- pool #4197: utsuho's fancy cannon
Aparently it is an empty duplicate of pool #2318.
Posted under General
Aparently it is an empty duplicate of pool #2318.
pool #1692: "American live-action movie adaptations of video games. RE, SH, Street fighter, etc. to name a few"
Seems pretty pointless. Whoever made it wanted art of any video game that got an American live action movie adaptation, I guess. Only four images in it.
pool #4242 - Hot Maids
I don't really think the criteria presented is pool material.
Empty pool.
pool #1991, "I Just Shot Marvin in the Face", images showing lack of trigger discipline.
Contains 3 posts, nothing more added for more than a year.
SonicGTR pointed this out a year ago, but I though I'd bring it up again, since images with lack of trigger discipline just shouldn't be tagged with that?
pool #4255 - a Playboy Playground
This is a new pool with few images, but from the description, it seems mostly redundant to the bunnysuit tag.
Shintear said:
pool #4242 - Hot Maids
I don't really think the criteria presented is pool material.
I totally disagree. It surely is pool material, like countless other pools that follow the pattern "Beautiful Girl that is something".
To be fair, if Shintear's criticisms are somehow valid, one way to keep the pool while catering to them, would simply be changing the criteria of the pool.
Shintear said:
pool #4242 - Hot Maids
I don't really think the criteria presented is pool material.
Well sorta meh it still falls into the "theme pool" category. That being said going by the description it does need some pruning.
Do not show a maid. They show a waitress in a maid costume.
post #987675 does not specifically show a maid either. That would require meta knowledge that the girl depicted is a maid.
post #788923 does in fact show a "sexy maid" as she does appear to follow the general maid criteria.
Also
pool #4175 and pool #4242 HAVE to be by their definitions, mutually exclusive.
aka post #788923 cannot be both.
Popebug said:
Just out of curiousity, could you give any examples of those "countless other pools", not including the ones you made?
Sure I can.
pool #3719, pool #2465, pool #2887, pool #1394, pool #1392, pool #208, pool #3032.
Sorry, but your argument doesn't hold up.
Most of those pools are either expressions that aren't covered by tags (pool #3717, pool #2465, pool #1392) or more specific versions of tags (pool #208). That is not the same as making pools about a specific occupation or outfit that's already covered by tags.
Popebug said:
That is not the same as making pools about a specific occupation or outfit that's already covered by tags.
Technically "hot maid" is no more covered by tags then pool #1214 "perfect ass", so it still fits into the basic "theme pool".
Michael_Fesser said:
Technically "hot maid" is no more covered by tags then pool #1214 "perfect ass", so it still fits into the basic "theme pool".
Now that's a good point for once.
pool #4255 - "a Playboy Playground"
Is this necessary? Posts are easily searchable based on the description, if you ask me.
pool #4263 - "Not Self Explanatory"
Isn't this just pool #1844 - Speculation Fuel?
pool #4265 - "a Playboy Playground"
Got recreated again.
Janitor edit: Kit25 created 4265.
pool #4107 - "Touhou - The Imperial Gensokyo Army"
Easily duplicated by searching touhou and military_uniform
Mysterio006 said:
pool #4107 - "Touhou - The Imperial Gensokyo Army"
Probably ok if it's culled down to the k step2009 set and it's imitators.
pool #2531 "Awkward sex"
Could easily be changed to a tag of the same name. Scary sex is a similar tag, so awkward sex should follow that pattern.