Donmai

Nuking old deprecated tags

Posted under Tags

evazion said:

If we're not done by the deadline and people are still working on it then I'll extend the deadline. For this first batch I think I overestimated how much people could get done.

Some tags have seen good progress so far, but some like tied hair and remodel (kantai collection) have seen little to none.

Thank you! Yeah the general consensus on the discord so far is none of us seem to care about remodel.

Sounds great. I figure that if there are actual hands on the tags then it won't be a zero-sum game of trying to encourage people to garden these out. Having those tag count updates also helps with bumping the topic to the top so hopefully more eyes get on it. I do want to dive in as well with a few.

As far as remodel (Kantai Collection) goes for example, there's not many people who are actually knowledgeable about this to make a good decision with tag replacement so yeah I think that one's just gotta get toasted to force the KanColle people to switch tags but without the help of the deprecated tag.

WRS said:

Sounds great. I figure that if there are actual hands on the tags then it won't be a zero-sum game of trying to encourage people to garden these out. Having those tag count updates also helps with bumping the topic to the top so hopefully more eyes get on it. I do want to dive in as well with a few.

As far as remodel (Kantai Collection) goes for example, there's not many people who are actually knowledgeable about this to make a good decision with tag replacement so yeah I think that one's just gotta get toasted to force the KanColle people to switch tags but without the help of the deprecated tag.

I made myself learn about ole tower for a week or so to clean those tags up, could probably slowly chip away at that tag (as soon as I'm done with my fixation on playing lego star wars). 12k posts is so many goodness.

I personally would start with remodel_(kantai_collection) solo to try and bang out the easier ones, using wikis as reference for what the remodel is, if anyone else needs a point to launch from.

Updated

Ylimegirl said:

I personally would start with remodel_(kantai_collection) solo to try and bang out the easier ones, using wikis as reference for what the remodel is, if anyone else needs a point to launch from.

Here's the thing: back when we deprecated the remodel tag and moved them to the appropriate kai ni chartags, the BUR that was made for the task (forum #203532) already took care of the ones that were solo, had only 1 chartag in the art, and were not tagged cosplay. The remainder that weren't affected (which I gardened initially) were group illustrations involving 2girls or more, or involved cosplay.

ArcieA said:

Here's the thing: back when we deprecated the remodel tag and moved them to the appropriate kai ni chartags, the BUR that was made for the task (forum #203532) already took care of the ones that were solo, had only 1 chartag in the art, and were not tagged cosplay. The remainder that weren't affected (which I gardened initially) were group illustrations involving 2girls or more, or involved cosplay.

Well there's still 900 or so posts in that search to clean up regardless. 810 without the cosplay tag.

Ylimegirl said:

Well there's still 900 or so posts in that search to clean up regardless. 810 without the cosplay tag.

About half of that was due to Suzuya having been missed off the BUR. I've cleared all her ones from there except for 14 where I'm not sure how it was concluded that it was her remodel.

edit: another 79 were katsuragi - these are all cleared, including 1 mistag.

Updated

Slightly late, was scranning on Korean BBQ Wings at midnight. Also, goodbye green_legwear and pink_legwear.

Post counts after 24~ days with total progress and daily changes

white_legwear: 51965 posts (-13603) -640
black_legwear: 44399 posts (-12396) -583
red_legwear: 8164 posts (-450) -52
blue_legwear: 4843 posts (-345) -208
green_legwear: 0 posts (-3247) -294
purple_legwear: 5097 posts (-1937) -372
pink_legwear: 0 posts (-5269) -1450
brown_legwear: 11708 posts (-392) -35
grey_legwear: 3842 posts (-1825) -604
black_neckwear: 4311 posts (-339) -1
blue_neckwear: 3488 posts (-3060) -2
green_neckwear: 2064 posts (-594) -1
hands: 1248 posts (-15448) -22
fingers_together: 726 posts (-2999) 0
tied_hair: 15644 posts (-2302) -1
remodel_(kantai collection): 11453 posts (-1108) -895

Any thoughts on whether or not Intrepid Kai deserves a tag?

