Donmai

Convert "Googling Yourself" pool into the tag "Egosearching"

Posted under Tags

BUR #36115 is pending approval.

mass update pool:14334 -> egosearching
nuke pool:14334
create alias googling_yourself -> egosearching
create alias egosurfing -> egosearching
create alias egogoogling -> egosearching
create alias autogoogling -> egosearching
create alias self-googling -> egosearching
create alias vanity_searching -> egosearching

The concept of someone searching their own name on the internet as covered in Googling Yourself pool is a clearly defined practice that should have been its own tag rather than a pool. So I think the pool should be converted into a tag "egosearching" and make the name of the pool an alias. Also adding a bunch of alternate name of the act as an alias.

sinning said:

i support it being turned into a tag, but what's wrong with the current pool name?

OP is right that ego<something> is the commonly accepted name for it, there's no reason for us to be stubborn to keep this odd name.

ANON_TOKYO said:

Why not egosurfing, just like the Wikipedia page? Not because of that, but at least in my experience egosurfing is the more common term (and Wikipedia using that seems to back it up).

Because imo having "searching" in the tag name would be enough to tell what the tag is about.

"egosurfing" had about 55,300 results on Google vs "egosearching" which only had about 4,300 results. This is likely reflected with the anime Oshi no ko's translation using the term "egosurfing" as well in both the name of the episode and when talked about within the episode involving it. The Japanese title of the same episode is エゴサーチ (Ego Sāchi ie egosearching).

Given this, "egosurfing" appears to be the term used more in English so I would support its use over "egosearching."

Side note: spellcheck is flagging "egosearching" as a misspelled word, but isn't for "egosurfing."

Updated

Egosurfing is far more common in English, despite the Japanese egosa/egosaachi coming from egosearching (ergo not wasei eigo), so I support egosurfing. An alias from egosearching to egosurfing could be added, but it'd be the only thing that appears in autocomplete anyway.

As a prescriptive nitpick, I also don't like the current pool name because "Googling" is considered incorrect compared to something more verbose, like "Google searching" or "searching with Google" (or something engine-agnostic).

Updated

LQ said:

As a prescriptive nitpick, I also don't like the current pool name because "Googling" is considerable incorrect compared to something more verbose, like "Google searching" or "searching with Google" (or something engine-agnostic).

That's only a nitpick Google makes because they don't want the trademark on the word "Google" to genericize like aspirin, which thus makes the use of "Google" incorrect in their eyes. That is to say that it's a pointless thing to bring up, especially when the pool is going to get nuked once the tag gets made anyway, and the use of "Google" as a verb has decreased in public use anyway in favor of searching as apps become the preferred means of accessing info and thus you'd be more likely to be searching within the app itself rather than only searching the open web with a specific search engine in mind; you can't "Google" yourself on Twitter, you egosurf there.

Due to the arguments above I prefer the first one.
However I think the aliases are a bit overkill. Aliasing egosurfing and egogoogling is not useful, because egosearching will appear in an ego* search (heh)

1