Donmai

Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

Posted under General

ILikeBuffGirls123

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7426505?q=user%3AILikeBuffGirls123+status%3Adeleted

Hello, mods. Maki Lover here. Can anyone perchance check this again? For the glory of girl abs of course.

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6937315?q=user%3AILikeBuffGirls123+status%3Adeleted

And this is a while ago but was wondering still why this Mirko one wasn't approved since it's pretty good if I say so myself.

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/6698655?q=user%3AILikeBuffGirls123+status%3Adeleted

And this not getting approved is somewhat heretical IMO but I won't say anything to the Commissar if you approve it!

Reply
Mayhem-Chan

sidbarrett said:

Hello, could you please review this post again? Please give them a second chance.
post #7426794

I doubt anyone's gonna approve this one, it just doesn't look great

sidbarrett said:

An approver and a contributor appealed 2 posts I published. Could you please review them?
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts?tags=user%3Asidbarrett+status%3Aappealed

If it's already appealed just let things happen, this is a thread for feedback on deletions, not for review/appeal requests

alphasigmaevolved said:

What's wrong with:

https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7388527?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3Aalphasigmaevolved
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7429941?q=status%3Adeleted+user%3Aalphasigmaevolved

First is a third-party edit, second has no comprehensive source

KoakumaBR said:

What 's wrong with post #7429709

Anatomy

MarqFJA87 said:

What is wrong with post #7409306?

Anatomy + perspective

gunupmyskirt said:

post #7427196
post #7427254
post #7427338
post #7427371
post #7427762

These aren't deleted yet but I am a bit perturbed because I feel like they are going to be. My posts are not usually in the approval stage for so long unless they are going to be deleted, so I was actually wondering if there was something different about these from my others.

Next time, wait until a post is actually deleted before asking here. I understand the worry when you're not used to having a post stay without approval for too long but many posts that get approved do in their 3rd day right before time is out; Also this thread is for deleted posts

NobodyReally101 said:

Based on other images which have been accepted, I do not understand the deletion of these (the last two in particular):
post #7418755
post #7400990
post #7401011
post #7381334
post #7378774

And then, were these too low res or too much text?
post #7400977
post #7418802
post #7404808

It boils down to poor anatomy, except for post #7404808 which is just a blurry/artifacted low-res pic from a third party source, that's too borderline to have any real probability to get approved

MF144 said:

What's wrong with these posts?
post #6878436
post #7361487
post #7415232
post #7411172
post #7412790
post #7412799
post #7297778

Poor quality or anatomy in general.
post #7411172 is the best looking one here imo
And stuff like post #7297778 has no chance to get approved here

Reply
Nacha

MF144 said:

What's wrong with these?
post #7432582
post #7157051
post #7427814
post #7424587
post #7428096
post #7422736
post #7406307
post #7422707
post #7422714
post #7422729
post #7386464
post #7415232
post #7412799
post #7371914
post #7157051
post #7420169
post #7412790

Please concentrace on less images when asking for feedback. You even added post #7157051 two times, because you don't have an overview yourself if you add too many pictures.
Some have a really poor anatomy like post #7371914 others have smaller mistakes that ruin the whole image like post #7420169. I approved two that I think are fine.

Reply
reg panda

minnazzo said:

my reupload: https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7347803 (didn't get approved)
self approved reupload: https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/7437572
hmmmmmmmm

In general, if there is a pixiv version of the image, you shouldn't upload the twitter version of the image. The pixiv version usually has more pixels, and png compressed instead of jpg.

Check for Duplicates
Be sure that your post has not been uploaded by someone else. When uploading an image, a list of similar images will appear at the bottom of the page.

If your image has already been uploaded, only upload if you have a higher quality copy. Once you have uploaded your higher quality copy, set all existing copies of the image as child posts of your copy.

help:upload

Reply
Crazos

reg_panda said:

I made them parent and child now. If you appeal it, saying "finished version of post #7169763" or something like that, I think they'll approve it, a better version of an approved post usually gets approved.

how do i appeal? i thinked that only moderators can do that

Reply
Laudividni

Crazos said:

how do i appeal? i thinked that only moderators can do that

Scroll down a status:deleted post and you'll see an "appeal" option in the left bar. Any user can appeal deleted posts at the cost of three upload slots for each appeal, until a post gets approved or deleted, but the same user can only appeal the same post once.

Reply
1 359 360 361 362 363 364 365 366 367 488