Aside from equipment the main difference is in the style and colouring of her neckerchief, which is noticeable when she's wearing her official outfit. There are 4 images with the remodel tag solely for her in that form, plus a few others with the tag where she's one of several that would get a remodel tag if there was one. There's no general tags that would bring up the neckerchief differences as both versions have two colours so no way other than the remodel tag to search for the relatively few images where she's visibly in her kai form outfit.

--

edit: apart from Intrepid Kai pics and one of the Italian kanmusu that I don't really know, all official art now no longer has the remodel tag.

Updated

Post counts after 25~ days with total progress and daily changes

white_legwear: 51919 posts (-13649) -46
black_legwear: 43009 posts (-13786) -1390
red_legwear: 7398 posts (-1216) -766
blue_legwear: 4609 posts (-579) -234
purple_legwear: 4443 posts (-2591) -654
brown_legwear: 11704 posts (-396) -4
grey_legwear: 497 posts (-5170) -3345
black_neckwear: 4310 posts (-340) -1
blue_neckwear: 3488 posts (-3060) 0
green_neckwear: 2064 posts (-594) 0
hands: 1248 posts (-15448) 0
fingers_together: 726 posts (-2999) 0
tied_hair: 15640 posts (-2306) -4
remodel_(kantai collection): 11377 posts (-1184) -76

See you grey_legwear...

Post counts after 26~ days with total progress and daily changes

white_legwear: 49691 posts (-15877) -2228
black_legwear: 42189 posts (-14606) -820
red_legwear: 7034 posts (-1580) -364
blue_legwear: 3701 posts (-1487) -908
purple_legwear: 4031 posts (-3003) -412
brown_legwear: 6441 posts (-5659) -5263
grey_legwear: 0 posts (-5667) -497
black_neckwear: 4309 posts (-341) -1
blue_neckwear: 3488 posts (-3060) 0
green_neckwear: 2064 posts (-594) 0
hands: 1248 posts (-15448) 0
fingers_together: 726 posts (-2999) 0
tied_hair: 15637 posts (-2309) -3
remodel_(kantai collection): 10000 posts (-2561) -1377

@commentary_request with the carry on brown_legwear my goodness...

Post counts after 27~ days with total progress and daily changes

white_legwear: 49501 posts (-16067) -190
black_legwear: 41363 posts (-15432) -826
red_legwear: 7027 posts (-1587) -7
blue_legwear: 3650 posts (-1538) -51
purple_legwear: 3792 posts (-3242) -239
brown_legwear: 0 posts (-12100) -6441
black_neckwear: 4309 posts (-341) 0
blue_neckwear: 3488 posts (-3060) 0
green_neckwear: 1983 posts (-675) -81
hands: 618 posts (-16078) -630
fingers_together: 726 posts (-2999) 0
tied_hair: 15631 posts (-2315) -6
remodel_(kantai collection): 10000 posts (-2561) 0

We wave goodbye to red_legwear and (finally) hands

Post counts after 28~ days with total progress and daily changes

white_legwear: 49409 posts (-16159) -92
black_legwear: 39228 posts (-17567) -2135
red_legwear: 0 posts (-8632) -7027
blue_legwear: 3489 posts (-1699) -161
purple_legwear: 3296 posts (-3738) -496
black_neckwear: 4264 posts (-386) -45
blue_neckwear: 3488 posts (-3060) 0
green_neckwear: 1983 posts (-675) 0
hands: 0 posts (-16716) -618
fingers_together: 615 posts (-3110) -111
tied_hair: 15631 posts (-2315) 0
remodel_(kantai collection): 9690 posts (-2871) -310

Post counts after 29~ days with total progress and daily changes

white_legwear: 49398 posts (-16170) -11
black_legwear: 37859 posts (-18936) -1369
blue_legwear: 3489 posts (-1699) 0
purple_legwear: 3070 posts (-3964) -226
black_neckwear: 4234 posts (-416) -30
blue_neckwear: 3262 posts (-3286) -226
green_neckwear: 1982 posts (-676) -1
fingers_together: 610 posts (-3115) -5
tied_hair: 15126 posts (-2820) -505
remodel_(kantai collection): 9204 posts (-3357) -486

1 2