inclusive. Which kinda make the argument "but Pixiv..." fall apart.

Little edit :
Yes, even Japanese websites and mentality do change towards inclusiveness.

sadodere said:

Okay, I WILL confess that there is a specific mod in mind who has said a lot of transphobic stuff for the past few years...

But I think this is mainly so people aren't creating duplicate accounts just to rig the vote. Which, I WILL say, Danbooru very openly saves IP addresses and stuff. I've even had a mod "brag"(?) about it to me when I made a new account (this one) for various reasons concerning my old one.

Better to be safe than sorry, I guess. I get it, rigged votes are never helpful.

Then leaving out the accounts with matching IPs would be the way to go about it, not siding with the transphobes and actively ignoring my vote since I found out from a third party.

Yeah, duplicating accounts is obviously unfair and scummy, but what does it matter WHERE someone heard about the poll? I have visited and known about this site for a while, and never had any incentive to make an account, but this poll was the final push I needed.

The fact that it's even left up to debate is actually pathetic, because it's actively allowing people to vote yes on the question "will we continue to misgender this girl?"

Izumi_blah said:
Safebooru which is another booru site seems to have already made the change and handle all post-strive posts as 1girl for bridget, and seems to be working fine there, I believe.

Safebooru and Gelbooru and Sankaku and Yande.re and E621 and others are different communities with different norms and different tagging methodologies, what works for one booru doesn't necessarily work for others and its users. Safebooru also doesn't have to care about NSFW content so it's easier to make that decision.

LovelyLeafeon7 said:
Then leaving out the accounts with matching IPs would be the way to go about it, not siding with the transphobes and actively ignoring my vote since I found out from a third party.

Then what? Nobody knows if you're only here to virtue signal for a cause and don't give a flying fuck about the site. I'm also sure you wouldn't be spouting such horseshit if it was a majority making votes against, rather you'd be crying about vote fraud.

evazion said:

BUR #12569 has been rejected.

mass update bridget_(guilty_gear) guilty_gear_strive 1boy rating:general -> 1girl -1boy -otoko_no_ko -male_focus -crossdressing

This would tag Bridget as a girl on all SFW Guilty Gear Strive posts. See bridget_(guilty_gear) guilty_gear_strive rating:general to see which posts this would affect.

Just as a quick note, this BUR seems to be missing solo. There are rating:g posts where Bridget is present with other girls, such as post #5691949. If the BUR goes through as-is, this post'd be tagged "1girl 2girls", rather than "3girls", as it should.

g6672D said:

Safebooru and Gelbooru and Sankaku and Yande.re and E621 and others are different communities with different norms and different tagging methodologies, what works for one booru doesn't necessarily work for others and its users. Safebooru also doesn't have to care about NSFW content so it's easier to make that decision.

Then what? Nobody knows if you're only here to virtue signal for a cause and don't give a flying fuck about the site. I'm also sure you wouldn't be spouting such horseshit if it was a majority making votes against, rather you'd be crying about vote fraud.

So... your entire argument is based off just making assumptions about me without zero evidence, nor factual statements. Just wild accusations and an opinion on how I MIGHT react in a hypothetical scenario?

Good to know that's the logic you are going with.

Yap, I've used this site constantly for finding references for poses and other things, it's a insanely powerful tool for searching up ideas, images for moodboards, seeing collections of artists work. I used it frequently as a lurker and have some of my own art uploaded here, I just never felt the need to make an account.

Then what? Nobody knows if you're only here to virtue signal for a cause and don't give a flying fuck about the site. I'm also sure you wouldn't be spouting such horseshit if it was a majority making votes against, rather you'd be crying about vote fraud.

Well, I mean LovelyLeafon7 is litterally giving you an option (go with IP)in case people make several accounts... So I don't know at all what you are complaining about I'll admit...

Small edit :
+Making an account takes investement. As a lot of person stated, they didn't until now because they didn't feel the need for. But now they did SPECIFICALLY to gender Bridget correctly.

Is this thread still going?
Hi mom o/