Tag Implication: izayoi sakuya (cosplay) -> enmaided

Implicating izayoi sakuya (cosplay) -> enmaided.

Reason: Sakuya is a maid, so dressing as her means dressing as a maid.

Imagine Izayoi Sakuya and Yumeko doing a costume switch.

Implications from characters to characteristics is a no-go because doing so for all characters from all copyrights ever is not a scalable practice, and the same applies here.

S1eth said:
Imagine Izayoi Sakuya and Yumeko doing a costume switch.

Apart from color, how would you be able to tell?

Point taken, in any case.

I thought that was the point, that there'd be no visible difference (making the tag look weird).

But I'd like to know what the practical difference is between enmaided and just maid in the first place.
Since we only tag by what we see, the enmaided qualifier of not canonically being a maid is kind of unusable...

Alignn said:
Since we only tag by what we see, the enmaided qualifier of not canonically being a maid is kind of unusable...

Tagging on Danbooru follows three principals:

• Tag what you see (not what you know)
• Tag [only] what you [and others] want to search for
• Tag only what is objectively agreeable on

Non of these principals are followed blindly or absolutely, nor should they be. It's all about compromise and good judgement.

A similar topic has been discussed in forum #73975. Your argument against enmaided also attacks alternative costume, adapted costume, young, adult, alternative hair style and alternative hair color.

Tags like these are useful and easily agreeable on, given just a little outside knowledge about the character (which you need anyway to tag the character name).

Fair enough... but isn't enmaided specifically already covered by maid alternate_costume?

Alignn said:
Fair enough... but isn't enmaided specifically already covered by maid alternate_costume?

Counter examples:
A maid in alternate/adapted maid costume e.g. post #1082033
A maid is present, but it is other characters are in alternate costume e.g. post #1004820

Alignn said:
Fair enough... but isn't enmaided specifically already covered by maid alternate_costume?

No. At least, probably not. Not enough to warrant deleting the tag, in my opinion. A few examples off the top of my head:

• Remilia scarlet playing dress-up/cosplay with izayoi sakuya watching. No enmaided tag.
• An adapted costume to look like a maid costume. No alternative costume tag.
• A cast of characters dressing up in alternative costumes and going to a maid cafe. No enmaided tag.

Edit: Ninja'd

Alright.