id:8637996..8638004 -id:8638002
What's the problem with these 8 posts?
I don’t expect them to be approved; I just want to know the reasons for their deletion besides "disinterested".
Posted under General
id:8637996..8638004 -id:8638002
What's the problem with these 8 posts?
I don’t expect them to be approved; I just want to know the reasons for their deletion besides "disinterested".
Witch-Hunter-Siegfried said:
Now that I’ve found art of her it’d be nice if the BBB concept art could be undeleted for comparison (not sure how to add it to her Wiki page)
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8209906
Edit: Her design only ever appears in concept art for context
For future reference, if you think an image should be added to a wiki but don't think it is likely to be approved, you can embed the asset to the wiki without posting it by typing the link like this (without quotes):
"* !asset #[ID HERE]"
post #8489385
post #8634544
post #8634580
If anyone has any specific feedback for any of these I'd be interested to hear it. Thanks.
kimonomiko said:
post #8634580
If anyone has any specific feedback for any of these I'd be interested to hear it. Thanks.
post #8634580 - The raised arm is poorly proportioned. It being raised and angled should make the forearm shorter but it appears longer than it should be. The angle is also slightly off.
I like the artists stuff though so thanks for introducing me to them!
https://danbooru.donmai.us/forum_posts/328693
Maybe I'm being a hypocrite because I'm technically new, but I don't think putting a rationale for new inquiries is "spamming" since not everyone will have read the previous inquiry
I don't see any compression artifacts.
I don't understand why these are not being approved. Some are from the same artists whose other artworks were approved.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8638786
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8636982
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8636842
Another that got deleted despite the only differences from all other approved parent and siblings is the color scheme. Either the color scheme is just ugly or modqueue is slow this week.
didsomeonejustsayweeaboo said:
https://danbooru.donmai.us/forum_posts/328693
Maybe I'm being a hypocrite because I'm technically new, but I don't think putting a rationale for new inquiries is "spamming" since not everyone will have read the previous inquiry
I don't see any compression artifacts.
It was the same rationale last time too. The only difference is it was put alongside other post numbers.
Knowledge_Seeker said:
Either the color scheme is just ugly or modqueue is slow this week.
The latter most likely, it went down to around ~1200 a few days ago before NYE, now it's at around ~1600.
VidiViciVeniViciVeni said:
I don't understand why these are not being approved. Some are from the same artists whose other artworks were approved.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8638786
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8636982
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8636842
post #8636842: It probably doesn't affect the overall quality of the artwork, but something about how Marichka holds her AK looks kind of off.
Updated
NoIdea4GoodName said:
The latter most likely, it went down to around ~1200 a few days ago before NYE, now it's at around ~1600.
Yeah, I was assuming it was the latter due to the fluctuation of my own uploads in queue. Modqueue is always much slower around the holidays like New Year's for what I hope are obvious reasons, and there's not really much you can do about bad timing besides appeal it or ask about here lol.
Either way, the post in question is approved now. Thank you!
Post it here or it will flood down the holiday's season.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8636935
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8638476
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8646397
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8646445
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8647410
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8647424
So many posts are in the modqueue with little to no approvers and also in the appeal hell that also have fewer approvers around.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8641806?q=user%3AWitch-Hunter-Siegfried
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/8641817?q=user%3AWitch-Hunter-Siegfried
Why were these 2 deleted, they're of the same quality and style as the rest of his stuff and there's 100s of pieces from the artist on here.
definitelysleeping said:
They weren't 'removed', they failed to be approved in the 3-day window during which posts from restricted users' posts are 'pending'. As a restricted user, it's not enough for your posts to not break any rules, they have to be high enough quality to attract the attention of an approver.
If you look at the last post you listed, you will see that 11 approvers looked at the image while it was pending and declined to approve it. That's actually better than many, as only 6 approvers looked at two of the posts I was asking about here. Feel free to look at mine to see some other examples of posts that failed to get approved, but at the end of the day, it is 100% subjective on the part of the approvers. The best you can do is upload the highest quality images you can find and hope for the best, while far worse slop gets approved for inscrutable reasons.
Sorry for the mistake in words, I just used a translator. You're right that it is subjective, but I've already uploaded images of an artist who approves almost all of his works, but arbitrarily does not approve some of his drawings that have the same quality and do not break any rules. In addition, some contributors who no longer need to have their drawings approved upload content of dubious quality. Instead of contributors helping other people to reach their same level, they only hinder it, as I said, it seems that they do not want them to exist anymore.
NoIdea4GoodName said:
The latter most likely, it went down to around ~1200 a few days ago before NYE, now it's at around ~1600.
post #8636842: It probably doesn't affect the overall quality of the artwork, but something about how Kraken holds her AK looks kind of off.
That's not an AK, that's an RPK. the approvers are also just stating "disinterest" instead of "low quality"
post #8640131
post #8641154
post #8642076 (Larger, transparent version of post #2887727)
I've been posting a lot of official Pokémon art recently, and while most of it has been approved, these three weren't.
Updated
VidiViciVeniViciVeni said:
That's not an AK, that's an RPK. the approvers are also just stating "disinterest" instead of "low quality"
"Disinterest" is just the most simple way of saying, that an approver didn't like it enough. It could mean anything from "I don't like it" to "I think it has bad aspects" like a bad arm etc. Stating "poor quality" is mostly used for very poor quality images, but needs more clicks for us, which is why we mostly only use "disinterest".
Because I saw your appeal message:
Just a little reminder for everyone, that it doesn't matter how many approved images an artist has on this site. Artist can draw poor images once in a while, it's not against the law for them.
Nacha said:
"Disinterest" is just the most simple way of saying, that an approver didn't like it enough. It could mean anything from "I don't like it" to "I think it has bad aspects" like a bad arm etc. Stating "poor quality" is mostly used for very poor quality images, but needs more clicks for us, which is why we mostly only use "disinterest".
Because I saw your appeal message:
Just a little reminder for everyone, that it doesn't matter how many approved images an artist has on this site. Artist can draw poor images once in a while, it's not against the law for them.
So because of a badly drawn arm it'll be rejected?
I could upload Kraken and Otaman's transparent profiles then, would it work?
Nacha said:
"Disinterest" is just the most simple way of saying, that an approver didn't like it enough. It could mean anything from "I don't like it" to "I think it has bad aspects" like a bad arm etc. Stating "poor quality" is mostly used for very poor quality images, but needs more clicks for us, which is why we mostly only use "disinterest".
Because I saw your appeal message:
Just a little reminder for everyone, that it doesn't matter how many approved images an artist has on this site. Artist can draw poor images once in a while, it's not against the law for them.
Oh sure, but if the images are the same quality as everything else that's been approved/uploaded by approvers, then it really leaves people completely in the dark about why the upload isn't getting approved. The problem is that this forum thread is treated as a dumping ground/containment zone, and the modqueue has so many pages of pending uploads that changing that by taking time to give actual useful feedback will almost certainly result in even fewer approvals.