Artist-specific Patchoulies

BUR #29202 has been rejected.

create implication catchouli_(hazuki_ruu) -> patchouli_knowledge
create implication patchouli_knowledge_(crr001) -> patchouli_knowledge

Left them out of topic #28075 since i went unsure if it would apply to that topic. As NNT suggested to separate on different topics Cirno/Daiyousei and Keine cases.

Both are Patchouli Knowledge depictions by hazuki ruu and crr001 with cat and fox traits respectively, so I see no reason why not imply them to the main Patchouli tag

crr001's Patchouli have only 5 posts with three approved, but other artists drew on his design so I am unsure if tag + artist would suffice to just nuke instead implying, so I put it as well

EDIT: Precedents: topic #17867

BUR #29221 has been rejected.

create alias catchouli_(hazuki_ruu) -> patchouli_knowledge
create alias patchouli_knowledge_(crr001) -> patchouli_knowledge

I don't understand why we have these tags.

zetsubousensei said:

BUR #29221 has been rejected.

create alias catchouli_(hazuki_ruu) -> patchouli_knowledge
create alias patchouli_knowledge_(crr001) -> patchouli_knowledge

I don't understand why we have these tags.

For the same reasons we have puru-see_(hoshizuki_(seigetsu)), hata-tan_(rui_(hershe)), inu_sakuya_(nejikirio), ect. I assume.

patchouli_knowledge_(crr001) can probably be nuked though. It's three images from one artist, we don't need a tag for every artist interpretation, just the popular/prolific ones.

I would be for getting rid of those as well, I think if they are actually things people want grouped it should be a pool, especially since that Parsee for instance is all by a single artist save for 2 posts.

zetsubousensei said:

BUR #29221 has been rejected.

create alias catchouli_(hazuki_ruu) -> patchouli_knowledge
create alias patchouli_knowledge_(crr001) -> patchouli_knowledge

I don't understand why we have these tags.

I still would keep Catchouli on own tag implying Patchouli, as it falls on same place of Inu Sakuya (Thumb of Rule: For none or for all, no exceptions, or else we will ever be under this fight to take subjectiveness).

If we can all agree crr001 Patchouli is a useless tag, a nuke (or manual removal) should suffice.

patchouli_knowledge_(crr001)'s design has actually been drawn by different artists (post #6680065, post #6611089). Meanwhile catchouli (hazuki ruu) looks nothing like the original design in posts from other artists (post #1222371, post #4437712, post #3285268, post #1293872 all have different designs). It's the opposite, the first should be kept and the second should be nuked.

nonamethanks said:
patchouli_knowledge_(crr001)'s design has actually been drawn by different artists (post #6680065, post #6611089)

I can understand keeping Catchouli since that's more of a fan-character but wouldn't this just be crr001 (style) + style parody?

I don't understand why we have these tags at all.

I'm not gonna go make nicole_demara_(kinkymation) because the artist has drawn several images of the character with cat ears, even if someone else started doing it.

Feels like Touhou being a weird holdout of oldbooru practices again.

If it's a specific design that's uniquely identifiable it should have a tag.

Narehate said:

I can understand keeping Catchouli since that's more of a fan-character but wouldn't this just be crr001 (style) + style parody?

Which one are you talking about here? Which design in particular? Because they all look different and amount to just "Patchouli, but with cat ears". That's not a specific design.

This bulk update request is pending automatic rejection in 5 days.

The bulk update request #29221 (forum #295753) has been rejected by @nonamethanks.

The bulk update request #29202 (forum #295700) has been rejected by @nonamethanks.