Provence said:
Yes.
Let's not water down the rating when you see the breast outline this clearly (almost impossible shirt) + rather intimate situation.
The breasts aren't emphasized any more than in post #5779780, and we had three users (including the one who changed the rating to G) agree it was not enough on its own (see forum #279334 and the posts below that). I do think other factors such as the thighs and presentation push this to S, especially considering we usually want to favor S over G in borderline posts.
Fundamentally, cameltoes start by being rated q. If there are mitigating aspects of the picture that loosens the rating, then they should be applied. I don't see that here, though.
Prominent cameltoes are Q and subtle cameltoes are S, as stated in howto:rate. In this case, the mitigating factors such as the crotch focus would push it from S to Q, not the other way around.
c_spl said:
if it's noticeable enough on the characters that make up the focus, yes, which applies to the first pic
I don't see cleavage on the 2nd pic though. there's noticeable breast outlines, but I'm unsure if it's enough to qualify for S
The amount of cleavage shown in both posts wouldn't be enough for G by itself, and neither post focuses on it. However, the dresses in the first post show a moderate amount of skin overall, which makes it appropriate for S. I don't believe the breast outlines are prominent enough in the second post for it to be rated S, so that should be fine to rate G.
