About Elizabeth Fate tags

I initially proposed BUR #34007 with pointing most towards the elizabeth bathory ccc tag before being told in forum #320588 that this was incorrect and reverted it. I'd like to argue against that change, since it goes counterintuitive to other base tags for characters we have like Nero Claudius (fate), Artoria Pendragon (fate), and Jeanne d'Arc (fate). We already imply all of her first few Halloween variants to the base tag (Pretender excluded, which I'm not fighting against) so it feels vaguely messy to have all her Lancer costumes pointing to the base tag.

BUR #34342 has been rejected.

create implication elizabeth_bathory_(second_ascension)_(fate) -> elizabeth_bathory_(fate/extra_ccc)
remove implication elizabeth_bathory_(second_ascension)_(fate) -> elizabeth_bathory_(fate)
create implication elizabeth_bathory_(third_ascension)_(fate) -> elizabeth_bathory_(fate/extra_ccc)
remove implication elizabeth_bathory_(third_ascension)_(fate) -> elizabeth_bathory_(fate)
create implication elizabeth_bathory_(joint_recital)_(fate) -> elizabeth_bathory_(fate/extra_ccc)
remove implication elizabeth_bathory_(joint_recital)_(fate) -> elizabeth_bathory_(fate)

Pointing her second, third, & joint recital ascensions to her CCC tag.

BUR #34343 has been approved by @evazion.

create alias elizabeth_bathory_(fate/extra_ccc) -> elizabeth_bathory_(fate/extra)

Actually, why do we have the CCC at the end there? We don't qualify BB (fate/extra) with CCC even though she never appeared in the original fate/extra.

BUR #34685 has been rejected.

create alias elizabeth_bathory_(corroded)_(fate) -> elizabeth_void_(fate)
create alias corroded_elizabeth_(fate) -> elizabeth_void_(fate)

Official name is エリザベート・ヴォイド, localized as "Corroded Elizabeth".

Ylimegirl said:

BUR #34685 has been rejected.

create alias elizabeth_bathory_(corroded)_(fate) -> elizabeth_void_(fate)
create alias corroded_elizabeth_(fate) -> elizabeth_void_(fate)

Official name is エリザベート・ヴォイド, localized as "Corroded Elizabeth".

Where does "Elizabeth Void" come from? IIRC Extella calls her Corroded Elizabeth and/or Dark Eliza.

xcv450 said:

Where does "Elizabeth Void" come from? IIRC Extella calls her Corroded Elizabeth and/or Dark Eliza.

Taking my information from TYPE-MOON Wiki, which has of course never been wrong ever.

This bulk update request is pending automatic rejection in 5 days.

Ylimegirl said:

I initially proposed BUR #34007 with pointing most towards the elizabeth bathory ccc tag before being told in forum #320588 that this was incorrect and reverted it. I'd like to argue against that change, since it goes counterintuitive to other base tags for characters we have like Nero Claudius (fate), Artoria Pendragon (fate), and Jeanne d'Arc (fate). We already imply all of her first few Halloween variants to the base tag (Pretender excluded, which I'm not fighting against) so it feels vaguely messy to have all her Lancer costumes pointing to the base tag.

I agree with NNT. She has the same outfit in Fate/Extra CCC, Fate/EXTELLA, and in her first ascension in Fate/Grand Order. I see no reason why other outfit tags should imply her original outfit.

I don't know what is going on with those other characters because their implication hierarchies are too convoluted. Convoluted hierarchies like these should be avoided. Keep it simple and strive to have one base tag and one subtag per unique appearance.

The bulk update request #34342 (forum #321769) has been rejected by @evazion.

The bulk update request #34343 (forum #321770) has been approved by @evazion.

Ylimegirl said:

BUR #34685 has been rejected.

create alias elizabeth_bathory_(corroded)_(fate) -> elizabeth_void_(fate)
create alias corroded_elizabeth_(fate) -> elizabeth_void_(fate)

Official name is エリザベート・ヴォイド, localized as "Corroded Elizabeth".

Don't we normally stick with the localized name?

This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 45 days.

The bulk update request #34685 (forum #323174) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.