Donmai

Tag discussion: removed <-> off

Posted under General

Danielx21

These tags are more-or-less the same thing:

  • There is something wearable and someone in the same image, but the person is not wearing the thing.

There are a few small differences in descriptions, like glasses_removed saying that any pair of glasses that "are present in the pic but not worn" are fine, whereas hat_off says that someone was "supposedly wearing [the hat] a short while before the image". These nuances sound negligible, though.

Maybe they could be aliases one way or another, for consistency. Some of these already are.

The numbers between parentheses are the quantity of posts, according to the tag search. (http://danbooru.donmai.us/tag)

Updated by jxh2154

Reply
jxh2154

Did:
create alias eyepatch_off -> eyepatch_removed
create alias clothes_off -> clothes_removed
create alias glasses_off -> glasses_removed
create alias hat_off -> hat_removed
create alias helmet_off -> helmet_removed
create alias shirt_off -> shirt_removed
create alias shoes_off -> shoes_removed

Reply
jxh2154

Did:
create alias bra_off -> bra_removed
create alias skirt_off -> skirt_removed
create alias socks_off -> socks_removed
create alias jacket_off -> jacket_removed
create alias clothes_off -> clothes_removed
create alias undressed -> clothes_removed

Seems clothes_off already had an alias in place which is why it didn't work. Undid that and moved to removed.

Reply
jxh2154

Danielx21 said:
Apparently, turning a tag with aliases into an alias requires special care. I'll have that in mind.

It's just the way the Batch Create functionality I have works. I can submit about 10 at once using a specific syntax, but if 1 of those 10 existed and can't be created, I'm not explicitly told that, so I don't notice sometimes.

Did
create alias mask_off -> mask_removed
create alias goggles_off -> goggles_removed
create alias necktie_off -> necktie_removed

Reply
Danielx21

S1eth said:
-1 to
shirt_removed
is also used for sweaters and other upper-body clothes
shoes_removed
is also used for boots, sandals, slippers and other footwear

Too confusing! Then, at least, apparently the latter should be footwear removed. (for comparison, the most popular tag with "footwear" in the name is cross-laced footwear)

Don't forget we have jacket removed and could have sweater removed, if needed.

EDIT:

Removing my opinion against using shirt removed for any upper-body clothes, because on second thought I see it has some merit.

Updated

Reply
S1eth

shirt_lift, shirt_pull, shirt_tug, shirt_slip, sleeveless_shirt, tied_shirt, shirt_grab and more have always been using the name "shirt" as a catch-all for a variety of upper-body clothes such as shirts, blouses, sweaters, tank_tops, etc.

Jxh, please remove the impossible_shirt, open_shirt, torn_shirt and wet_shirt implications which were created in forum #68613. Those all include blouses, tank_tops, cardigans, camisoles and other clothes that aren't shirts.

Reply
jxh2154

Did:
remove implication impossible_shirt -> shirt
remove implication open_shirt -> shirt
remove implication torn_shirt -> shirt
remove implication wet_shirt -> shirt
create implication bra_removed -> bra
create implication eyepatch_removed -> eyepatch
create implication goggles_removed -> goggles
create implication helmet_removed -> helmet
create implication jacket_removed -> jacket
create implication mask_removed -> mask
create implication necktie_removed -> necktie
create implication panties_removed -> panties

Daniel, you said:
Related alias: panties_removed -> panties

Did you mean panties_off -> panties_removed?

Reply
1