Posted under General
CoreMack said:
BUR #31836 has been rejected.
nuke pool:23310
"Any posts relating to Sweden and China."
5/8 of the pool is just gotland_(kancolle) in a china dress. Would not be the first pool created by this user (LenaLatoya) to be nuked.
Unanimous upvotes so I just nuked it manually
The bulk update request #31836 (forum #308994) has been rejected by @CoreMack.
The bulk update request #30095 (forum #298793) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.
The bulk update request #30095 (forum #298793) has been approved by @nonamethanks.
I just noticed that a bunch of gluttony-related pools were removed for some reason. I tried to see if there was a discussion here (or elsewhere in the forum for that matter) to no avail. Anyone know why? It definitely wasn't a "pointless" pool, given how many posts populated each of them, at least for me.
@Jnglmpera said:
I just noticed that a bunch of gluttony-related pools were removed for some reason. I tried to see if there was a discussion here (or elsewhere in the forum for that matter) to no avail. Anyone know why? It definitely wasn't a "pointless" pool, given how many posts populated each of them, at least for me.
forum #298665
Remove because we have glutton
pool #23758
Seems to be a favorites pool of bikini topless.
John_Hopfield said:
forum #298665
Remove because we have glutton
I don't remember seeing that forum post... Wouldn't there have been a notice the same way tags get notices when someone is discussing change? I would've voted not in favor of nuking the pools (perhaps as a neutral vote), if only because they would've been fine as it was to me. "If it ain't broke don't fix it", after all.
BUR #33249 is pending approval.
mass update pool:9549 -> nishimura's_fleet_(kancolle)
mass update pool:10954 -> kimura's_raiding_force_(kancolle)
In line with the precedent that in-game groups (e.g. Anti-Rain (Girls' Frontline)) can have gentags, I'm gauging opinions on the Kantai Collection history-specific teams with this BUR.
BUR #33521 has been rejected.
nuke pool:23776
nuke pool:23782
nuke pool:23802
Somebody's pet pools that should've been favgroups.
Obst said:
BUR #33521 has been rejected.
nuke pool:23776
nuke pool:23782
nuke pool:23802Somebody's pet pools that should've been favgroups.
Sent the user a message with the post IDs so go ahead and nuke these.
Obst said:
BUR #33521 has been rejected.
nuke pool:23776
nuke pool:23782
nuke pool:23802Somebody's pet pools that should've been favgroups.
Nuked these.
BUR #33676 is pending approval.
nuke pool:19352
Game CGs from Magia Record: Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica Gaiden.
NOTE: This pool only includes CGs in the more traditional understanding of the word. This does not include character cards, Memoria cards or other sprites that are considered "game CGs" on Danbooru.
Simple game_cg pool with a few arbitrary exclusions.
The problem with this idea is that, without the pool, it becomes very difficult to search for game CGs as traditionally defined. Search official art of any character from this game and you will be slapped with all kinds of card art first and foremost, and good luck sifting through if that's not what you're after.
What do you mean "arbitrary exclusions"? Magia Record has a lot of different types of in-game images that all can fall under game CG - memoria, card art, backgrounds, Witch sprites, doppel sprites, story CGs. This pool is only for the last one. How is it pointless to have a pool for this when it'd be impossible to search for them specifically otherwise?
I think this is something that would be better handled with a tag specifically for story CGs rather than a pool. There are other games that have the same issue, so it would be nice to have something that could be used for all of them.
I’m also skeptical of those 1komas being included in the pool. I get that they’re technically being used as story CGs in-game, but they still stick out quite a bit. I feel like it might be better for them to have their own pool.
If the order is important, then a series pool is justified. The problem is that the pool description does not say anything about this. The current description makes it sound like a random collection of in-game artwork. Nothing about it implies there’s any order to them. And not all users will understand what is meant by “traditional game CGs.” If these are scenes from the story, the pool description should make it clear. If they need to be in a certain order and it’s not obvious how to order them, then that should also be explained.
Whether this pool stays or goes, a tag would still be useful for distinguishing story art from other game cg posts.
